The Plot Against America makes for stark viewing in uncertain times

David Simon and Ed Burns’ HBO series imagines an alternate reality that suddenly feels frighteningly close to home.


Roxanne Sancto


In their latest venture into the HBO sphere, The Wire co-writers David Simon and Ed Burns abandon the streets of Baltimore once again, this time in exploration of an alternate American reality – one in which Germany wins World War Two. As the American people watch scenes of Hitler dancing through the ruins of what was once Paris – like a “happy Putz” – the close-knit Jewish community of Newark is starting to feel nervous.

The Levin family are living a life of 1940s luxury compared to many others still struggling to make ends meet. Where the corner boys’ warning call “5:0!” dominated the streets of The Wire, the children of The Plot Against America announce the arrival of their fathers after a long day’s work with “car!” By drawing attention to these upper-class nuances, Minkie Spiro, director of the premiere episode, sets us up for what’s to come. Over the course of one night, individual and institutional racism spikes by several degrees, and the life families like the Levins have painstakingly built over many years are about to change drastically.

Adapted from Philip Roth’s 2004 novel of the same name, The Plot Against America imagines a Trump-esque figure running for the US presidency against Franklin D Roosevelt. Xenophobic populist Charles Lindbergh (Ben Cole) turns the general population against Jewish and British communities, insisting on their being war-agitators, and threatening deportation. All the while, news channels show footage of Jewish men, women, and children being shipped off to concentration camps in Hitler’s Germany.

While Herman Levin (Morgan Spector) and the neighbouring men air their frustrations and fears on the stoop, his wife Bess (Zoe Kazan) tries her best to keep this sense of mounting dread from their teenaged sons Sandy (Caleb Malis) and the much younger Philip (Azhy Robertson). Spector and Kazan’s on-screen chemistry feels natural. It’s easy for the audience to feel comfortable with the Levin family, to become enthralled by their multigenerational dinner settings and their concerns regarding the state of the world and how to protect their children and other relatives from it.

Perhaps the most intriguing story arc in the show’s premiere episode is Philip’s gradual exposure to an adult world and feelings of otherness he was previously sheltered from. From questions of justice and morality surrounding his uncle’s shady friends and pastimes, to recognising and feeling intimidated by the worldliness of other kids his age, it seems Philip is suddenly looking at a whole new world. Robertson’s performance is unforced, awakening a parental instinct in the viewer – one that wants to preserve his innocence and stop his wide-eyed wonder from turning into a picture of constant terror.

Like other recent dystopian dramas such as The Handmaid’s Tale, The Plot Against America is zooming in on the surrealism of time and existence. How, from one day to the next, the hateful clown wreaking havoc in the circus that is society can convert an entire country through television screens and radio waves, changing the world as we know it forever and for the worse. It’s a study in how different parties react to sudden changes in the political climate, and how to prepare a new generation for an uncertain future without unintentionally manipulating their present.

Published 17 Mar 2020

Tags: Adolf Hitler David Simon Donald Trump Ed Burns John Turturro The Plot Against America

Suggested For You

End Times – How America’s war machine perpetuates a false threat to liberty

By Forrest Cardamenis

In the first of a series of essays on Obama Era Cinema, Forrest Cardamenis counts the toll of US foreign policy during Barack Obama’s presidency.

A brief history of America according to the Coen brothers

By Paul Risker

Hail, Caesar! is the latest entry into the directors’ career-long reframing of their country’s storied past.

Feed, The War Room and the awkward reality of American politics

By Alex Chambers

How two early ’90s documentaries exposed the media machinery that helps determine US elections.

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.