How Smithereens captured the scuzzy charm of post-punk New York

Susan Seidelman’s debut feature is an unflinching portrait of the city’s underground scene.


Shane O’Reilly

Susan Seidelman’s lo-fi New York debut, Smithereens, not only defined the director’s early career, serving as a precursor to her better-known Desperately Seeking Susan, it was also one of the defining post-punk films of the era. The film exists today as a time capsule of pre-gentrification New York. Every shot is caked in urban decay, with the city featuring almost as a central character alongside daydreaming punk protagonist Wren (played with relish by Susan Berman).

Released in 1982, the film coincided with new albums by Bad Religion, Flipper, Bad Brains and Descendents. While punk was being quickly laid to rest in the UK thanks to the emergence of synth-based electro-pop, the US clung on thanks in part to legendary venues such as New York’s CBGBs. The same year saw the release of several films similar in both tone and spirit to Smithereens: punk porno Café Flesh; revenge drama Class of 1984; berserko sci-fi Liquid Sky; and punk musical Ladies and Gentlemen, The Fabulous Stains, starring – of all people – Diane Lane.

Smithereens’ spunky, never-take-no-for-an-answer heroine is in many ways a precursor to Madonna’s famous role as Susan Thomas, with certain character traits filtering through to Ann Magnuson’s Frankie Stone in Seidelman’s 1987 film Making Mr Right and later Emily Lloyd’s Cookie Voltecki in 1989’s Cookie.

At first Wren is likeable enough, but as the film unfolds her true colours begin to show. She’s a user. Not of drugs but of people, constantly running her mouth and attempting to fleece strangers. This is a story of survival, and Wren is the film’s street-smart, tough-talking, gum-chewing heart. There’s something at once charming and intriguing about her. After all, who doesn’t love a chancer?

It’s not long before Wren’s path crosses two very different men, Eric (real-life rocker Richard Hell essentially playing himself) and Paul (Brad Rinn), whose interest in Wren is spurned by her obvious attraction to Eric, the slouchy bad boy of the piece. Thankfully Smithereens doesn’t segue into an Eric versus Paul scenario. Wren’s quest for success and self-improvement remains at the fore as she bounces around NYC, grafting and hustling. But Hell’s character is a tricky mark. It’s clear he has his own agenda.

Nothing goes quite to plan for Wren. Her destructive fling with Eric is little more than a fantasy she initially liked the sound of and sold to herself. In reality, Eric is only out for himself and has no intention of leaving the city without first lining his pockets. He drags Wren down with him while she continues to rebuff Paul. By the end of the film, Wren has burned all her bridges with her habitual freeloading and unfulfilled promises. The city starts to chew her up. So she hits the road.

It’s hard to imagine anyone in the real world tolerating Wren for more than five minutes, but Berman’s engaging performance carries the entire film. It’s hardly surprising that it became her calling card, although after Smithereens her acting opportunities were limited before she finally landed one last bit part in 1993’s Bikini Carwash Company II. As New York became increasingly gentrified, it swallowed up Berman just as it had Wren.

After the success of Desperately Seeking Susan, Seidelman gradually pulled away from independent cinema, and over the course of the next decade she reestablished herself in television, eventually directing the pilot episode of Sex and the City in 1998. But it all started with that raw but fully realised 1982 debut, driven by two incredibly talented women: a young filmmaker who poured her love of an underground scene into one of its defining portraits; and an actor who made her mark in style and disappeared almost as suddenly as she appeared.

Smithereens is released on Blu-ray on 27 August via The Criterion Collection.

Published 27 Aug 2018

Tags: Punk Susan Seidelman

Suggested For You

The further dimensions of Desperately Seeking Susan

By Leigh Clark

Does Madonna’s iconic pyramid jacket contain a hidden message?

Jim Jarmusch: ‘The spirit of punk is even more valuable now than ever’

By Zach Lewis

The indie idol discusses Paterson, the musicality of movies and how Man Ray made films for his band to play along to.

A brief guide to punks on film

By David Hayles

From Repo Man to the Class of 1984, here are seven memorable examples of anarchy on the big screen.

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.