The Duke of Burgundy and the mysterious language… | Little White Lies

The Duke of Bur­gundy and the mys­te­ri­ous lan­guage of love

20 Feb 2015

Dark-haired person lying on mossy ground, eyes closed, warm lighting.
Dark-haired person lying on mossy ground, eyes closed, warm lighting.
Despite its les­bian and lep­i­doptera themes, Peter Strickland’s rela­tion­ship dra­ma is anchored by uni­ver­sal truths about domes­tic role-play.

Peter Strickland’s The Duke of Bur­gundy is many things: sen­su­al erot­i­ca; pro­gres­sive LGBT cin­e­ma; even roman­tic com­e­dy. But the most pow­er­ful sto­ry it tells is about two indi­vid­u­als and their oppos­ing lan­guages of love.

Cyn­thia (Sidse Babett Knud­sen) and Eve­lyn (Chiara D’Anna) live togeth­er in a ridicu­lous­ly opu­lent house in an unspec­i­fied Euro­pean vil­lage pop­u­lat­ed only by women. Strick­land doesn’t touch upon explana­to­ry details. His focus is pure and height­ened and fixed on the way the two women interrelate.

Their spe­cif­ic dilem­ma is how to rec­on­cile Evelyn’s masochism with Cynthia’s more tra­di­tion­al tastes. Their strug­gle iso­lates the ongo­ing issue that indi­vid­u­als with­in cou­ples face: how to please both them­selves and their lover. A poignant but humourous scene shows a dec­la­ra­tion of love impa­tient­ly shot down in favour of dirty talk. There is a point to which this type of clash is inevitable and a point to which it is gra­tu­itous­ly painful and a klax­on call for part­ing. Strick­land brings to life a rela­tion­ship where the love is not gone but pain — in and out of S&M role-play — is an ongo­ing under­cur­rent that con­stant­ly reframes our under­stand­ing of how these women are coping.

Strick­land uses a spe­cif­ic, cin­e­mat­i­cal­ly reward­ing and sen­su­al type of domes­tic set-up to explore pow­er, but the strug­gle between gen­er­ous love and per­son­al need is uni­ver­sal. The nature of life is there’s always some­thing that has to be sac­ri­ficed…. When I think of peo­ple that I know there’s always some­one who has to com­pro­mise,” Strick­land said in a recent inter­view with LWLies.

Strick­land has cit­ed Ger­man new wave direc­tor Rain­er Wern­er Fass­binder as an inspi­ra­tion, specif­i­cal­ly his 1975 film Fox and his Friends. When Fass­binder brings his boyfriend to din­ner his par­ents don’t even ques­tion it,” explains Strick­land. In the late 70s it was always about accep­tance when you bring the boyfriend over for din­ner. But in Fox and His Friends it was just like bring­ing your girl­friend for din­ner. They spoke about oth­er things.” The Duke of Bur­gundy has tak­en the lead of its inspi­ra­tion. It is so earnest­ly at the core of a love quandary that it is not about the par­tic­u­lars of sexuality.

Anoth­er Ger­man named Rain­er elo­quent­ly expressed a solu­tion to dis­con­nec­tion in cou­ples. Poet Rain­er Maria Rilke wrote: Once the real­i­sa­tion is accept­ed that even between the clos­est peo­ple infi­nite dis­tances exist, a mar­vel­lous liv­ing side-by-side can grow up for them.” While this is a salve for a cer­tain lev­el of benign sep­a­ra­tion, there is a type of dis­tance that lends itself more to pain, doubt and mad­ness than any­thing like mar­vel. The com­mu­nion-sep­a­ra­tion bal­ance has to be deter­mined by indi­vid­u­als, rather than a cou­ple hive-mind. A cou­ple can only func­tion when two peo­ple are in har­mo­nious accord over the state of their togeth­er­ness. In The Duke of Bur­gundy the cam­era lingers on the women’s faces sep­a­rate­ly as fre­quent­ly as it pho­tographs them togeth­er, search­ing sto­ical per­for­mances for clues as to per­son­al happiness.

Sidse Bab­bett Knudesen’s soft voice imbues Cyn­thia with melan­choly as she ful­fils her role and orders her sub to per­form domes­tic chores. She sits alone at a type­writer or alone in front of a mir­ror, nev­er ful­ly con­vinced by her task, huge eyes flit­ting rest­less­ly and unsee­ing­ly. As Eve­lyn, Chiara D’Anna also seems caught in rever­ies. Eve­lyn wash­es Cynthia’s ele­gant satin under­wear hyp­no­tised by the rain­bow pat­terns that dance across the suds. She is slack­ing off her flesh and blood part­ner in favour of per­son­al fan­tasies. Despite the women being each other’s sole human con­tact, imag­i­na­tion nudges them apart.

The pow­er imbal­ance here is that one woman is act­ing for her­self while the oth­er acts for her loved one. The film is a slow sub­mer­gence in the ques­tion of whether Cyn­thia will accept pow­er bal­ance for the sake of Eve­lyn. What hap­pens when inequal­i­ty is accept­ed in the name of love and desire? Sam Taylor-Johnson’s Fifty Shades of Grey explores the same ques­tion from two con­flict­ing points of view. Talk­ing about his for­ma­tive years as a sub’, Chris­t­ian Grey says, When I gave up con­trol I felt free from respon­si­bil­i­ty and deci­sion-mak­ing. I felt safe.”

Sub­mis­sion bequeathed him a cocoon away from the storms of soci­ety. Anas­ta­sia Steele is not as con­vinced of the ben­e­fits of aban­don­ing her free will. The strength of her iden­ti­ty is pro­tec­tion for her and a phe­nom­e­non for him in that it offers a depar­ture from the famil­iar pat­terns of S&M pow­er play. It is ter­ri­fy­ing for him to go off-script, off-cue and sim­ply fol­low feel­ings. Her pow­er is his weak­ness and vice ver­sa. When sex­u­al tastes are in oppo­si­tion, love becomes a bat­tle for dom­i­nance. As for who will come out on top, Fass­binder offered the fol­low­ing view:

The one who loves or loves more is obvi­ous­ly the infe­ri­or one in the rela­tion­ship. This is to do with the fact that the one who loves less has more pow­er, obviously.”

Strickland’s style is gen­tler and more abstract than his Ger­man fore­bear. Cyn­thia and Eve­lyn try to side­step pow­er issues in order to live side-by-side. They cycle togeth­er, sleep togeth­er and fuel lep­i­dopter­ist obses­sions togeth­er. Amid the dusky light and deca­dent fur­nish­ings of their man­sion, Nicholas D Knowland’s sen­su­al cin­e­matog­ra­phy cap­tures the shared life they try to snatch from the jaws of their war­ring predilec­tions. Cyn­thia inch­es her skirt up as Eve­lyn kneels at her feet. We hear the cloth scratch­ing against her stock­ings, Strick­land fram­ing the point of fric­tion in inti­mate close-up. This is the camera’s way of evok­ing Cynthia’s sen­si­tiv­i­ty to the sharp­ened focus of her lover’s charged gaze. S&M nev­er seemed so mer­ci­ful and compassionate.

Eve­lyn is either not will­ing or not able to be as flex­i­ble with love’s lan­guage. She is a slave to her desires, child-like and id-dri­ven, whis­per­ing her dis­dain at a but­ter­fly lec­ture and sus­cep­ti­ble to anoth­er woman who shares her bed­room tastes. (Could stream­lined taste be more of a deter­min­er of cou­ple­dom than attach­ments forged on emo­tion­al grounds?)

Some­times Cynthia’s role seems more like a care-giv­er than a lover. The nar­ra­tive pro­gress­es to Cat’s Eyes’ oth­er­world­ly sounds and engage­ment with the abstract realm of emo­tion­al deci­sions height­ens. Will she sur­ren­der her iden­ti­ty to serve her lover’s insa­tiable sex­u­al appetite? Or are the forces of self-preser­va­tion more pow­er­ful than love? And if wil­ful love can’t keep peo­ple togeth­er, what on Earth can?

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.