How Network predicted the insidious rise of ‘fake… | Little White Lies

In Praise Of

How Net­work pre­dict­ed the insid­i­ous rise of fake news’

28 Nov 2016

Words by Edward Cripps

A man in a coat shouting with a look of desperation, surrounded by clocks.
A man in a coat shouting with a look of desperation, surrounded by clocks.
Sid­ney Lumet’s prophet­ic 1976 satire warned of the moral ero­sion of main­stream media 40 years ago.

Released 40 years ago this month, Sid­ney Lumet’s pitch-black media satire Net­work antic­i­pat­ed the rise of Fox News, Mail Online, Don­ald Trump and the insid­i­ous con­ver­gence of real­i­ty TV and pol­i­tics, as well as pop­ulist prophets like Rus­sell Brand and Katie Hop­kins. An acrid tragi­com­e­dy of oper­at­ic pro­por­tions, its appar­ent pre­science has only grown in the time since its orig­i­nal release back in 1976. Lumet drew on his ear­ly TV expe­ri­ence to bring the para­ble of Howard Beale (Peter Finch) to life for the big screen. The film tells of a sacked news­read­er who vows to kill him­self live on air – The first known instance of a man killed because he had lousy ratings.”

Exploiter-in-chief here is glassy pro­duc­er Diana (a career-best Faye Dun­away). When she first hears of Beale’s plan to kill him­self, her instinct is to make a show out of it. After suc­cess­ful­ly pitch­ing Sui­cide of the Week’ to the execs of the fic­tion­al Unit­ed Broad­cast­ing Sys­tem, a night­ly slot is devot­ed to Beale’s increas­ing­ly unhinged rants. Her amoral­i­ty is can­ni­bal­is­tic (“I eat any­thing,” she hiss­es in one par­tic­u­lar­ly mem­o­rable scene) and even sex is stewed with ambi­tion: she gives her­self an orgasm rat­tling off the network’s view­ing fig­ures and palms off a lover who tries to kiss her while she’s watch­ing TV in bed. The jux­ta­po­si­tion of cor­po­rate dou­ble-speak with casu­al vio­lence is grim­ly fun­ny. One exec pon­ders, Should we kill Howard Beale or not? I’d like to hear some more opin­ions on that.”

Vot­ed among the top 10 scripts of all time by two Amer­i­can writ­ers’ guilds, Pad­dy Chayefsky’s dia­logue is at once potent, pre­scient and the­atri­cal with­out ever feel­ing over­ly hys­ter­i­cal or stagy (Beale’s why me?” visions, the far­ci­cal use of psy­chics on Wall St, a sooth­say­er who claims to know the next day’s news). Each char­ac­ter deliv­ers some bleak­ly pro­found turns-of-phrase, such as when Beale rails against the dement­ed slaugh­ter­house of a world we live in.” Like Don Quixote or King Lear, his is a semi-per­sua­sive mid­dle-aged mad­ness for whom death is a per­cep­ti­ble thing with defin­able fea­tures” and whose rat­ings dip, depress­ing­ly, the more rea­son­ably he behaves. He bab­bles to William Holden’s news pres­i­dent Max, an old friend, that he’s imbued with some spe­cial spir­it. It’s not a reli­gious feel­ing at all; it’s a shock­ing erup­tion of great elec­tri­cal ener­gy. I feel vivid and flash­ing as though I’ve been plugged into some great elec­tro-mag­net­ic field.”

Max him­self is ful­ly aware of his own arti­fi­cial­i­ty: in a row with his wife, he acknowl­edges, here we are, going through the oblig­a­tory mid­dle-of-Act-Two scorned wife throws hus­band out’ scene.” Most sat­is­fy­ing­ly for the view­er, Max resists Diana’s heart­less tyran­ny. This is not a script, Diana… Decay­ing love is the only thing between you and the shriek­ing noth­ing­ness you live the rest of the day…. You’re tele­vi­sion incar­nate, Diana. Indif­fer­ent to suf­fer­ing; insen­si­tive to joy. All is reduced to the com­mon rub­ble of banal­i­ty. Every­thing you touch dies with you, but not me.” By the end, television’s cur­rents have cor­rod­ed them all.

Since its release, Net­work has been hostage to its own eeri­ly prophet­ic real-life rever­ber­a­tions, the sad­dest of which was Peter Finch’s death in Jan­u­ary 1977 which denied him the oppor­tu­ni­ty to col­lect his Best Actor Oscar. But now its influ­ence rages on in satires as var­ied as The Lar­ry Sanders Show, The Play­er, The Tru­man Show, Mag­no­lia, UnRE­AL and Black Mir­ror (espe­cial­ly Bing’s mon­e­tised rant in X Fac­tor pas­tiche 15 Mil­lion Mer­its’). Some­how, it man­aged to seem­ing­ly fore­shad­ow almost every aspect of mod­ern life: the sado-voyeuris­tic, vam­pir­ic drip-drip of increas­ing­ly inva­sive real­i­ty TV, the mis­placed right­eous­ness of pro­duc­ers, the ubiq­ui­ty of adver­tis­ing, the obso­les­cence of pri­va­cy, sui­cide videos, and the dan­ger­ous ascent of self-appoint­ed social com­men­ta­tors like Alex Jones, a one-time fringe con­spir­a­cy the­o­rist and beat poet of para­noia” whom pres­i­dent-elect Trump has quot­ed in his speeches.

If you’ve nev­er seen Net­work before, there’s nev­er been a bet­ter time to watch it. It might be the best film-about-tele­vi­sion ever made, its genius man­i­fest in Beale’s famous mad as hell” melt­down but also more sub­tly in the way it fore­saw TV’s rabid poten­tial, the unchecked vorac­i­ty of those who have exploit­ed it for their own per­son­al gain. How apt that a counter-cul­ture icon­o­clast like Sid­ney Lumet sig­nalled the appro­pri­a­tion of the anti-estab­lish­ment move­ment by anoth­er, even more potent icon­o­clast for just the greedy, destruc­tive ends he warned us about.

You might like