The films of Martin Scorsese – ranked | Little White Lies

Top Ranking

The films of Mar­tin Scors­ese – ranked

09 Jan 2017

Two men wearing casual clothing in an outdoor setting with a colourful background.
Two men wearing casual clothing in an outdoor setting with a colourful background.
A com­pre­hen­sive guide to the direct­ing cred­its of this great Amer­i­can auteur, from Mean Streets to The King of Com­e­dy to Killers of the Flower Moon.

Mar­tin Scors­ese is a film­mak­er who requires no intro­duc­tion, his stag­ger­ing con­tri­bu­tion to Amer­i­can cin­e­ma hav­ing been the sub­ject of count­less stud­ies and ret­ro­spec­tives over the years. He is, to put it in plain Eng­lish, one of the all-time greats. To cel­e­brate the extra­or­di­nary career of this mas­ter direc­tor, we’ve under­tak­en the mam­moth task of revis­it­ing and rank­ing his entire fil­mog­ra­phy, from the ear­ly, less­er-seen works right through to his most revered cin­e­mat­ic mile­stones and every­thing in between. Check out the full list below, then share your per­son­al Scors­ese Top 10 with us @LWLies.

Scors­ese teams up with Robert De Niro, Leonar­do DiCaprio and Brad Pitt for an extend­ed com­mer­cial for a Macau casi­no. The flim­sy plot cen­tres on Bob­by and Leo’s com­pe­ti­tion for the lead in Marty’s next pic­ture; the actors play­ing vain, bick­er­ing ver­sions of them­selves. With Ter­ence Winter’s script made up entire­ly of ter­mi­nal­ly unfun­ny ban­ter, only Scors­ese walks away with his dig­ni­ty intact – in front of the cam­era, that is (the direc­tion amounts to a pile-up of CG-aug­ment­ed cliché). The price of said dig­ni­ty? $13m apiece for a week’s work. Fair enough. Matt Thrift

This 20-minute puff piece on fash­ion design­er Gior­gio Armani is notable for mark­ing the first col­lab­o­ra­tion between Scors­ese and Jay Cocks, who would go on to write the screen­plays for The Age of Inno­cence, Gangs of New York and Silence. Avail­able on a com­pendi­um DVD com­pris­ing Scorsese’s short films, it’s worth seek­ing out, but only if you have a pen­chant for uncharis­mat­ic, immac­u­late­ly-tai­lored Milanese elites. Adam Wood­ward

A 24-minute episode made for Steven Spielberg’s huge­ly hyped series, Amaz­ing Sto­ries: Mir­ror, Mir­ror all but col­laps­es under the weight of its com­pet­ing impuls­es. Work­ing from a cute con­cept by Spiel­berg, After Hours scribe Joseph Min­ion brings lit­tle to the table in psy­cho­log­i­cal terms (the brevi­ty of the for­mat an appar­ent mill­stone), while a bland Sam Water­ston – as the writer haunt­ed by a loom­ing killer every time he looks in the mir­ror – offers few clues as to the point of a bite­size moral­i­ty play in the Tales From the Crypt mode. MT

Scors­ese returned to the mean streets of New York for the pilot of Vinyl, a 70s-set HBO series cen­tred on music mogul Richie Fines­tra (Bob­by Can­navale). Sad­ly, the script’s lack of direc­tion means not even the impec­ca­ble sound­track or trade­mark bursts of extreme vio­lence man­age to make the fea­ture-length episode more than mild­ly enter­tain­ing – large­ly due to the sense that Robert De Niro and Har­vey Keitel’s Mean Streets char­ac­ters could well be up to no good just off cam­era. The show was recent­ly can­celled after just one sea­son. Jacob Stol­wor­thy

Though bare­ly dis­trib­uted, Scorsese’s urgent, sear­ing debut fea­ture Who’s That Knock­ing at My Door did won­ders for the rep­u­ta­tion of its then 25-year-old direc­tor – not to men­tion its break­out star, Har­vey Kei­t­el. By con­trast his fol­low-up, Box­car Bertha, arriv­ing five years lat­er, did lit­tle to sug­gest that Scors­ese was the real deal. A rough-hewn Bon­nie and Clyde knock off, the scuzzy fin­ger­prints of pop pro­duc­er extra­or­di­naire Roger Cor­man are all over this down and dirty pic­ture. Less so Scorsese’s, who was very much a gun-for-hire here. One for Mar­ty com­pletists only. AW

A group of people standing in a city street, some wearing winter coats and one person in a dark-coloured coat.

With Michael Jackson’s schnoz mak­ing glob­al head­lines in the mid-’80s, it’s fit­ting that the title video from the superstar’s 1987 album would prove to be so on-the-nose. Writ­ten by Richard Clock­ers” Price, the full 18-minute cut of Scorsese’s film may be the singer’s most forth­right attempt at con­fronting ques­tions of racial iden­ti­ty before he took a sledge­ham­mer to sub­tle­ty in the ear­ly 90s with Black or White’, but there’s lit­tle escap­ing the camp cre­den­tials of a leather-clad riff on West Side Sto­ry. The biggest pop cul­ture icon on the plan­et gets out-charisma’d by an unknown Wes­ley Snipes in a role that was orig­i­nal­ly intend­ed for Prince, whose com­ments on the mat­ter sum things up rather nice­ly. MT

It speaks vol­umes that Scorsese’s first ever for­ay into film­mak­ing focused on per­haps his most inno­cent pro­tag­o­nist. This nine-minute com­e­dy short was made while Scors­ese stud­ied at New York University’s Tisch School of Arts in 1963 and fol­lows a writer who grows obsessed with a pic­ture on his wall. Fran­tic from the get go, the film is an unashamed merg­ing of Buñuel and Bergman while the mind-bend­ing cli­max intrigu­ing­ly sug­gests Scorsese’s career path almost veered in a total­ly dif­fer­ent direc­tion. Still, the film’s over­ar­ch­ing mantra – Life is fraught with per­il” – could apply to near­ly all of the director’s films to have fol­lowed. JS

While it cer­tain­ly has more going for it than Scorsese’s more recent stab at TV pilot­ing, the debut episode of Board­walk Empire is beset by the same prob­lems – name­ly, the need to get enough plates in the air so they can keep spin­ning for a fur­ther 50-odd episodes. Watch­ing it, you get the sense that Scors­ese is lend­ing lit­tle more than the most super­fi­cial aspects of his brand to pro­ceed­ings. Despite cost­ing a report­ed $18m, the lev­el of his­tor­i­cal accu­ra­cy is below that of the director’s supe­ri­or peri­od pieces. Still, a lead role for Steve Busce­mi can nev­er be an entire­ly bad thing. MT

A six-minute short pro­duced for the 911 fundrais­er, A Con­cert for New York City, the film sees Scors­ese take to the streets of Lit­tle Italy for a whistlestop tour of the area in which he grew up. The film serves as a brief cel­e­bra­tion of the area’s shift­ing eth­nic demo­graph­ics over the years, as Scors­ese offers both fond rem­i­nis­cence and con­tem­po­rary por­trait of a neigh­bour­hood in which a large Chi­nese com­mu­ni­ty coex­ists with the rem­nants of its Ital­ian pre­de­ces­sors. A tri­fle, per­haps, but an affec­tion­ate, micro­cos­mic glimpse nonethe­less of a social land­scape forged by its immi­grant pop­u­la­tion. MT

While show­cas­ing many seeds Scors­ese would go onto plant in his own films – there’s musi­cal num­bers (New York, New York), gang­sters (Good­fel­las) and loqua­cious nar­ra­tion (here’s look­ing at you, Jor­dan Belfort), this sec­ond short of Marty’s impor­tant­ly high­lights what so influ­enced the man to pick up a cam­era in the first place (this short’s end­ing in par­tic­u­lar direct­ly riffs off Fellini’s 8 ½). For that rea­son alone, it’s an essen­tial work. JS

Three men in suits and hats engaged in a conversation, with one man handing another a document.

Shut­ter Island is all about trick­ery. An adap­ta­tion of Den­nis Lehane’s nov­el, it tracks US Mar­shal Ted­dy Daniels (Leonar­do DiCaprio) as he inves­ti­gates the dis­ap­pear­ance of a patient from a hos­pi­tal for the crim­i­nal­ly insane. Through evoca­tive imagery and bla­tant homage (Shock Cor­ri­dor is clear­ly his sub­ject), Scors­ese lay­ers this mind-bend­ing thriller with inten­tion­al­ly ambigu­ous over­tones so as to throw us off the scent. But is Shut­ter Island an under­rat­ed entry into the director’s canon or is it emblem­at­ic of Scors­ese rest­ing on his lau­rels? Whichev­er way you lean, one thing that can be said is that no two views are the same. JS

Tight and imper­son­al, Andrew Lau’s Infer­nal Affairs got its busi­ness done in 100-min­utes. For his remake, Scors­ese adds the best part of an hour, large­ly fail­ing to cohe­sive­ly fuse nar­ra­tive con­cerns with the Oedi­pal­ly-rid­den weight of his lofti­er the­mat­ic ideals. Mark Wahlberg took the lion’s share of plau­dits – and an Oscar nom­i­na­tion – but the best per­for­mance here belongs to Matt Damon in the film’s least showy part; wit­ness the caught-red-hand­ed scene with Vera Farmi­ga (sad­dled with a thank­less role). Sad­ly it seems that even Scors­ese couldn’t tame Jack Nichol­son, who – even when he’s not wav­ing a dil­do around – read­i­ly serves up slice after slice of grade‑A ham. MT

Hav­ing placed the spot­light on Bob Dylan for doc­u­men­tary No Direc­tion Home six years pre­vi­ous, Scors­ese turned his sights to The Bea­t­les – more specif­i­cal­ly George Har­ri­son – with this unpar­al­leled glimpse into the life of who was often the unsung genius in the cor­ner. Devel­oped along­side Harrison’s wid­ow Olivia, the ten­der con­tri­bu­tions – rang­ing from sur­viv­ing Bea­t­les Paul McCart­ney and Ringo Starr to fel­low musi­cians Eric Clap­ton, Jeff Lynne and Tom Pet­ty – make this an essen­tial, if a lit­tle lan­guorous, delve into the life of arguably the great­est Bea­t­le. JS

A man shaves in the bath­room mir­ror. Once fin­ished, he lath­ers up and shaves again. Blood pours from his face. He slits his throat to the strains of a caden­za – I Can’t Get Start­ed’ – impo­tence and masochism. Unnec­es­sary action result­ing in unnec­es­sary blood­shed, tak­en to self-fla­gel­lat­ing extrem­i­ty. 1968: brute force and blunt alle­go­ry. A cred­it reads, White­ness by Her­man Melville’ – Viet­nam anoth­er elu­sive white whale; a direct, final title card dri­ving the point home. Or all just films school lols symp­to­matic of an overindul­gent art­house diet? MT

Whether or not you enjoy Pub­lic Speak­ing will like­ly depend on your capac­i­ty to with­stand the rat-a-tat com­ic pat­ter of Fran Lebowitz, the feisty sub­ject of Scorsese’s 2010 docu-pro­file. The sar­don­ic New York­er is cer­tain­ly on uncom­pro­mis­ing form here, yet the film’s casu­al tone at least eas­es us into the con­ver­sa­tion. As Lebowitz sets the world to rights, you can’t help but think of anoth­er strong-willed, anti-estab­lish­ment Scors­ese pro­tag­o­nist. Inci­den­tal­ly, she also hap­pens to dri­ve a che­quered cab. AW

A woman with blonde hair wearing a white dress and belt, sitting in a dimly lit room.

Or: Mar­tin Scorsese’s A Series of Unfor­tu­nate Events. After Para­mount can­celled The Last Temp­ta­tion of Christ in 1983, the direc­tor realigned his atten­tions back to inde­pen­dent film­mak­ing for After Hours, a screw­ball tale fol­low­ing a night in the life of Grif­fin Dunne’s word pro­cess­ing pro­tag­o­nist. As he mean­ders inno­cent­ly from one bizarre encounter to anoth­er, it becomes tough not to hand this vibrant Scors­ese out­ing acknowl­edge­ment for the cre­ation of most future Coen Broth­ers films; it’s hard to imag­ine the Dude abid­ing with­out it. JS

It may be his most straight­for­ward star vehi­cle (New­man, not Cruise), but Scorsese’s sequel to 1961’s The Hus­tler remains as sol­id a stu­dio throw­back as any deliv­ered by a tread­ing-water auteur. Attempts to per­son­alise the mate­r­i­al begin with an open­ing voiceover from Scors­ese, the film nev­er bet­ter than in its ear­ly stages. If the recog­nis­ably ener­gised style rarely tran­scends the dec­o­ra­tive (that open­ing aside), there’s an enjoy­ably pre­dictable – and pre­dictably enjoy­able – momen­tum to the age-old nar­ra­tive and char­ac­ter dynam­ics. While the method stu­dents that pop­u­late so much of his work tend to walk away with the lion’s share of cred­it, one need only look at the per­for­mance Scors­ese gets from Tom Cruise for evi­dence of one of the pre­mier actor’s direc­tors in the busi­ness at work. MT

Only Scors­ese could make an adver­tise­ment for Cata­lan wine mak­er Freix­enet into a beguil­ing love let­ter to the mas­ter of sus­pense. This faux doc­u­men­tary short sug­gests the direc­tor has dis­cov­ered three and a half pages of a lost’ Alfred Hitch­cock film and is mak­ing it into a film. Cue Bernard Hermann’s fran­tic North by North­west score play­ing out as lead actors (resem­bling Cary Grant and Eva Marie Saint) reen­act a suit­ably Hitch­cock­ian – and whol­ly fab­ri­cat­ed – plot. A ref­er­ence-ladled love let­ter from one cineaste to anoth­er. JS

Those in thrall to Shine a Light would be well-served by plung­ing into this sev­en-part doc­u­men­tary series. The open­er was helmed by Scors­ese him­self, with lat­er episodes direct­ed by the likes of Charles Bur­nett, Wim Wen­ders and Clint East­wood. A rough-and-ready intro­duc­tion to the sounds of the Mis­sis­sip­pi Delta, Scors­ese shoots on low-grade DV, allow­ing gui­tarist Corey Har­ris to take the lead in inter­view­ing side­men to the greats and unsung heroes in their own right. Less refined than his archive or con­cert docs but no less essen­tial for those with even the vaguest inter­est in the evo­lu­tion of a sound. MT

No Direc­tion isn’t a biog­ra­phy of Bob Dylan. Well, it is that, but it’s also a film about Amer­i­ca, telling as it does the sto­ry of the times via the prodi­gious folk prince’s dis­tinct brand of musi­cal poet­ry. Cin­e­mat­i­cal­ly, No Direc­tion Home – which takes its name from a lyric in Dylan’s 1965 song Like a Rolling Stone’ – is indebt­ed to a film wide­ly regard­ed as the first ever rock­u­men­tary, DA Pennebaker’s Dont Look Back from 1967; some of Pennebaker’s orig­i­nal colour stock footage of Dylan on tour even made it into the final cut, culled from hours of unseen tape donat­ed by long­time Dylan asso­ciate Jeff Rosen. If you ever want to show some­one what it meant to be Amer­i­can dur­ing the ear­ly to mid-’60s, show them this. AW

Elderly man in dark suit and pink tie sitting in the back of a yellow vehicle, looking contemplative.

Chart­ing 50 years of The New York Review of Books, Scorsese’s most recent doc­u­men­tary is pro­pelled by the rhythm of lan­guage and­kun­du ideas. As a chrono­log­i­cal­ly hop-scotch­ing jour­ney through the paper’s his­to­ry, Scors­ese (and co-direc­tor David Tedeschi) wise­ly allow its con­trib­u­tors’ words speak for them­selves, eschew­ing sound­bites for a rich lay­er­ing of theme through mon­tage. One sus­pects it’s an edi­to­r­i­al job of which its cen­tral sub­ject, the NYRB’s estimable edi­tor Robert Sil­vers would be proud. The ideas were sen­su­ous,” says Colm Toib­in of the paper’s attrac­tion, a notion not lost in the film­mak­ers’ account of a 50-year cru­sade to engen­der dia­logue on the path to change. MT

More than mere warm-up for Mean Streets, Scorsese’s debut fea­ture tran­scends the patch­work aes­thet­ic qual­i­ties borne out of a pro­tract­ed pro­duc­tion. Ground zero for auteurist read­ings of the the filmmaker’s work, the film wears its cinephile heart on its sleeve, charm­ing­ly fore­ground­ing its debts to Felli­ni, Cas­savetes, Truf­faut, Godard and – most lit­er­al­ly – Ford and Hawks. Mas­ter­ing the swift­ly trade­marked, con­tra­pun­tal use of pop music from the get-go, Who’s That Knock­ing at My Door maps the fault lines between sex and reli­gion that Scors­ese has exam­ined through­out his career. The Girl (Zina Bethune) may not be afford­ed a name, but this remains as forth­right a cri­tique of mas­culin­i­ty and ego as any of the director’s films to come. MT

Pre­ced­ing Silence in Scorsese’s unof­fi­cial Faith’ tril­o­gy is Kun­dun, his auto­bi­o­graph­i­cal account of the 14th Dalai Lama’s exile from Tibet (The Last Temp­ta­tion of Christ came first). A beguil­ing depar­ture for the direc­tor, Kun­dun – writ­ten by the late Melis­sa Math­i­son – is not with­out its pit­falls and con­tro­ver­sies (the film’s depic­tion of Chi­na almost derailed Disney’s rela­tion­ship with the coun­try). Yet there remains plen­ty to admire, not least the mar­riage of Scors­ese, cin­e­matog­ra­ph­er Roger Deakins and com­pos­er Philip Glass, whose exper­tise kicks into gear for a mem­o­rable final act that quick­ens the pulse thank­ful­ly war­rant­i­ng the often tedious med­i­ta­tive jour­ney. JS

Around the time of The Aviator’s release, Scors­ese stat­ed that he had no desire to con­tin­ue mak­ing big $100m movies. Which in hind­sight seems a lit­tle disin­gen­u­ous giv­en that the five fea­tures he’s direct­ed since 2004 were all made on rough­ly the same bud­get. The point here is that Scors­ese has always been artis­ti­cal­ly-dri­ven and self-aware enough not to let him­self be sucked too far into the Hol­ly­wood machine. With very few excep­tions, he’s always prized small­er, more per­son­al projects over high-pres­sure stu­dio fare; his bold­ness and will­ing­ness to take risks not unlike Leonar­do DiCaprio’s epony­mous pro­tag­o­nist, Howard Hugh­es. The Avi­a­tor isn’t Scorsese’s best film by any stretch, but watch­ing it you get a clear sense of these two great Amer­i­can vision­ar­ies, both equal­ly bold and unground­ed in their respec­tive ambi­tions. AW

Sand­wiched between Mean Streets and Taxi Dri­ver, Alice Doesn’t Live Here Any­more was Scorsese’s first Hol­ly­wood pro­duc­tion. It is, how­ev­er, almost defi­ant­ly inde­pen­dent in spir­it and style – both in its imme­di­ate telling of a young woman’s search for iden­ti­ty and lib­er­a­tion, and through the director’s acknowl­edge­ment of the expec­ta­tions and lim­i­ta­tions placed on him by the stu­dio. Ellen Burstyn is ter­rif­ic as the title char­ac­ter, an aspir­ing singer whose unwill­ing­ness to bend to society’s wills sees her strug­gle to find her place in the world. Often read as a straight­for­ward tale of fem­i­nist angst, Alice is actu­al­ly com­plete­ly unteth­ered from ide­o­log­i­cal stric­tures. Sim­ply put, it’s a film about going your own way. AW

Two musicians performing on stage, a woman with long blonde hair and a man with long dark hair, both singing into microphones.

Scors­ese swapped the swing of New York, New York for San Fran­cis­co rock­a­bil­ly with The Last Waltz, a con­cert film show­cas­ing The Band’s 1976 farewell show in the venue they first per­formed at 16 years pre­vi­ous. Split between leg-slap­ping ren­di­tions of renowned tracks and inter­views with the charm­ing­ly poised band mem­bers, Scors­ese bears the good judge­ment to recline and let the musi­cians do the talk­ing. The Last Waltz hits all the right notes, her­ald­ed by Scorsese’s open­ing instruc­tion: This film should be played loud!’ and backed up by the inclu­sion of pio­neers Bob Dylan, Joni Mitchell and Mud­dy Waters. A neces­si­ty for any­one who’s ever heard a bar of music. JS

Scorsese’s open­ing con­tri­bu­tion to the port­man­teau film, New York Sto­ries ranks as one of his finest achieve­ments, a styl­is­ti­cal­ly aggres­sive and exper­i­men­tal work inspired by Dostoyevsky’s The Gam­bler’ that comes in under 50 min­utes. Where the dec­o­ra­tive nature of his direc­tion in the likes of After Hours and The Col­or of Mon­ey comes off as super­fi­cial, here he offers a styl­is­tic tour de force whol­ly sim­pati­co with the brutish­ly ner­vous, vio­lent ener­gies of his pro­tag­o­nist. Open­ing on abstract­ed details to the strains of Pro­col Harem – a recur­ring sound­track motif – Scors­ese exam­ines the ten­sions between love, life and art from the sub­jec­tive per­spec­tive of Nick Nolte’s ego­cen­tric painter; as quin­tes­sen­tial a Scors­ese pro­tag­o­nist as they come. MT

My films would be unthink­able, real­ly, with­out them.” That’s how Mar­tin Scors­ese once described the influ­ence of the Rolling Stones on his work. Filmed at New York’s Bea­con The­atre dur­ing the band’s 2006 A Big­ger Bang Tour’, Shine a Light is a con­cert film that achieves the rare feat of cap­tur­ing the spe­cial, inex­press­ible con­nec­tion the sur­viv­ing band mem­bers have not just with their ador­ing fans, but with each oth­er. Mick Jag­ger, Kei­th Richards, Ron­nie Wood and Char­lie Watts are hard­ly in their prime here, but Scors­ese mas­ter­ful­ly reveals how the Stones’ endur­ing rock n’ roll spir­it has kept them in such good shape. Musi­cal­ly speak­ing, any­way. AW

These days it seems like Amer­i­can cin­e­ma is all there is,” says Scors­ese in the open­ing moments of his sec­ond, vast doc­u­men­tary on the movies. All the oth­er cin­e­mas are sec­ondary, includ­ing Ital­ian cin­e­ma, and that real­ly wor­ries me. In fact, it’s the rea­son I’m mak­ing this doc­u­men­tary.” Much like his pre­vi­ous film on Amer­i­can movies, Scors­ese begins on an auto­bi­o­graph­i­cal note, the sense of nos­tal­gic rem­i­nis­cence fore­ground­ed with mem­o­ries of fam­i­ly view­ings of Rober­to Rossellini’s Paisan, before afford­ing the movies in ques­tion a greater depth of analy­sis, of per­son­al res­o­nance. While we nat­u­ral­ly cher­ish every nar­ra­tive fea­ture Scors­ese turns his hand to, there’d be no com­plaints here if the rest of his post-Silence career were spent pro­duc­ing such per­son­al epics of cin­e­mat­ic acad­e­mia. MT

If noth­ing else, Scorsese’s most recent doc makes a fierce argu­ment for his fic­tion and non-fic­tion work to be con­sid­ered insep­a­ra­bly. He’d already tack­led the career of Bob Dylan in his wide-rang­ing 2005 film No Direc­tion Home, but for this return to the elu­sive musician’s discog­ra­phy, the focus is on a spe­cif­ic peri­od in the icon’s life on the road. Chart­ing Dylan’s Rolling Thun­der Revue, a series of low-key gigs in small venues that Dylan shut­tled between across 1975 – 76, the film soars in its stage per­for­mances, large­ly tak­en from the singer’s self-direct­ed Renal­do and Clara. On the sur­face, Rolling Thun­der Revue appears to be a straight­for­ward mix of con­cert footage, back­stage shenani­gans and talk­ing heads inter­view, but Dylan proves a slip­pery cus­to­di­an of his own his­to­ry, mythol­o­gy and essen­tial unknowa­bil­i­ty – which Scors­ese, like any good dis­ci­ple, appears more than hap­py to indulge. MT

From the first shot, in which the film­mak­er shares a bath with his sub­ject – larg­er-than-life Taxi Dri­ver gun-sales­man, Steven Prince – Scors­ese makes no bones about the direct­ed nature of his doc­u­men­tary por­trait. As Prince tells his tall tales, rang­ing from hilar­i­ous to hor­rif­ic, Scors­ese keeps up a dia­logue with both sub­ject and crew. From asides to an unseen edi­tor and DoP Michael Chap­man, to the refer­ral to pre-pro­duc­tion notes on anec­dotes he wants to cap­ture on film, said decon­struc­tion reach­es its peak as Scors­ese reveals as much about the rehearsed nature of sto­ry­telling as he does his mag­net­ic racon­teur, and by exten­sion the very notion of doc­u­men­tary truth. MT

A man with dark hair and an intense expression, holding a remote control.

A pulpy remake that’s bet­ter than the orig­i­nal, Cape Fear was the biggest com­mer­cial hit of Scorsese’s career until The Avi­a­tor blew it out of the water a lit­tle over a decade lat­er. Much of the film’s suc­cess lies in De Niro’s all-con­sum­ing cen­tral turn as Bible-lov­ing, cig­ar-chew­ing rapist Max Cady, whose lurid tat­toos, Hawai­ian shirts and lispy south­ern lilt instant­ly set him apart as the most car­toon­ish vil­lain of De Niro’s career. The stormy finale aboard a hijacked river­boat was at the time the most ambi­tious action sequence Scors­ese had ever attempt­ed. It’s cer­tain­ly apt that Cady/​De Niro appears to be chan­nelling the shark in Steven Spielberg’s Jaws: he’s cold-blood­ed and unre­lent­ing to the last. AW

Ear­ly in the film, Scors­ese talks about repeat­ed­ly bor­row­ing a pic­to­r­i­al guide to cin­e­ma from the New York Pub­lic Library as a child. For him, many of the films exist­ed only on the pages of said book. This won­der­ful doc­u­men­tary served a sim­i­lar pur­pose for cinephiles of a cer­tain age, many a list com­piled off the back of the filmmaker’s affec­tion­ate rec­ol­lec­tions and judi­cious­ly illus­trat­ed analy­ses. Track­ing down a copy of Delmer Dav­es’ The Red House, say, was nigh-on impos­si­ble back in 1995; it seemed to exist only in the tan­ta­lis­ing glimpses found on a worn-out VHS of this, Scorsese’s per­son­al canon. An intox­i­cat­ing trea­sure map of the Amer­i­can cin­e­ma from one of its lead­ing cham­pi­ons. MT

Few film­mak­ers pos­sess the clout – or the incli­na­tion – to mount such a per­son­al project on so grand a scale. A fam­i­ly movie as hymn to film preser­va­tion and an aching tale of loss both per­son­al and cul­tur­al, Hugo sees Scors­ese adopt the lat­est film­mak­ing tools to pay homage to the ear­li­est. Fit­ting­ly this trib­ute to that pio­neer­ing cin­e­mat­ic magi­cian, Georges Méliès, result­ed in the most effec­tive use of 3D post-Avatar; not least evi­denced in a stun­ning update of the Lumiere broth­ers’ The Arrival of a Train, here seen career­ing across a dream-stage of CG-aug­ment­ed cin­e­mat­ic arti­fice. The filmmaker’s man­i­festo – beyond illu­mi­nat­ing the need to safe­guard a medium’s her­itage – is that of his pro­tag­o­nists; to con­jure the impos­si­ble, Scors­ese forg­ing an up-to-the-minute dig­i­tal realm as a means to bring the dreams shared with Méliès to life. MT

As Las Vegas fix­er Sam Ace” Roth­stein, Robert De Niro is cool­ness per­son­i­fied, keep­ing things togeth­er even as his world crum­bles around him to prove once and for all that liv­ing in a mobster’s par­adise is no pic­nic. Yet it’s a career-best Sharon Stone who steals the show as Ace’s pill-pop­ping, treach­er­ous wife, Gin­ger – show­ing that Scors­ese is just as adept at elic­it­ing strong per­for­mances from women as he is men. Her sud­den death, teed up by De Niro’s snap­py, snarling nar­ra­tion, is one of the most con­sum­mate­ly staged scenes in the director’s entire fil­mog­ra­phy. AW

While Who’s That Knock­ing at My Door made lit­er­al its quo­ta­tion of Howard Hawks’ Rio Bra­vo through a series of mag­a­zine-sourced stills, Mean Streets fus­es its hang­ing-out-with-the-guys vibe to Vitel­loni-ban­ter, riff­ing more exten­sive­ly on the ear­li­er film’s superla­tive par­ty scene. If its pre­sen­ta­tion of the city harks back to the unvar­nished imme­di­a­cy of Shad­ows or Lit­tle Fugi­tive – and for­ward to the noc­tur­nal, claret-hued hellscape of Taxi Dri­ver – the masochis­tic psy­cho­log­i­cal and inter­per­son­al con­flicts en route to a Brook­lyn Bridge Gol­go­tha see the vio­lence of cul­tur­al and reli­gious imper­a­tives cast in oper­at­ic terms. MT

Two figures, a woman with blonde hair and a man, facing each other, in an intimate setting.

There’s a scene late in The Wolf of Wall Street where stock­broking scamp Jor­dan Belfort (Leonar­do DiCaprio) devolves into an anti-hero in front of our eyes: after being asked for a divorce, he smacks his wife Nao­mi (Mar­got Rob­bie) around the face. It’s a shock­ing, stray act of vio­lence in a film large­ly devoid of them and ham­mers home the fact that, until that point, you’ve been watch­ing an irrev­er­ent, dynam­ic old-fash­ioned fea­ture up there with his most enjoy­able. Only Scors­ese could have adept­ly weaved this sprawl­ing film and its mad­cap char­ac­ters into a coher­ent whole that improves on each view. And not just for beer-guz­zling uni stu­dents. JS

One of the chief plea­sures in revis­it­ing a filmmaker’s entire back cat­a­logue lies in the hope of a film’s ascen­dan­cy when viewed with fresh eyes. Gangs of New York is a prime exam­ple of this, not least giv­en the coin­ci­dence of its cur­rent polit­i­cal poten­cy. As one of the last great stu­dio back­lot pro­duc­tions, it’s a film whose tac­til­i­ty is fore­ground­ed to the point of arti­fi­cial­i­ty. Scors­ese has nev­er made a west­ern, but that genre’s self-defin­ing approach to his­tor­i­cal revi­sion­ism and myth mak­ing finds an urban equiv­a­len­cy on the bat­tle­ground of Gangs’ Five Points. Over-stuffed with detail it may be – the result of a trou­bled pro­duc­tion – but this is a work whose for­mal attrib­ut­es chaot­i­cal­ly coa­lesce after-the-fact in much the same man­ner as the era on which it casts its eye. MT

A 49-minute oral his­to­ry, not just of the Scors­ese clan, but of the immi­grant expe­ri­ence. Famil­iar faces from their cameo appear­ances in a num­ber of his films, Cather­ine and Charles Scors­ese take cen­tre stage in their son’s affec­tion­ate por­trait of a 40-year mar­riage. Shot in the couple’s apart­ment, the film’s charm lies in its casu­al lack of refine­ment; the gen­tle rib­bing and bick­er­ing between the pair as unvar­nished as Scorsese’s coax­ing of per­son­al and cul­tur­al his­to­ries. As Scors­ese directs his moth­er in the open­ing scene – and she directs him back – this most per­son­al of films lays bare the need to pre­serve such sto­ry­telling tra­di­tions, as well as the mechan­ics by which to do so. MT

It’s per­haps sur­pris­ing that for the most mov­ing and auto­bi­o­graph­i­cal­ly prob­ing of his doc­u­men­taries, Scors­ese shares a cred­it as writer and direc­tor (with film crit­ic, Kent Jones). An hour-long trib­ute to one of his cin­e­mat­ic heroes, A Let­ter to Elia is no hagio­graph­i­cal love-in. Part con­fes­sion­al, part the­mat­ic analy­sis, part psy­cho­log­i­cal inves­ti­ga­tion – into both Kazan and Scors­ese – the film isn’t shy of con­fronting the late filmmaker’s per­son­al and polit­i­cal con­tro­ver­sies. End­ing ten­ta­tive­ly with a trib­ute to a late friend­ship, the film final­ly proves itself less a love-let­ter than a touch­ing­ly sin­cere note of thanks, from one film­mak­er to the trans­for­ma­tive, soul-pierc­ing work of anoth­er. MT

Scorsese’s high soci­ety peri­od romance is rarely men­tioned in the same breath as his oth­er New York films. Yet in Daniel Day-Lewis’ lusty wannabe aris­to­crat, New­land Archer, it boasts a sym­pa­thet­ic hero who is in his own fop­pish way an essen­tial guide to the city of the director’s birth. Jay Cocks intro­duced Scors­ese to Edith Wharton’s source nov­el in the late 80s and his old friend was instant­ly smit­ten. The result­ing script is as faith­ful as they come; an immac­u­late lit­er­ary adap­ta­tion that would sure­ly rank high­er were it not for the sim­ple fact that Scors­ese has so many mas­ter­pieces under his belt. AW

A man and a woman lying together on a bed, embracing.

Although Silence has been described as the third part of Scorsese’s Faith’ tril­o­gy, the film it feels most akin to is his neglect­ed gem from 1999, Bring­ing Out the Dead. An Orphean odyssey tee­ter­ing on the edge of a noc­tur­nal abyss between life and death, night and dawn, the film was the director’s last col­lab­o­ra­tion with Paul Schrad­er. You might think a reli­gious­ly-sym­bol­ic, last-ditch grasp towards grace would prove a solemn affair, but this is one of Scorsese’s most black­ly com­ic works, thanks in no small part to Nico­las Cage deliv­er­ing one of his best per­for­mances as God’s Exhaust­ed Man. Direct­ed with hyper-caf­feinat­ed, bravu­ra flour­ish­es, the man­ic ener­gy is tem­pered by the sense of a wak­ing-dream; that sal­va­tion could be on hand, If I could just close my eyes…” MT

Frank Sinatra’s cov­er ver­sion of the theme song from Scorsese’s 1977 jazz musi­cal – writ­ten by John Kan­der and Fred Ebb and per­formed by Liza Min­nel­li – may be more famous than the film itself, but then this is per­haps the most under­rat­ed of all the director’s nar­ra­tive fea­tures. An ambi­tious, over-bud­get love let­ter to both the Big Apple and the clas­sic Hol­ly­wood cin­e­ma of Scorsese’s child­hood (its lav­ish sets were built on the old MGM sound­stages), New York, New York is a heady trib­ute to the out­mod­ed school of film­mak­ing that gave way to the New Hol­ly­wood class who came to dom­i­nate Amer­i­can cin­e­ma between the late 60s and ear­ly 80s. Behind the scenes, Scors­ese was enter­ing a peri­od of great per­son­al tur­moil – brought on by his exces­sive cocaine use and extra­mar­i­tal affair with his lead­ing lady – that even­tu­al­ly land­ed him in hos­pi­tal. An ugly foot­note to a roman­tic, melan­choly mas­ter­work that has aged bet­ter than many of the Gold­en Age musi­cals it riffs on. AW

Moral­ly offen­sive” and the­o­log­i­cal­ly unsound” is how the crit­ics (read: Catholic Church) first react­ed to Scorsese’s con­tro­ver­sial bib­li­cal epic. It cer­tain­ly doesn’t shy away from the seri­ous and – yes – blas­phe­mous nature of Nikos Kazantza­kis’ source nov­el. Shot on a pal­try $7m bud­get for Uni­ver­sal Stu­dios after the project was dropped by Para­mount, the film inad­ver­tent­ly marked a water­shed moment in America’s cul­ture wars, draw­ing a line in the sand between the country’s tra­di­tion­al­ist val­ues and its increas­ing­ly sec­u­lar enter­tain­ment indus­try. Described in a pre-open­ing cred­its dis­claimer as a fic­tion­al explo­ration of the eter­nal spir­i­tu­al con­flict”, it is first and fore­most an alle­go­ry of the director’s own crises of faith, most intense­ly man­i­fest­ed in lat­er scenes where Willem Dafoe’s deeply con­flict­ed, imper­fect­ly human Son of God expe­ri­ences vivid hal­lu­ci­na­tions while suf­fer­ing on the cross. A stir­ring com­pan­ion piece to Scorsese’s most recent reli­gious dra­ma, Silence. AW

In reck­on­ing with the pro­found sin of Amer­i­can geno­cide – one large­ly scrubbed from the cul­tur­al con­scious­ness – Scors­ese shrewd­ly switch­es the per­spec­tive of David Grann’s source nov­el to give the Osage Nation a more promi­nent voice in their own trag­ic sto­ry. Scors­ese stal­warts DiCaprio and De Niro are on top form, but it’s Lily Glad­stone who deliv­ers the stand­out per­for­mance; a bea­con of qui­et dig­ni­ty and hope in the face of per­sis­tent colo­nial tyran­ny. The film’s dis­arm­ing­ly play­ful end­ing, where the direc­tor pulls back from the nov­el­is­tic scope of the cen­tral nar­ra­tive to ask dif­fi­cult ques­tions both of him­self and the audi­ence – point­ed­ly draw­ing atten­tion to the hypocrisy and com­plic­i­ty that stems from turn­ing such sub­ject mat­ter into pop­u­lar enter­tain­ment – con­sti­tutes arguably the great­est mas­ter­stroke of his long and sto­ried career. AW

One might argue that it’s a lit­tle soon to stake a claim for Silence in the upper ech­e­lons of the Scors­ese canon. At the very least it is a film that demands repeat view­ings. Its long-ges­ta­tion has been well-doc­u­ment­ed, and the sub­ject mat­ter should come as lit­tle sur­prise to any­one with even the vaguest knowl­edge the director’s work; the fig­ures that pop­u­late his films live accord­ing to a code, and Silence serves as a sus­tained test of such, a spir­i­tu­al and intel­lec­tu­al bat­tle­ground vio­lent­ly phys­i­calised. Whether on the streets of Lit­tle Italy, the moun­tains of Tibet or in late-19th cen­tu­ry draw­ing rooms, Scors­ese has proved him­self a sen­si­tive and detail-ori­ent­ed cul­tur­al ethno­g­ra­ph­er. Silence is root­ed in such con­cerns, even as its test of faith tran­scends ques­tions of reli­gious doc­trine to stand for any core, imper­illed belief sys­tem. MT

Sam Roth­stein takes off his over-sized shades, folds his hands beneath his chin and con­tem­plates hav­ing arrived right back where he start­ed. Fade to black. Roll cred­its. Despite being laud­ed by audi­ences and crit­ics alike, 1995’s Casi­no marked the start of an unof­fi­cial 14-year hia­tus for one of Hollywood’s great­est ever actor-direc­tor pair­ings. It was De Niro who first pitched the idea that would even­tu­al­ly become The Irish­man to Scors­ese back in 2004, straight after read­ing I Heard You Paint Hous­es’, Charles Brandt’s chron­i­cle of the life and (alleged) crimes of Frank Sheer­an. The project stalled and the pair went their sep­a­rate ways before Steven Zail­lian was brought in to thrash out a script in 2009. Sev­er­al more years passed. Paci­no joined the cast. Then Pesci. Then Net­flix pushed a blank cheque under Scorsese’s nose. Final­ly, in 2019, with antic­i­pa­tion at fever pitch after more than a decade of spec­u­la­tion and false starts, the direc­tor unveiled his suit­ably epic mob ele­gy. Boy was it worth the wait. AW

And now, ladies and gen­tle­men, the man we’ve all been wait­ing for… Rupert Pup­kin is a far cry from the gristly macho arche­types that had by the ear­ly 1980s become syn­ony­mous with the Scors­ese-De Niro dou­ble act, but the char­ac­ter is no less com­pelling – or dan­ger­ous – than Travis Bick­le and Jake La Mot­ta before him. By turns a(nother) stark exam­i­na­tion of mas­culin­i­ty and a scathing celebri­ty satire, The King of Com­e­dy feels eeri­ly pre­scient in the way it antic­i­pates of our media obsessed cul­ture – today’s TV land­scape is filled with pre­cise­ly the sort of tal­ent­less fame seek­ers that Jer­ry Lewis’ vet­er­an talk-show host, Jer­ry Lang­ford, rails against. Despite being made at the peak of the Scorsese’s pow­ers, the film was a huge com­mer­cial flop upon its ini­tial release and the expe­ri­ence took its toll on both its direc­tor and star; the pair part­ed ways only to reunite sev­en years lat­er for Good­fel­las. AW

Two male boxers sparring in a boxing ring, with a referee observing the match in the foreground.

While Scors­ese was laid up fol­low­ing a bout of depres­sion that came to a head dur­ing the mak­ing of New York, New York, he was vis­it­ed by Robert De Niro, who brought with him a propo­si­tion in the form a script about the life of a for­mer mid­dleweight box­ing champ. The actor had been obsessed with the (cau­tion­ary) tale of Jake La Mot­ta for a num­ber of years, and in his long­time friend and col­lab­o­ra­tor he saw the only per­son capa­ble of bring­ing it to life on the big screen.

It’s fit­ting that a film detail­ing the pro­fes­sion­al highs and per­son­al lows of a bril­liant but self-destruc­tive star should put Scors­ese – still bruis­ing from the crit­i­cal and com­mer­cial fail­ure of New York, New York – back in the lime­light. At the time the direc­tor believed that Rag­ing Bull would be his last film, and con­se­quent­ly he put his full cre­ative weight behind the project. It real­ly shows. This is a stag­ger­ing, vir­tu­oso work whose redemp­tive qual­i­ties can­not be over­stat­ed. MT

Yellow taxi cab with chequered pattern, driver seated behind wheel

For a filmmaker’s great­est work – or sec­ond great­est, see­ing as we’ve set our­selves the impos­si­ble task of rank­ing these films – it might be expect­ed that said film stand as a com­plete auteurist state­ment, one unde­ni­ably marked with the stamp of its author. That Taxi Dri­ver is a quin­tes­sen­tial Scors­ese work isn’t in ques­tion, but it is a film – per­haps more than any of his oth­ers – that couldn’t exist with­out its col­lab­o­ra­tors. Not least Paul Schrad­er, whose par­tic­u­lar brand of nihilism deserves equal cred­it to his direc­tor – whether you read John Ford’s The Searchers or Robert Bresson’s Pick­pock­et as the film’s fore­most influ­ence depends on which auteurist lens you favour.

Then, of course, there’s Michael Chapman’s cin­e­matog­ra­phy, run­ning an intox­i­cat­ing gamut from neon smear to sick­ly pal­lor; and Bernard Herrmann’s mag­nif­i­cent (and last) score, which alter­nate­ly lends melan­choly roman­ti­cism and an impend­ing sense of dread. Taxi Dri­ver is ulti­mate­ly a film entire­ly of its moment, a prod­uct of a spe­cif­ic time and place, cast and crew. It may be Scorsese’s mas­ter­piece, but he couldn’t have made it alone. MT

Four adults seated around a table laden with food and drink.

There’s a moment rough­ly mid­way through Good­fel­las where Hen­ry (Ray Liot­ta), Jim­my (Robert De Niro) and Tom­my (Joe Pesci) stop by the latter’s mother’s house en route to dis­pos­ing of loud mouth Bil­ly Batts (Frank Vin­cent). She hasn’t seen the boys in a while and con­vinces them to stay for a spot of late-night sup­per. Dur­ing the meal, Jim­my picks up a bot­tle of Heinz Toma­to Ketchup and rolls it smooth­ly between his palms in one quick motion, even­ly releas­ing the tangy condi­ment onto his plate of pas­ta (as the only non Ital­ian-Amer­i­can at the table, it’s telling that he alone opts to embell­ish mama’s home­made marinara).

Although this scene was most­ly impro­vised by the cast (pre­sum­ably to accom­mo­date Scorsese’s elder­ly moth­er, Cather­ine, appear­ing in a brief but mem­o­rable cameo), it nonethe­less begs the ques­tion: was this spe­cif­ic action described in the script, a sub­tle yet cru­cial behav­iour­al trait intend­ed to reveal some­thing about the character’s method­i­cal and clin­i­cal nature? Or is it sim­ply how Bob­by shakes his sauce? A doc­u­men­tary about the mak­ing of the film reveals that it was, in fact, inspired by Jim­my Conway’s real-life coun­ter­part. Still, for all the rea­sons to love and admire Good­fel­las – and there are far too many to list here – it’s small, seem­ing­ly arbi­trary details like this that make it Scorsese’s most reward­ing and rewatch­able film. AW

What are your favourite Mar­tin Scors­ese films? Share you per­son­al Top 10 with us @LWLies

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.