Verdict | Little White Lies

Ver­dict

26 Feb 2021 / Released: 12 Mar 2021

Two people, a woman and a young girl, sitting together with serious expressions.
Two people, a woman and a young girl, sitting together with serious expressions.
3

Anticipation.

This is going to be brutal.

4

Enjoyment.

This is brutal done right.

4

In Retrospect.

The world is a nightmare but nightmares make great films.

This sen­si­tive and har­row­ing por­trait of domes­tic abuse looks at how the jus­tice sys­tem fails women.

Ver­dict begins with vio­lence. Joy (Max Eigen­mann) is attacked by her hus­band Dante (Kristof­fer King) while their weep­ing daugh­ter watch­es on. She screams as her limbs are beat­en and her face is pum­melled to a swollen pulp. Her daugh­ter cries, tug­ging at her mother’s blood­ied hem before she too is soon drenched in blood, her mat­ted hair form­ing a slash across her tiny face.

It is a scene of almost unbear­able cru­el­ty and yet the night­mare has only just begun. The film fol­lows Joy’s tor­tu­ous fight for jus­tice with­in a labyrinth of unfeel­ing bureau­cra­cy. Fil­ipino direc­tor Ray­mund Rib­ay Gutier­rez suc­ceeds in grace­ful­ly bal­anc­ing these scenes of intense bru­tal­i­ty with a pro­found sense of empathy.

Despite the tow­ers of paper­work and men await­ing jus­tice expir­ing of tuber­cu­lo­sis in the back of court­rooms, this is not a sys­tem of Kafkaesque absur­di­ty. It is some­thing more insid­i­ous, one pur­pose­ly designed to dis­em­pow­er and destroy women. Dante is per­mit­ted to hurl abuse, scream and lunge at her while she deliv­ers state­ments to the police and receives treat­ment for the wounds that cov­er her entire body. At every turn there is the ques­tion, either explic­it or implic­it What did you do to deserve this?’

The film grap­ples with the jus­tice sys­tem and at every turn finds its gate­keep­ers com­plic­it, from the neigh­bours who ignore Joy’s screams, to the lawyers who manip­u­late her daugh­ter, to the local police force who think of Dante as a decent enough guy. Joy, with­out the mon­ey and resources to make the sys­tem work for her, is treat­ed with care­less­ness and contempt.

Ver­dict is filled with strong per­for­mances. Eigen­mann brings sen­si­tiv­i­ty to her cen­tral role, but par­tic­u­lar praise must go to King who makes Dante, with his irre­deemable vio­lent ten­den­cies and com­plete lack of remorse, feel like a real per­son rather than a pan­tomime vil­lain. The dynam­ic cam­era work enhances the per­for­mances, keep­ing unflinch­ing­ly close to the char­ac­ters. From the fill­ing out of forms to the stitch­ing of wounds, a feel­ing of creep­ing, almost mun­dane evil per­vades throughout.

It is rem­i­nis­cent of oth­er recent under­stat­ed female tragedies, such as Nev­er Rarely Some­times Always and The Assis­tant. And there is, hang­ing over the nar­ra­tive, the ques­tion of how a film like this can ever speak truth to the hope­less sit­u­a­tion many vic­tims of domes­tic abuse find them­selves in. Thank­ful­ly, the choic­es Ver­dict makes are both sat­is­fy­ing and hon­est, and at no point does it betray Joy’s journey.

You might like