Under the Tree | Little White Lies

Under the Tree

10 Aug 2018 / Released: 10 Aug 2018

A woman with short blonde hair wearing an orange cardigan and holding gardening tools in an outdoor setting.
A woman with short blonde hair wearing an orange cardigan and holding gardening tools in an outdoor setting.
3

Anticipation.

This Icelandic comedy was well received upon its US release.

3

Enjoyment.

Nicely judged satire of the terminally bored bourgeoisie.

3

In Retrospect.

Opts for Grand Guignol over subtle nuance, but entertaining nonetheless.

Neigh­bours go to war in this bit­ter­ly cyn­i­cal Ice­landic com­e­dy about our capac­i­ty for malevolence.

If there’s one incon­tro­vert­ible truth in this world, it’s that peo­ple love cats. And they do so with a pas­sion and inten­si­ty that is all-con­sum­ing, per­haps to the lev­el where it might cor­rupt their abil­i­ty to live nor­mal, rel­a­tive­ly sane lives. Ice­landic direc­tor Haf­steinn Gun­nar Sig­urðs­son offers a weird riff on Romeo and Juli­et’ in his third fea­ture, Under the Tree, which fol­lows the lives of two fam­i­lies, both alike in indignity.

The Romeo of the set-up is Atli (Steinþór Hróar Steinþórs­son), a tat­tooed dolt who is caught red hand­ed by his wife (and moth­er of his tod­dler daugh­ter) mas­tur­bat­ing over an archive sex tape in which he canoo­dles (and more) with an ex-girl­friend. She descends into an under­stand­able rage, boot­ing him to the curb and send­ing him back to the fam­i­ly nest. While Atli tries and fails to patch up his rela­tion­ship, his par­ents mean­while are in the midst of a tit-for-tat bat­tle with their neigh­bours, who have kind­ly asked for them to trim back the tree in their garden.

Sig­urðs­son appears fix­at­ed on the notion that most peo­ple are too quick to act on neg­a­tive impulse, and that human com­pas­sion is lit­tle more than an idyl­lic myth. These char­ac­ters get a kick out of con­fronta­tion, and while that helps to retain a sat­is­fy­ing sense of hair-trig­ger ten­sion, it also ends up mak­ing the even­tu­al out­come feel a tad pre­dictable. That said, the film does work in that the ways in which the neigh­bours devise to tor­ture one anoth­er are at least cre­ative and amus­ing, if not always entire­ly believable.

The film’s key com­bustible ele­ment is the eter­nal­ly intractable Edda Björgvinsdóttir’s Inga, the chain-smok­ing, wine-quaffing moth­er of Atli who thinks noth­ing of insult­ing her neigh­bours to their face. She is a cat lover, and this whole mess winds back to a cat-based loss in her life – one which seems to have tipped her entire exis­tence on its head. Indeed, there’s a sense that she loves cats more than she loves her kind­ly door­mat of a hus­band, Bald­vin (Sig­urður Sigurjónsson).

It’s a fun­ny, sil­ly yarn that weaves togeth­er the com­ic and the trag­ic with­out ever real­ly tip­ping things over the edge. And it’s inter­est­ing to see an Ice­landic film which is entire­ly urban and domes­tic in its set­tings – there are no gor­geous nat­ur­al vis­tas or cap­ti­vat­ing, tourism-stok­ing land­scape mon­eys shots, just lots of bor­ing, dim­ly lit hous­es and flats, and lots of peo­ple with lit­tle more to do than start unnec­es­sary arguments.

You might like