The Limehouse Golem

Review by Anton Bitel @AntBit

Directed by

Juan Carlos Medina


Bill Nighy Eddie Marsan Olivia Cooke


We loved director Juan Carlos Medina’s previous film Painless.


Low society, high gothic, mid orgasm.

In Retrospect.

Twisty theatrical vision of Victorian vice and injustice.

Director Juan Carlos Medina takes us on a grisly tour through Victorian London in this terrific gothic chiller.

We hear the murmurings of an audience, then we see curtains open, and actor Dan Leno (Douglas Booth) appears on the stage, dressed as a woman and promising to begin at the end. What follows is a cinematic rendition of something like the play’s content: Elizabeth (Olivia Cooke), a former actress, discovers her husband, the playwright John Cree (Sam Reid), dead in his bed, and is placed on trial for his poisoning, with the threat of the gallows hanging over her.

Yet what is important here is those first sights and sounds, framing everything that follows as part of a spectacle for an audience (which it is). For, adapted by Jane Goldman from Peter Ackroyd’s 2012 novel ‘Dan Leno and the Limehouse Golem’, this film is a bravura music-hall gothic, with all of 1880s London its theatricalised stage.

Closeted Inspector John Kildare (Bill Nighy) is set up by his superior, in what is a piece of political theatre, to fail in investigating the latest grisly human tableau left by the serial killer dubbed, indeed self-dubbed, ‘the Golem’. He finds in the British Library a handwritten diary/confession which could only have been penned by one of the four men who had visited the reading room at that time: John Cree, Karl Marx (Henry Goodman), scholar George Gissing (Morgan Watkins) and self-made actor/impresario Dan Leno.

Connecting this case to Elizabeth, Kildare sets about proving her innocence, even as Elizabeth’s own life story – of abuse, neglect, exploitation and eventual celebrity on the boards – also turns out to be the subject of the late John’s failed play Misery Junction, in which Elizabeth would star as herself.

Told in a series of interlocking flashbacks that form a mosaic of both Elizabeth’s troubled past and of London’s rich underbelly, and presenting its own grisly precursor to Jack the Ripper, The Limehouse Golem is a whodunnit that carves up Victorian society to both comic and tragic effect. And like any good pantomime, it comes with enough variety to please everyone in the audience.

As its Grand Guignol and penny dreadfulness unfold in the dockyards, back alleys, gin houses and opium dens of a corrupted capital baying for blood (and that enjoys a good show), the film’s commitment to anatomising a marginalised demimonde oppressed either for its class, ethnicity, gender or sexuality might almost earn it the label of Marxist. The presence of Marx himself as a character, representing both persecuted Jewry and the proletariat, ensures that there is a solid ideological scaffold from which to hang the film’s social concern with the overlooked underclass. Even Elizabeth herself is regarded as doubly tainted, being of low birth and merely a woman. Her mistreatment by so many lies at the heart of the film.

Director Juan Carlos Medina (responsible for 2012’s Painless) mounts an onscreen drama in which marriages are sham, murders are stage-managed, and only myths and legends are realised. By the time the end of this twisty, topsy-turvy narrative has caught up with its beginning in a world of illusions and performances, nothing seems the same any more, all roles have been reversed, and the script has been rewritten several times to centre, elevate and immortalise the Victorian age’s bit players.

Published 31 Aug 2017

Tags: Bill Nighy Douglas Booth Jane Goldman Olivia Cooke


We loved director Juan Carlos Medina’s previous film Painless.


Low society, high gothic, mid orgasm.

In Retrospect.

Twisty theatrical vision of Victorian vice and injustice.

Related Reviews

The Girl with All the Gifts

By Anton Bitel

A new star rises in Sennia Nanua who plays a preteen zombie who’s still showing signs of life.

review LWLies Recommends

A gorgeous new film celebrates life in London

By David Jenkins

London Symphony is a collage of scenes capturing the richness and poetry of life in the British capital.

Their Finest

By David Jenkins

Gemma Arterton gives Blighty a much-needed morale boost in this charming wartime comedy-drama.


What are you looking for?

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.



Sign up to our newsletter to hear more from team LWLies