Review by Aimee Knight @siraimeeknight

Directed by

Natalie Erika James


Bella Heathcote Emily Mortimer Robyn Nevin


Hereditary 2: Aus-Gothic Boogaloo?


That finale will live in my mind rent-free in perpetuity.

In Retrospect.

An earth-toned ghost story about the ravages of time.

The spectre of dementia haunts Emily Mortimer and Bella Heathcote in this taut Australian Gothic.

Matriarchy is a haunted house in this psychological horror about memory, aging and empathy. The debut feature from Japanese-Australian filmmaker Natalie Erika James, Relic explores the fear and shame allied to Alzheimer’s disease – an interior condition here rendered visible, visceral, in the form of a weatherboard house mottled with black mould. Inside, three generations of women exorcise their grief, tethered by familial bonds and the question of genetic destiny.

When elderly widow Edna (Robyn Nevin, The Matrix franchise’s Councillor Dillard) vanishes in leafy regional Victoria, her tetchy daughter Kay (Emily Mortimer) and lax granddaughter Sam (Bella Heathcote) call upon the family manor, searching for its AWOL matriarch. Then, as mysteriously as she disappeared, Edna returns, marked by dark bruises, missing time and distressed with a menacing presence in the house.

Dank, heavy and pallid, Relic is Australian Gothic. That said, it resists the canon’s typically colonial worries about dangerous bushland (and, by extension, that land’s first peoples). Instead, it centres on traditional Gothic fixtures like ‘home’ and ‘family’ to tell this tale of moral obligation.

Relic is an exercise in control and denial. As Edna’s health deteriorates, the story unfolds mostly from Kay’s point of view, hinging on her role as a carer learning to nurse a parent, just as that parent once nursed her. Edna, on the other hand, becomes more Other than mother.

Gradually eking out crucial backstory, James and co-writer Christian White create a clammy likeness of family dynamics: it’s never quite clear whose perception – if anyone’s – is untouched by guilt, dread and indignation. This ambiguity echoes the destabilising nature of neurological decline. One claustrophobic sequence even traps Sam within the house’s walls, blurring her spatial and sensory processing abilities, forcing the young woman to enter her grandmother’s headspace.

The house itself is plagued by brown and green mundanity, laden with such cottagecore horrors as wallpaper, carpeting and drapes. Textures like wool, velvet and paper speak to plush creature comforts, but everything organic must eventually break down. To that end, a pretty leadlight window becomes an awkward MacGuffin, linked to a great grandfather’s degenerative illness (and its spectral/fungal repercussions).

This complicates the film’s house-as-mind metaphor and muddies its maternal motifs. Still, Relic avoids leaning into some easy generic clichés, as James subverts familiar horror tropes like the slasher’s Final Girl and folklore’s old crone.

When the third act tips from messy into monstrous, Edna’s decaying body could be leveraged as a site of perverse fascination, or abject disgust. Kay takes pains to assure her daughter that the old hag terrorising the house is no longer the nanna they knew and loved. So there’s an unexpected tenderness to the bizarre finale, in which Kay performs something akin to last rites on her mother’s soiled form, stripping back layers of family mythos for one last – or maybe first – look at the person inside.

Gran’s memory palace has succumbed to a moth-eaten cosmos. Her successors can finally go home again, for the time being.

Published 28 Oct 2020

Tags: Natalie Erika James Relic


Hereditary 2: Aus-Gothic Boogaloo?


That finale will live in my mind rent-free in perpetuity.

In Retrospect.

An earth-toned ghost story about the ravages of time.

Suggested For You

My Cousin Rachel

By David Jenkins

Roger Michell’s plush adaptation of Daphne du Maurier’s mystery romance novel fails to leave a lasting impression.


The Little Stranger

By Hannah Strong

Despite an impressive cast, Lenny Abrahamson’s gothic ghost story never quite manages to deliver the desired chills.


Make Up

By Anton Bitel

A Cornish caravan park provides the backdrop to a young woman’s sexual (re)awakening in Claire Oakley’s impressive debut.

review LWLies Recommends

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.