Pieces of a Woman | Little White Lies

Pieces of a Woman

05 Jan 2021 / Released: 07 Jan 2021

Two people, a man and a pregnant woman, talking in a dimly lit room.
Two people, a man and a pregnant woman, talking in a dimly lit room.
4

Anticipation.

White God is a modern classic.

4

Enjoyment.

A compelling and sensitive exploration of child loss.

3

In Retrospect.

Let down by a too-neat ending, but Kirby’s performance is utterly remarkable.

Kornél Mundruczó’s affect­ing dra­ma fol­lows a cou­ple who expe­ri­ence the loss of their first child short­ly after birth.

Kornél Mundruczó’s dra­ma, writ­ten by his part­ner and fre­quent col­lab­o­ra­tor Kata Wéber, focus­es on an ele­ment of moth­er­hood so rarely depict­ed on screen, it feels rad­i­cal and dev­as­tat­ing all at once.

Expec­tant par­ents Martha Weiss (Van­nes­sa Kir­by) and Sean Park­er (Shia LaBeouf) await the arrival of their daugh­ter in Boston, Mass­a­chu­setts: they’ve dec­o­rat­ed the nurs­ery, and even pur­chased a new car with the help of Martha’s wealthy moth­er Eliz­a­beth (Ellen Burstyn). Ten­sions nig­gle between the cou­ple – Sean is a recov­er­ing addict work­ing an intense job in bridge con­struc­tion, and Martha dis­tant in a way that makes her appear cold – but it’s evi­dent that the baby is much want­ed, and the cou­ple are excit­ed about her arrival.

Opt­ing for a home birth, the couple’s reg­u­lar mid­wife can’t attend when Martha goes into labour, so a replace­ment, Eve (Mol­ly Park­er), arrives. Over the course of a gru­elling labour, which plays out in an intense, inti­mate 23-minute scene cut to sug­gest a sin­gle take (with hand-cam mim­ic­k­ing a home video), a tragedy occurs, and Martha and Sean’s daugh­ter dies short­ly after birth.

The rest of the film deals with the after­math of this awful, life-chang­ing moment, and the crim­i­nal neg­li­gence court case against Eve that Martha’s fam­i­ly insti­gate. No one knows how to acknowl­edge Martha and Sean’s loss, and the cou­ple them­selves strug­gle to grieve, while the fall­out dev­as­tates every­one in their imme­di­ate fam­i­ly. The apart­ment Martha and Sean share becomes a war­zone; Eliz­a­beth starts to unrav­el, heart­bro­ken by her daughter’s loss.

A close-up of a man and woman gazing intently at each other, with the woman's face being the focal point.

LaBeouf is decent as the epit­o­me of blue-col­lar machis­mo unable to process grief with­out turn­ing to anger, but this is undoubt­ed­ly Vanes­sa Kirby’s film. Martha is a woman of few words: terse, stiff, unable to process her trau­ma in a way that peo­ple around her find acceptable.

Would it be more palat­able to those around her if she screamed and cried? Per­haps, but Martha is despon­dent. She returns to her office less than a month after the birth, still wear­ing med­ical under­wear, while her col­leagues gawp at her. She goes out drink­ing and danc­ing and flirts with a co-work­er. There’s no right or wrong way to process a loss so mon­u­men­tal, and Pieces of a Woman is an empa­thet­ic look at some­thing most of us will nev­er under­stand unless we expe­ri­ence it.

This isn’t to say Pieces of a Woman is with­out flaw; a dis­tract­ing Sig­ur Rós musi­cal beat threat­ens to derail the grav­i­tas of the labour scene, and the cli­mac­tic moment of Martha’s court case feels a lit­tle heavy-hand­ed in its exe­cu­tion. But Mundruczó is prov­ing an excel­lent film­mak­er when it comes to facil­i­tat­ing moments of true emo­tion­al res­o­nance, and his lat­est film cer­tain­ly offers them – not just in the trau­mat­ic, but in unex­pect­ed­ly awk­ward­ly comedic beats, such as when Martha’s broth­er-in-law Chris (Ben­ny Safdie) tries to offer her some advice from his pastor.

There are plen­ty of films about moth­er­hood in its myr­i­ad forms – even a whole sub­genre of hor­ror films about the ter­rors of mater­ni­ty. But as a soci­ety, we strug­gle to talk about the dev­as­tat­ing loss of life before it’s even begun. Mis­car­riage, still­birth and sud­den infant death are top­ics many of us strug­gle to com­pre­hend, let alone talk about. But for those who have under­gone such a trau­mat­ic expe­ri­ence, it’s essen­tial that they are giv­en the sup­port they need, and some­thing a sim­ple as acknowl­edg­ing their expe­ri­ence can be vital.

Ulti­mate­ly, Martha just wants to be seen and heard. She wants her daughter’s life to mat­ter, for her to be more than just evi­dence in a court case or the name on a grave­stone. Although slight­ly too keen to resolve its ten­sions with a neat end­ing, Pieces of a Woman is a del­i­cate, dev­as­tat­ing account of an all-too-com­mon but lit­tle-spo­ken-about sort of grief, and worth see­ing for Kirby’s per­for­mance alone, which sug­gests she should be tak­ing on roles much more chal­leng­ing than her most recent efforts co-star­ring in Mis­sion: Impos­si­ble and Hobbs & Shaw.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.