Lucy in the Sky | Little White Lies

Lucy in the Sky

05 Dec 2019 / Released: 06 Dec 2019

Words by Hannah Strong

Directed by Noah Hawley

Starring Jon Hamm, Natalie Portman, and Zazie Beetz

A man and a woman sitting at a table, engaged in conversation, with tropical foliage in the background.
A man and a woman sitting at a table, engaged in conversation, with tropical foliage in the background.
3

Anticipation.

Strong cast, fascinating source material… Noah Hawley?!

2

Enjoyment.

Undermines itself so aggressively and repeatedly it’s impossible to find the point.

2

In Retrospect.

The Beatles cover used in a pivotal scene really ties the whole thing together.

Astro­naut Natal­ie Port­man strug­gles to adapt to life back on earth in Noah Hawley’s dull space drama.

On the evening of 4 Feb­ru­ary, 2007, Lisa Nowak, a for­mer naval flight offi­cer turned NASA Astro­naut, got in her car and drove from Hous­ton to Orlan­do Air­port. Upon arrival, she con­front­ed her col­league Colleen Ship­man in a park­ing garage over her involve­ment with fel­low astro­naut William Oefelein, and attempt­ed to kid­nap her.

The sto­ry made inter­na­tion­al head­lines, not least because of the per­sis­tent rumour that Nowak had worn adult-sized nap­pies dur­ing the car jour­ney to elim­i­nate the need for bath­room breaks. It’s no sur­prise that this lurid sto­ry of adul­ter­ous astro­nauts has now found its way to the big screen, serv­ing as the chief inspi­ra­tion for Noah Hawley’s sci-fi dra­ma Lucy in the Sky, which sees Natal­ie Port­man play a return­ing space cadet who strug­gles to reac­cli­ma­tise to life on earth.

Lucy Cola (Port­man) is a self-made woman. She’s worked hard to rise through the ranks, and is now at the top of her game, so has no inten­tion of going any­where. She lives in Hous­ton near the NASA base with her sup­port­ive hus­band Drew (Dan Stevens) and niece Blue Iris, whose father is a dead­beat much like Lucy’s.

When she returns from a two-week mis­sion in the cos­mos, Lucy finds her­self drift­ing out of touch with her old life. She begins an affair with hand­some, hard-drink­ing co-work­er Mark Good­win (Jon Hamm), one of the few peo­ple with whom she shares the expe­ri­ence of hav­ing gone to space, but feels threat­ened by the pres­ence of beau­ti­ful new recruit Erin Eccles (Zazie Beetz). Her col­leagues start to wor­ry about her, but Lucy is deter­mined to take part in the next mis­sion in a year’s time and throws her­self into training.

A woman with short dark hair wearing a blue NASA-branded uniform, looking straight at the camera with a serious expression.

There’s absolute­ly no sub­text in Hawley’s film. Recur­ring cocoon/​butterfly imagery and the less-than-sub­tle literal/​cultural mean­ing of its title are two exam­ples of the sledge­ham­mer-to-crack-a-wal­nut approach he employs. As Lucy’s men­tal state becomes increas­ing­ly frac­tured, blur­ry cam­er­a­work abounds to cre­ate an over­ly obvi­ous visu­al rep­re­sen­ta­tion of her inner being.

Teamed with fre­quent­ly ludi­crous dia­logue (“All that astro­naut dick has made you soft,” Ellen Burstyn tells Port­man in one choice exchange) the film becomes a farce, ges­tur­ing wild­ly at themes rather than mak­ing any mean­ing­ful attempt to engage with them. It’s clear that Lucy is unwell, but no one real­ly seems to notice – or at least offer her help – until it’s too late. There are hints of the way her gen­der plays a role in the obsta­cles she faces, but Haw­ley has no inter­est in inter­ro­gat­ing the sys­tem, instead opt­ing to sug­gest that Lucy real­ly did just lose her mind because she went to space.

This bizarre over­sim­pli­fi­ca­tion of human psy­chol­o­gy feels like a strange leap. Lisa Nowak was diag­nosed with var­i­ous men­tal health con­di­tions after her arrest, but Lucy in the Sky is more con­cerned with how Lucy’s men­tal ill­ness man­i­fests than why it does. For Port­man, the role is no more of a stretch than any­thing else she’s done – the mate­r­i­al lets her down, reduc­ing the char­ac­ter to a cry­ing, shout­ing parody.

She is the woman that the press made Lisa Nowak out to be. It’s not that Lucy in the Sky is bor­ing – quite the oppo­site, in fact – yet it does feel like a sto­ry that would have been told much bet­ter by a female direc­tor, or at the very least, a female writer.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.