Ginger & Rosa | Little White Lies

Gin­ger & Rosa

18 Oct 2012 / Released: 19 Oct 2012

Two young women with reddish-brown hair sitting in a car
Two young women with reddish-brown hair sitting in a car
4

Anticipation.

Worth keeping tabs on the always-idiosyncratic Sally Potter.

2

Enjoyment.

Sincere and heartfelt, but there are too many rough edges for it to take of as a satisfying drama.

2

In Retrospect.

Feels like Potter had a more abstract movie in mind, but tried to package it for a more general audience.

Sal­ly Pot­ter returns with a jum­bled but heart­felt exam­i­na­tion of teenage death anx­i­ety in 60s London.

On the back of Orlan­do, her astound­ing, Jar­manesque debut film from 1992, Sal­ly Pot­ter has (right­ly) remained a key play­er in the pan­theon of mod­ern British art­house direc­tors, even though she has nev­er quite man­aged to eclipse the swirling, light­ly avant-garde genius of that ear­ly missive.

Her fol­low-up, 1995’s The Tan­go Les­son, was cer­tain­ly a bold and, at times, tran­scen­dent­ly beau­ti­ful side-shuf­fle, but was marred by its rough edges and less-than-stel­lar per­for­mances, not least from Pot­ter herself.

With her lat­est, Gin­ger & Rosa, all her strengths and weak­ness­es as a direc­tor are present and cor­rect. On the plus side, it’s a study of bur­geon­ing ide­ol­o­gy and sex­u­al­i­ty which refus­es to set­tle into a staid gener­ic tem­plate, com­pris­ing a series of short ellip­ti­cal episodes rather than a tired three-act sweep.

It’s also a film which locates a sat­is­fy­ing the­mat­ic uni­ver­sal­i­ty by zero­ing in on a very spe­cif­ic time and place: though the action takes place in the smoky out­skirts of Lon­don dur­ing the ear­ly 60s (pho­tographed mood­i­ly, if rather obvi­ous­ly by Rob­bie Ryan) and con­cerns a young girl’s grow­ing anx­i­ety at the pre­car­i­ous state of world affairs (specif­i­cal­ly, the threat of nuclear holo­caust dur­ing the Cuban Mis­sile Cri­sis), it chan­nels cur­rent fears of nuclear anni­hi­la­tion and very real con­cerns about the future of the planet.

And yet it’s also a film which lacks any gen­uine dra­mat­ic heft and is con­stant­ly ham­pered by an ensem­ble of actors who all appear to be work­ing on very dif­fer­ent artis­tic plains. At its cen­tre is Gin­ger (Elle Fan­ning), the only child of dowdy, petit-bour­go­is house­wife Natal­ie (Christi­na Hen­dricks) and her absen­tee poet-war­rior father, Roland (Alessan­dro Nivola), a man of fly-boy good looks who was a con­sci­en­tious objec­tor dur­ing World War Two.

Ginger’s way­ward friend­ship with the emo-inclined latch-key sprite, Rosa (Alice Englert), takes up the ear­ly part of the film, and we are giv­en reg­u­la­tion scenes of teen rebel­lion in which the pair smoke cig­a­rettes, recite poet­ry and shrink-fit their blue­jeans in the bath.

But this cen­tral friend­ship, ini­tial­ly sug­ges­tive of some­thing like Peter Jackson’s Heav­en­ly Crea­tures, fades into the back­ground as Pot­ter choos­es to fol­low Ginger’s path into the CND move­ment and exam­ine the rea­sons behind her grad­ual estrange­ment from her friends and fam­i­ly and her gnaw­ing belief that she’s going to die young. The title of the film is mis­lead­ing, as Rosa becomes more of a bland plot insti­ga­tor than char­ac­ter in the sec­ond half of the film.

Fan­ning, so great in Sofia Coppola’s Some­where and JJ Abrams’ Super 8, here dis­pens­es with her appeal­ing apti­tude for loose, earnest­ly nat­u­ral­is­tic per­for­mance to deliv­er a very trad lead­ing lady’ turn that – with its ago­nised wails and actor­ly ges­tures – is robust, but dis­ap­point­ing­ly con­ven­tion­al. Hen­dricks is sad­ly mis­cast as Ginger’s long-suf­fer­ing moth­er, her forced Eng­lish accent is too notice­ably clipped and her nat­ur­al glam­our under­cuts the fact that she’s left to feel alone and inse­cure by Roland.

Potter’s aim, it appears, is to jux­ta­pose the threat of a loom­ing world dis­as­ter with dis­so­lu­tion of a polit­i­cal­ly and roman­ti­cal­ly frac­tured fam­i­ly, and she aims to depict how those night­mare sce­nar­ios might chip away at Ginger’s frag­ile sense of self. But the bold­ness of intent nev­er trans­lates into par­tic­u­lar­ly lucid or mov­ing cin­e­ma, and a cli­mac­tic scream­ing match (fol­lowed by oblig­a­tory kiss­ing and mak­ing up) not only comes as some­thing of a weak dénoue­ment, but seems to under­mine the film’s cau­tion­ary the­sis by stat­ing that it’ll all be alright in the end’.

Joe Dante explored sim­i­lar notions, albeit with a more male-ori­ent­ed bent, far more cogent­ly and enter­tain­ing­ly in his 1993 film, Matinée.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.