Blackfish | Little White Lies

Black­fish

25 Jul 2013 / Released: 26 Jul 2013

A black and white circular graphic with a central eye-like shape surrounded by radiating lines.
A black and white circular graphic with a central eye-like shape surrounded by radiating lines.
3

Anticipation.

Sounds horrific yet intriguing.

3

Enjoyment.

Sad and shocking, but frustrating.

3

In Retrospect.

Important, informative, imperfect.

When Orcas attack! Gabriela Cow­perth­waite reveals the seamy under­side of fam­i­ly water parks.

The focus of this eco­log­i­cal­ly engaged doc­u­men­tary is orca Tilikum, who made head­lines in 2010 upon killing his train­er, Dawn Brancheau, dur­ing an exer­cise at Florida’s Sea­World theme park. Was Dawn, like the bear-munched sub­ject of Wern­er Herzog’s Griz­zly Man play­ing a dan­ger­ous game with nature? The dubi­ous sug­ges­tion from com­pa­ny big­wigs that Brancheau was the archi­tect of her own down­fall (by sport­ing a too-long pony­tail) prompt­ed skep­ti­cal direc­tor Gabriela Cow­perth­waite to inves­ti­gate further.

Cow­perth­waite traces the ori­gins of the sto­ry back to 1983, when Tilikum was first cap­tured and con­signed to life in an aquat­ic amuse­ment park. Mix­ing upset­ting archive footage of Tilikum’s mal­treat­ment with informed com­ment from sci­en­tists and regret­ful ear­ly par­tic­i­pants, the direc­tor makes a con­vinc­ing case against the cap­tiv­i­ty of whales and sug­gests, trou­bling­ly, that Tilikum’s enforced impound­ment may have influ­enced destruc­tive actions; though the whale was per­form­ing in 2010, Brancheau was actu­al­ly his third human victim.

Black­fish chan­nels right­eous ire at Tilikum’s uneth­i­cal treat­ment, but it’s less suc­cess­ful in its attempts to build a con­spir­a­cy thriller nar­ra­tive, start­ing with the dou­ble-bluff open­ing sequence of mis­matched audio and video which devi­ous­ly sug­gests we’re about to actu­al­ly wit­ness the death of Brancheau (we don’t). It’s a queasy, sen­sa­tion­al­is­tic slice of audi­ence manip­u­la­tion that com­pro­mis­es the ensu­ing film’s stri­dent moral focus.

Tilikum’s first killings are sketchi­ly addressed and while Cow­perth­waite is under­stand­ably eager to por­tray the water­park indus­try as a men­da­cious cov­er-up out­fit, she fails to pro­vide a com­pelling por­trait of how they are struc­tured or who should be held account­able. The lack of any robust inter­ro­ga­tion extends to the lives of the train­ers; one feels fur­ther insight into their moti­va­tions would have made for far rich­er viewing.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.