Twin Peaks season 3 decoder: Judy | Little White Lies

Not Movies

Twin Peaks sea­son 3 decoder: Judy

05 Sep 2017

Words by Martyn Conterio

Two people, a man in a suit and a woman in casual clothes, holding hands and walking together outside at night.
Two people, a man in a suit and a woman in casual clothes, holding hands and walking together outside at night.
David Lynch wrapped up his extra­or­di­nary series with a typ­i­cal­ly cryp­tic mes­sage: mys­tery is a beau­ti­ful thing.

This arti­cle con­tains spoil­ers for Twin Peaks sea­son 3 parts 17 and 18. For max­i­mum enjoy­ment, we rec­om­mend read­ing after you’ve watched the show.

David Lynch rein­vent­ed the tele­vi­sion wheel not once but twice. The orig­i­nal Twin Peaks, which ran from 1990 – 1991, was his attempt at branch­ing out into a new cre­ative medi­um, intrigued by long-form sto­ry­telling. Things soured con­sid­er­ably, as the show went from cul­tur­al phe­nom­e­non to ignominy in the space of a year. By the time the sea­son two finale aired in June 1991, nobody real­ly gave a damn. Once Lau­ra Palmer’s killer had been unmasked, the water cool­er con­ver­sa­tions quick­ly dried up.

Now sea­son three has come to an end, and it may just have altered the tele­vi­sion land­scape all over again. Ear­li­er this year Show­time CEO David Nevins described Twin Peaks: The Return as the, pure hero­in ver­sion of David Lynch”. He wasn’t kid­ding. In part eight, Lynch treat­ed us to a 45-minute exper­i­men­tal short film involv­ing nuclear bombs, killer lum­ber­jacks and a sequence set inside an explo­sion which replaced 2001: A Space Odysseys star gate’ sequence as the most far out thing we’ve ever expe­ri­enced. How did he get away with it? Well, because David Lynch is David Lynch, and his cul­tur­al stock was high enough again for the net­work to give he and Twin Peaks co-cre­ator Mark Frost cre­ative carte blanche.

If part 17 was the excit­ing show­down we’ve long expect­ed between Coop and Mr C – and it was very excit­ing – part 18 was the haunt­ing coda nobody saw com­ing. While the penul­ti­mate chap­ter prac­ti­cal­ly reboot­ed the mythol­o­gy – yes, even Lynch has joined the reboot craze – it did so in an unspeak­ably trag­ic way. The som­bre tone and pecu­liar mood of part 18 recalled 1962’s hor­ror gem, Car­ni­val of Souls (a sin­gu­lar work which itself feels pro­to-Lynchi­an), and one of the director’s favourite’s, Alfred Hitchcock’s Vertigo.

Agent Cooper/​Richard (Kyle MacLach­lan) sets off to find Lau­ra Palmer (Sheryl Lee) in Odessa, Texas and return her to the Pacif­ic North­west moun­tain town for a hap­py fam­i­ly reunion with Sarah and Leland. Although Coop woke up and revert­ed to his kick-ass for­mer self, in sav­ing Lau­ra in the woods moments before her ren­dezvous with Jacques Renault (Wal­ter Olkewicz) and Leo John­son (Eric DaRe), some­thing went very wrong. This was no Quan­tum Lea-style right­ing of past wrongs.

Philip Jef­fries’ line in Fire Walk with Me, We live inside a dream,” reap­peared in the final parts, and it now looks like Lynch and Frost have con­demned Coop to exist­ing in a liv­ing night­mare. While every­one in the town thinks Dale is per­fect, his mis­takes tend to be big ones. Is he guilty of arro­gance or lack of guile? Hawk (Michael Horse) did warn him, back in sea­son two, cross­ing into the Black Lodge with­out per­fect courage would anni­hi­late his soul. Turns out Coop is a very flawed hero after all.

Frost and Lynch have been hint­ing at frac­tured time­lines and alter­nate dimen­sions through­out sea­son three. This goes some way to explain­ing curi­ous con­ti­nu­ity errors too delib­er­ate in design to be the prod­uct of slop­py direct­ing, two prime exam­ples being Big Ed’s reflec­tion in the Gas Farm win­dow front not match­ing his actions in the scene, and Nor­ma (Peg­gy Lip­ton) cor­rect­ing her suit­or and busi­ness part­ner about her not hav­ing any fam­i­ly. In one real­i­ty of Twin Peaks, Nor­ma does have a sis­ter named Annie (Heather Gra­ham) and a food crit­ic moth­er named Vivian (Jane Greer), but not nec­es­sar­i­ly in anoth­er. Frost set the stage for all this time-blur­ring mad­ness in his 2016 book The Secret His­to­ry of Twin Peaks’, where Norma’s lin­eage is total­ly at odds with the show’s.

It’s time – at long last – to talk about Judy. Judy’ began as a ref­er­ence to a per­son in Fire Walk with Me and in 2014’s The Miss­ing Pieces this per­son is referred to by Jef­fries as Miss Judy”. But Gor­don Cole’s rev­e­la­to­ry expla­na­tion in part 17 turned Judy into a malev­o­lent force of evil, not nec­es­sar­i­ly a lit­er­al per­son. The scene also, hilar­i­ous­ly, fea­tures a dick joke. When Albert (Miguel Fer­rer) quips that his boss is going soft in his old age, Cole fires back, Not where it counts, buddy.”

The FBI Deputy Direc­tor informed Albert and Tam­my (Chrys­ta Bell), Judy was in the old­en times” known as Jiāo dāi”, which is Man­darin for to explain”. Con­tained with­in this bit of ret­conned mythol­o­gy from the spin-off pre­quel is a cod­ed mes­sage from Lynch to the fans. Jiāo dāi in Twin Peaks is a supreme neg­a­tive force and the ulti­mate neg­a­tive force (for Lynch) is explanation.

Mys­tery is a beau­ti­ful thing. If all has been explained, it takes away the plea­sures of thought and imag­i­na­tion, strip­ping away mul­ti­ple mean­ings and read­ings into one defin­i­tive con­cern. It’s no fun and even anti-intel­lec­tu­al. Lynch wants us to active­ly engage with his work and day­dream about it. Keep the mys­tery alive, let it be, be in awe of the unknown and the unknow­able. In a world of direc­tors con­stant­ly talk­ing about mak­ing films for the fans”, Lynch and Frost have done the exact oppo­site. They love Peakies – as the fan base is affec­tion­ate­ly known – but the pair’s cre­ativ­i­ty is not in thrall to them, and they’re cer­tain­ly not inter­est­ed in cheap fan ser­vice. Lynch and Frost threw us more than a few bones along the way, but it was always on their terms.

Twin Peaks sea­son three is sure­ly Lynch’s mag­num opus. It feels like a sum­ma­ry state­ment of every­thing the direc­tor has achieved. From his inspi­ra­tions – the Holy Vedas (Hin­du texts), ani­ma­tion, abstract expres­sion­ism, 1950s Amer­i­cana, pop music, sur­re­al­ism, tran­scen­den­tal med­i­ta­tion and even quan­tum physics – Lynch has revealed that Twin Peaks exists and oper­ates like a dream, where forms, phys­i­cal­i­ty and phys­i­cal spaces are con­stant­ly in doubt, appear in dis­guise and can be pre­sent­ed in mul­ti­ple ver­sions. Sea­son three was nev­er going to end con­ven­tion­al­ly. Was any­one real­ly expect­ing to see Coop sit­ting in the Dou­ble R, munch­ing cher­ry pie and shoot­ing the breeze with all our favourite locals? That’s sim­ply not Lynch’s style, and we wouldn’t have it any oth­er way.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.