True Detective Season 3 review – Mahershala Ali… | Little White Lies

Not Movies

True Detec­tive Sea­son 3 review – Maher­sha­la Ali shines as win­ning for­mu­la returns

14 Jan 2019

Words by Emma Fraser

A man in a white shirt and tie, gesturing in an office environment with papers on the wall.
A man in a white shirt and tie, gesturing in an office environment with papers on the wall.
Series cre­ator Nic Piz­zo­lat­to hopes to recap­ture that debut mag­ic, and he’s found the per­fect man for the job.

Wwhile 2014’s first sea­son of True Detec­tive was a crit­i­cal dar­ling, 2015’s fol­low-up was viewed far less favourably. A cast­ing meme is prob­a­bly more mem­o­rable than cre­ator Nic Pizzolatto’s attempt to repli­cate the ini­tial suc­cess of his anthol­o­gy crime series. The McConais­sance, Cary Joji Fukunaga’s dis­tinct direct­ing style – includ­ing an auda­cious six-minute track­ing shot – and a mys­tery that had view­ers the­o­ris­ing as if they were watch­ing Twin Peaks or Lost, were all key, arguably unre­peat­able, fac­tors. With sea­son three, Piz­zo­lat­to has clear­ly attempt­ed to get some of that debut mag­ic back. But has it worked?

The first thing to note about True Detec­tive sea­son three is the return of the mul­ti­ple time­line for­mat. As the action weaves between 1980, 1990 and 2015 we fol­low Maher­sha­la Ali’s Detec­tive Wayne Hays, our nar­ra­tive teth­er and the anchor to the sto­ry. Hays was orig­i­nal­ly con­ceived by Piz­zo­lat­to as a white man, but after Ali read the scripts, he lob­bied for the lead. It’s a good thing he did, because he is the heart of the first two episodes. Fur­ther­more, race fac­tors into the sto­ry in a way that would have been impos­si­ble with­out Ali in the role; despite being in a posi­tion of author­i­ty, Hays’ voice is not always heard.

Play­ing the same char­ac­ter across a 35-year peri­od is no easy task (par­tic­u­lar­ly as Hays is revealed to be suf­fer­ing from demen­tia) but Ali wears the scars and lines of this case in more ways than old age make­up and a grey wig. Hays is defen­sive dur­ing the 1990 inter­ac­tions, as his mem­o­ries are called into ques­tion. When his mind is fail­ing, he con­tin­ues to be guard­ed. He is haunt­ed in all three peri­ods, by his expe­ri­ences dur­ing the Viet­nam War, the prob­a­ble wrong­ful con­vic­tion and because the woman he loves is no longer by his side. In these moments, True Detec­tive sings again.

A bur­geon­ing romance in the ear­li­est time­line sets this sto­ry apart from oth­er weary cop tales. Sea­son one played the cliché of bro­ken mar­riages and affairs. In com­par­i­son, Hays’ inter­ac­tions with teacher Amelia (Car­men Ejo­go) are a breath of fresh air, even if some of the dia­logue is over­wrought at times. Amelia’s voice mat­ters to Hays – hope­ful­ly in the fol­low­ing episodes she won’t sim­ply fade into the help­ful girlfriend/​absent wife ter­ri­to­ry, which often takes up so much space in this kind of narrative.

The case that haunts a detec­tive years after the fact is anoth­er tried-and-test­ed nar­ra­tive, as is one that involves miss­ing chil­dren. When one ado­les­cent boy is ques­tioned in the first episode, he has to defend his choice of Black Sab­bath T‑shirt; a ref­er­ence to the Satan­ic Pan­ic” in the 1980s, which dom­i­nat­ed the tri­al of the West Mem­phis Three. Sea­son one of the pod­cast In the Dark focused on the Jacob Wet­ter­ling kid­nap­ping – a case that went unsolved for 27 years – and the dis­ap­pear­ance of the Pur­cell kids in the first episode bears some of the hall­marks of this. It is hard to do some­thing new in this genre, par­tic­u­lar­ly with the glut of true crime pod­casts, doc­u­men­taries and books cur­rent­ly available.

A brief ref­er­ence to crooked spi­ral” imagery might have some view­ers won­der­ing if this will all tie back to sea­son one. Time is a flat cir­cle, after all. But this seems to be more East­er Egg than a major clue. There are plen­ty of oth­er unan­swered ques­tions at this ear­ly junc­ture, includ­ing where Hays’ for­mer part­ner Roland West (Stephen Dorff) is, the iden­ti­ty of the per­son (or per­sons) orig­i­nal­ly con­vict­ed of the crime and what went down with Tom Pur­cell (the excel­lent Scoot McNairy). Some of this with­hold­ing of infor­ma­tion makes sense, as no one wants all the answers by episode two, yet this some­times comes across as con­ceal­ing details for con­trivance sake. There is teas­ing out loose threads, but some of these con­ver­sa­tions are vague to the point of ridiculous.

The extra­or­di­nary high that comes with first sea­son suc­cess is often swift­ly fol­lowed by clos­er scruti­ny and even­tu­al back­lash. It would be unfair to mea­sure the first two episodes of sea­son three against the show’s hal­cy­on McConaughey/​Harrelson days, but with Maher­sha­la Ali at the fore, True Detec­tive has become com­pelling view­ing once again.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.