The Underground Railroad is a revelatory telling… | Little White Lies

Not Movies

The Under­ground Rail­road is a rev­e­la­to­ry telling of a com­plex tale

14 May 2021

Words by Rógan Graham

A woman and man in intimate embrace, looking distressed, seated by a weathered wooden wall.
A woman and man in intimate embrace, looking distressed, seated by a weathered wooden wall.
Bar­ry Jenk­ins’ adap­ta­tion of Col­son Whitehead’s Pulitzer Prize-win­ner is a nuanced small-screen masterwork.

Col­son Whitehead’s Pulitzer prize-win­ning 2016 nov­el The Under­ground Rail­road’ tells the sto­ry of the secret routes and safe hous­es that exist­ed for enslaved African-Amer­i­cans to escape to the free states and Cana­da. It con­ceives of an alter­nate real­i­ty where a lit­er­al rail net­work actu­al­ly exists. We fol­low the teenaged Cora (Thu­so Mbedu) in her quest for free­dom from the numer­ous inven­tive cru­el­ties of America.

In a ground­break­ing 10-part series for Ama­zon Prime, Oscar-win­ner Bar­ry Jenk­ins mas­ter­ful­ly ele­vates this epic and com­plex tale. His adap­ta­tion is rev­e­la­to­ry. Often enough, depic­tions of the slave expe­ri­ence on screen have reduced slave own­ers to car­i­ca­ture arbiters of extreme vio­lence, unrecog­nis­ably cru­el and easy to dis­miss, with enslaved peo­ple pre­sent­ed as lit­tle more than recep­ta­cles of that violence.

In this series, Jenk­ins imbues every mem­ber of the prin­ci­ple cast with a pro­found human­i­ty that seeps into the bones. By syn­the­sis­ing the skills of his trust­ed reg­u­lar col­lab­o­ra­tors, com­pos­er Nicholas Britell and cin­e­matog­ra­ph­er James Lax­ton, and per­haps most impor­tant­ly the nuanced and com­pas­sion­ate per­for­mance from lead actress Mbedu, Jenk­ins is at the height of his pow­ers when flu­id­ly mutat­ing the style and tone of every scene to align with Cora’s brit­tle interiority.

In the first episode, Jenk­ins estab­lish­es exact­ly what this series will and won’t be. Open­ing with a sur­re­al and eerie sequence of Cora falling back­wards through time, we land on the Ran­dall plan­ta­tion in Geor­gia, dur­ing a mea­gre birth­day par­ty the enslaved are throw­ing among them­selves. Cae­sar (Aaron Pierre) asks Cora to run away with him. She dis­miss­es his request out of hand and rejoins the fes­tiv­i­ties that are abrupt­ly inter­rupt­ed by the slave own­ing Ran­dall brothers.

The thick South­ern accents, fan­cy canes and gen­er­al unease the Randall’s inspire is famil­iar. The rou­tine of mas­ters humil­i­at­ing the enslaved and pun­ish­ing them for not ful­fill­ing their role as jester, and the whip­ping that fol­lows – though obscured by night and shot at a dis­tance – is famil­iar. Jenk­ins rein­tro­duces us to this well trod­den path in the first instance, only to diverge from it entire­ly through­out the series.

Two men, one wearing a hat, sit at a table in a rustic interior. A bottle and glasses are on the table in front of them.

Lat­er on in the episode we are intro­duced to Ridge­way (Joel Edger­ton), a slave catch­er whose rep­u­ta­tion pre­cedes him. He is return­ing a run­away to the Ran­dall plan­ta­tion with his accom­plice, 11-year-old freed slave Homer (Chase W Dil­lon), who at times appears like an appari­tion stand­ing at four feet tall in a three piece suit and bowler hat, tal­ly­ing up the price of fel­low Black peo­ple for his boss. Ter­rence Ran­dall (Ben­jamin Walk­er) is host­ing a tea par­ty, and the graph­ic flay­ing of the run­away pro­vides the entertainment.

An Eng­lish guest, Mr Churchill (Mark Ash­worth), remarks that he doesn’t under­stand how one can eat giv­en a man is being whipped in front of them. Since the Eng­lish export­ed their bru­tal­i­ty to the Caribbean, the prac­tis­es of the Ante­bel­lum South appear tacky by com­par­i­son. This is the first and last dis­play of gra­tu­itous vio­lence in the series, and it feels self-ref­er­en­tial to the on-screen for­mat as Jenk­ins makes it explic­it who these dis­plays are for: white spec­ta­tors, and they can either rev­el in or retract from them.

To tell a sto­ry about slav­ery for the screen, there will always be a ten­sion as to who this sto­ry and these images are for. Does the need to per­se­cute a mod­ern audi­ence over­ride the desire to present enslaved peo­ples with dig­ni­ty? Do fetishis­tic dis­plays of vio­lence achieve either of these goals, or do they become sala­cious fod­der for depraved racists? The body of the run­away is set on fire and the enslaved peo­ple on the plan­ta­tion are com­mand­ed to watch. The tea par­ty con­tin­ues. This is Cora’s cue to flee.

On Cora’s epic jour­ney, she encoun­ters the innu­mer­able inno­v­a­tive ways Black peo­ple are dehu­man­ised in Amer­i­ca. From episode to episode Jenk­ins isn’t draw­ing par­al­lels, but high­light­ing con­tin­u­a­tions of this treat­ment through to the present. At every new loca­tion (demar­cat­ed as stops on a secret train line), Cora is sus­pend­ed in hope, some­where between fear and faith. She swal­lows her grief and ten­ta­tive­ly embraces affec­tion where she can find it.

A person wearing a dark cloak stands in a lush, forested environment. The scene features a large, twisted tree and a grassy ground covered in fallen leaves.

The rail­road itself occu­pies a lim­i­nal space: pitch black; only acces­si­ble via trap doors; and run­ning on its own sched­ule. At var­i­ous stages Cora uses it to slip through the clutch­es of forced ster­il­i­sa­tion, chris­t­ian fanati­cism, mur­der and recap­ture. We are told that Mabel (Sheila Atim), Cora’s moth­er, is the only per­son who has man­aged to evade Ridgeway’s recap­ture. The humil­i­a­tion she brought on his rep­u­ta­tion is what fuels his obses­sion with recap­tur­ing Cora. Mabel’s escape is what fuels Cora’s belief that free­dom is worth every­thing, even aban­don­ing your child for. Themes of matri­lin­eal trau­ma and heal­ing are del­i­cate­ly woven into the series, which arrives at a poet­ic and heart­break­ing resolution.

A more promi­nent theme in the series’ lat­ter episodes is its sear­ing con­dem­na­tion of Black cap­i­tal­ism, and the astute asser­tion that free­dom treat­ed as a com­mod­i­ty is not free­dom and, under cap­i­tal­ism, any notion of free­dom is neb­u­lous. The fact that The Under­ground Rail­road can be so broad in scope yet so for­mal­ly inti­mate and tex­tured is a tes­ta­ment to the skill of its cre­ator and cast. Jenk­ins has proven time and again that he is the mae­stro of fus­ing love and suf­fer­ing, acknowl­edg­ing that life can­not exist with the absence of either.

The series shows a deep respect for the lives and expe­ri­ences that would have been lived, with­out ever sani­tis­ing the hor­rif­ic con­di­tions that were endured. Mbedu chan­nels Cora’s spir­i­tu­al anguish with the kind of heart-wrench­ing sor­row and grit that most actors could only hope to achieve in their career.

Trau­ma and vio­lence exist in every people’s his­to­ry. What many works fail to realise is that recap­tur­ing the cru­el­ty doesn’t have to require retrau­ma­ti­sa­tion. Cora is more than the vio­lence met­ed out on her. She saves her­self time and time again because it’s recog­nised that the will of the enslaved had to be stronger than any of us can fathom.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.