Why I love Jayne Mansfield’s performance in The… | Little White Lies

In Praise Of

Why I love Jayne Mansfield’s per­for­mance in The Girl Can’t Help It

17 Jun 2017

Words by Abbey Bender

Glamorous couple dining at a formal table, man in a tuxedo, woman in an orange dress and fur stole.
Glamorous couple dining at a formal table, man in a tuxedo, woman in an orange dress and fur stole.
She exudes sassy fem­i­nin­i­ty in this clas­sic musi­cal comedy.

There are few cin­e­mat­ic plea­sures greater than watch­ing Jayne Mans­field walk down the street. Too often likened to a poor man’s Mar­i­lyn Mon­roe, what with her blonde hair and coquet­tish screen pres­ence, Mans­field deserves far more cred­it for her ide­al, wink­ing embod­i­ment of pin-up fem­i­nin­i­ty, which reached its apex in Frank Tashlin’s 1956 rock n’ roll musi­cal com­e­dy The Girl Can’t Help It.

Tash­lin, shoot­ing in glo­ri­ous DeLuxe Col­or and Cin­e­maS­cope, got his start as a direc­tor and ani­ma­tor of Warn­er Broth­ers car­toons, and as vir­tu­al­ly any piece of writ­ing on the direc­tor will tell you, it shows. There’s noth­ing in the world to me that’s fun­nier than big breasts,” he was once quot­ed as say­ing – a crude state­ment, sure, but one that speaks to a sym­bi­ot­ic rela­tion­ship between the bawdy auteur and his cur­va­ceous and com­i­cal star.

In one of the film’s many icon­ic moments, Mans­field walks down the street as the title song blares and men gawk. Per­haps walk’ is an inad­e­quate word. She sashays, her whole body sway­ing, and she smiles broad­ly. Through­out the film, Mansfield’s lip­sticked smile helps to keep her depic­tion from edg­ing toward sex­ist car­i­ca­ture. The Girl Can’t Help It is a colour­ful, sil­ly film buoyed by the actress’ per­for­mance of joie de vivre. Mansfield’s over the top-ness, amus­ing­ly likened to a com­put­er-gen­er­at­ed image before the fact” by J Hober­man in The Vil­lage Voice, has a strong, sur­pris­ing­ly mod­ern ele­ment of self-awareness.

When her char­ac­ter, Jer­ri Jor­dan, hav­ing com­plet­ed her saunter down the street, greets press agent and even­tu­al love inter­est Tom Miller (Tom Ewell), she holds two milk bot­tles up to her ample bosom. Good morn­ing, Mr Miller!” she chirps, stand­ing with the bot­tles arranged just so. The dit­sy blonde may be one of the best-known tropes of 50s Hol­ly­wood, but there’s no way in which Mans­field is unaware of the gesture’s obvi­ous sex­u­al sym­bol­ism. A quick (and infi­nite­ly reward­ing) Google search of Jayne Mans­field dogs’ reveals a vari­ety of pic­tures of the actress hold­ing her beloved pet Chi­huahuas up to her bosom in quite a sim­i­lar fash­ion to how she held those milk bot­tles. On-screen and off it, Mans­field used her superla­tive fig­ure as a site of sassy visu­al comedy.

The famous 1957 pho­to­graph of Mans­field sit­ting next to Sophia Loren serves as a suc­cinct visu­al the­sis of her as a per­former. Mans­field looks direct­ly at the cam­era, wear­ing a dress cut per­ilous­ly low and smil­ing while Loren side-eyes her cleav­age. Mans­field appears total­ly in con­trol – her smile here says she knows she’s going to be looked at. She’s not some vic­tim of sex­ist soci­ety, but rather some­one who uses the male (and female!) gaze to her ben­e­fit. In his review of The Girl Can’t Help It, Fran­cois Truf­faut – him­self a mas­ter of cin­e­mat­ic empa­thy – wrote that Tash­lin, instead of ridi­cul­ing her, makes her a lik­able and mov­ing personality.”

Truf­faut empha­sis­es Tashlin’s direc­tion over Mansfield’s per­for­mance, but Mansfield’s lik­able and mov­ing per­son­al­i­ty” is large­ly a result of her prowess as a screen pres­ence. She often gig­gles while she speaks, clear­ly enjoy­ing being a blonde bomb­shell. In one scene, Jer­ri takes Tom out for a beach­side pic­nic. There are blan­kets here too,” she says, unload­ing sup­plies. Blan­kets?” Tom asks. To sit on!” she replies. There’s no way to ade­quate­ly tran­scribe the sound she makes to punc­tu­ate the pro-blan­ket state­ment. It’s the sound of a car­toon orgasm and a Val­ley Girl’s Duh!” It seems impos­si­ble that she’d pep­per her dia­logue with sat­is­fied sounds unknowingly.

Mansfield’s per­for­mance is a charm­ing whirl­wind of 50s wom­an­hood so exag­ger­at­ed and per­fect it’s hard to believe it ever tru­ly exist­ed. In the title song, Lit­tle Richard sings, She got a lot of what they call the most.” Watch­ing Mans­field gig­gle and strut and com­mand the Cin­e­maS­cope frame, who could ever argue with that?

You might like