Reality | Little White Lies

Real­i­ty

31 May 2023 / Released: 02 Jun 2023

Woman in white shirt standing in front of brick wall with arms crossed.
Woman in white shirt standing in front of brick wall with arms crossed.
3

Anticipation.

Tina Satter adapts her own play, which uses a real whistleblower interrogation as its source.

4

Enjoyment.

Sydney Sweeney grabs this role by the throat, hooking on to the nuances of the text.

3

In Retrospect.

A few little gimmicks go a long way to diminish the dramatic purity of this intriguing project.

Tina Sat­ter adapts her own play into a cham­ber dra­ma pow­ered by Syd­ney Sweeney’s per­for­mance as NSA whistle­blow­er Real­i­ty Winner.

When the unbe­liev­ably named Real­i­ty Win­ner print­ed out a clas­si­fied intel­li­gence report reveal­ing Russ­ian inter­fer­ence in the 2016 US elec­tion from her Nation­al Secu­ri­ty Agency work com­put­er and mailed it to the news­room of The Inter­cept, she, wasn’t try­ing to be a Snow­den or any­thing,” she said. An Amer­i­can lin­guist who served in the Air Force before tak­ing up a trans­lat­ing job with an NSA con­trac­tor, Win­ner mere­ly want­ed her employ­er to stop broad­cast­ing Fox News in the office all day. And she want­ed right wing politi­cians and com­men­ta­tors to stop lying to the Amer­i­can public.

Tina Sat­ter adapts her own play Is This a Room’ for her fea­ture film debut, a cham­ber dra­ma that, as with its the­atri­cal coun­ter­part, takes the entire­ty of its dia­logue ver­ba­tim from the tran­scripts of Winner’s 2017 FBI inter­ro­ga­tion at her home in Augus­ta, Geor­gia. It’s a neat device that high­lights both the inten­si­ty and the farce of the inves­ti­ga­tion against her, and refutes the very kind of nar­ra­tive fab­ri­ca­tion that Win­ner found so troubling.

Syd­ney Sweeney stars as Win­ner along­side Josh Hamil­ton and Marchánt Davis as the FBI agents who, over a fraught 83 min­utes, engage in a game of eva­sion, nei­ther side com­pre­hend­ing what the oth­er already knows. There is an ambi­gu­i­ty to Win­ner who is con­struct­ed through spe­cif­ic details – her bumper stick­ers, her yel­low low top Con­verse sans laces, her pink semi-auto­mat­ic rifle – but is per­formed as errat­ic and twitchy, strange­ly dis­tant except when it comes to the safe­ty of her pets.

Per­haps that’s how any­one would act if fed­er­al agents came knock­ing, but Sweeney’s depic­tion also serves as a way to build uncer­tain­ty around the char­ac­ter and then, ulti­mate­ly, to avoid defin­ing her in the way that the Amer­i­can media would in the days after the secu­ri­ty breach. Her sup­posed act of espi­onage brought her the longest sen­tence ever imposed for a crime of this sort and a tor­rent of media abuse focused on her actions and not the impli­ca­tions of the doc­u­ment she shared.

Sat­ter is adept at build­ing ten­sion but also opts for clum­si­er, more gim­micky for­mal choic­es that derail some of the film’s effi­ca­cy. A repeat­ed image of sound waves to inter­rupt the inter­ro­ga­tions in Winner’s home is an unnec­es­sary reminder of the broad­er audio con­ceit that has already been estab­lished, and a visu­al cen­sor­ing effect that cuts Win­ner from the frame any time she says some­thing that had been redact­ed from the tran­script feels a lit­tle exces­sive. The film’s strengths lie in the way it uses a government’s own doc­u­ment to expose its fail­ings; not only are the agents often bum­bling and misog­y­nis­tic in their approach, but the ques­tion remains as to why the NSA made it so easy for employ­ees to cre­ate phys­i­cal copies of top secret information.

Were it not for the tran­scripts, Real­i­ty would be a more straight­for­ward addi­tion to the already-over­sat­u­rat­ed true crime genre. Satter’s han­dling of the mate­r­i­al and Sweeney’s per­for­mance, how­ev­er, bring this into a more intrigu­ing space where ques­tions of nar­ra­tive truth, per­cep­tion and the pun­ish­ment for hon­esty are addressed.

Lit­tle White Lies is com­mit­ted to cham­pi­oning great movies and the tal­ent­ed peo­ple who make them.

By becom­ing a mem­ber you can sup­port our inde­pen­dent jour­nal­ism and receive exclu­sive essays, prints, month­ly film rec­om­men­da­tions and more.

You might like