A new documentary reveals the ugly truth of… | Little White Lies

A new doc­u­men­tary reveals the ugly truth of mod­ern politics

23 Nov 2018

Words by Justine Smith

A woman wearing a checked jacket, seated with a serious expression on her face.
A woman wearing a checked jacket, seated with a serious expression on her face.
The Tri­al exam­ines the impeach­ment of Brazil’s first demo­c­ra­t­i­cal­ly elect­ed female president.

Maria Augus­ta Ramos’ doc­u­men­tary, The Tri­al (O Proces­so), opens as two large crowds cheer on oppos­ing sides of the 2016 impeach­ment vote of for­mer Brazil­ian Pres­i­dent, Dil­ma Roussef. Dressed in Brazil’s colours, cit­i­zens watch as elect­ed offi­cials cast their votes, cheer­ing and jeer­ing like it’s a World Cup qual­i­fy­ing match. Invok­ing God, jus­tice and his­to­ry, the Yes vote suc­ceeds in push­ing Roussef into the first stage of impeach­ment. Among the Yes vot­ers is the cur­rent pres­i­dent-elect, Jair Bol­sonaro, who ded­i­cat­ed his vote to to the mem­o­ry of Colonel Car­los Alber­to Bril­hante Ustra,” who was the first mil­i­tary offi­cial to be recog­nised as a tor­tur­er dur­ing the 1964 – 1985 mil­i­tary dictatorship.

The Tri­al takes off in this chaos. It is an obser­va­tion­al doc­u­men­tary com­prised of behind-the-scenes footage of the Roussef legal team and the Brazil­ian Sen­ate offi­cial cable chan­nel, a trawl through the mis­takes and mis­truths of a dis­tinct­ly mod­ern polit­i­cal scan­dal. The doc­u­men­tary doesn’t shed light on the treach­er­ous polit­i­cal land­scape of Brazil as much as it reflects a greater polit­i­cal trend of frag­ment­ed and unsta­ble realities.

The film is struc­tured like a pro­ce­dur­al dra­ma. The non-stop buzzing of most­ly unchecked noti­fi­ca­tions cre­ates an audi­to­ry back­drop of unease, rais­ing the already anx­ious cir­cum­stances to new heights. Arti­fice takes a sim­i­lar­ly cen­tral stage as we see lawyers drift in and out of per­sonas, invok­ing injus­tice in tears, only to pull it back togeth­er once the cam­era pulls away. Ramos, who has pre­vi­ous­ly made sev­er­al doc­u­men­taries about the Brazil­ian jus­tice sys­tem, invokes the the­atre of jus­tice,” in dis­cussing her films at a recent Mas­ter Class at the RIDM fes­ti­val in Montréal.

Ramos, who men­tions the tra­di­tions of Dutch doc­u­men­tary film­mak­ing as a major influ­ence, sim­i­lar­ly draws on the works some of the great Dutch painters. There’s the casu­al grandeur of Rem­brandt, the focused order of Ver­meer and the chaot­ic lines of Van Gogh in her work. The film, which shifts from Baroque to mod­ernist, takes into account envi­ron­men­tal and casu­al details in its fram­ing. As well as cap­tur­ing the grand ges­tures of the events, there are sev­er­al sub­tle shifts in focus, such as onto a sub­ject bit­ing her lip, and the sym­bol­ic white tow­ers of the The Nation­al Con­gress of Brazil. The unique­ly struc­tured and func­tion­al ele­ments of the Con­gress build­ing, in par­tic­u­lar, serve as a pla­ton­ic ide­al of polit­i­cal thought in stark con­trast to the chaos that lies within.

Ramos is fas­ci­nat­ed by, What keeps the poor poor and the con­se­quences of inequal­i­ty,” and how the vio­lence with­in that soci­ety is also, Per­pet­u­at­ed through the jus­tice sys­tem.” In one of her pre­vi­ous films, Behave, she exam­ined cas­es in the juve­nile courts. In Brazil, it is ille­gal to show the faces and reveal the iden­ti­ties of youth offend­ers. A law set up to pro­tect young peo­ple had the oppo­site effect and result­ed in a media fren­zy that sought to fur­ther demonise young peo­ple, in par­tic­u­lar from poor neigh­bour­hoods and the favelas.

In The Tri­al, she coun­ters the anonymi­ty of these sto­ries by cast­ing actors to read out the tes­ti­mo­ny of these cas­es, inter­cut­ting them with real footage of the judges, lawyers and par­ents in the room. The effect is near-seam­less and has a pow­er­ful effect in coun­ter­act­ing tabloid media pro­pa­gan­da. Her film­mak­ing, though depict­ing flawed and often cru­el ele­ments of the jus­tice sys­tem, paint bro­ken insti­tu­tions rather than indi­vid­ual fail­ures. I like peo­ple, or I wouldn’t make movies,” she explains. Through the fram­ing of fic­tion, cin­e­ma is able to trans­late the real cir­cum­stances of these youth offend­ers bet­ter than real­i­ty itself.

The fram­ing of real­i­ty is as inte­gral to Ramos’ film­mak­ing as it is soci­ety itself. Absur­di­ty rules in the court­room to the point where sub­jects invoke Franz Kafka’s The Tri­al’. More than just a dis­cus­sion of what hap­pened and who is telling the truth, the tri­al and its sur­round­ings are rife with irrel­e­vant noise that only fur­ther mud­dies the waters of real­i­ty. The more you watch, the less cer­tain you are of what is actu­al­ly going on and this becomes a per­fect artic­u­la­tion for the cur­rent polit­i­cal cli­mate around the world.

The Tri­al is hor­ri­fy­ing­ly pre­scient. It is a film about pow­er, cor­rup­tion and real­i­ty, one that cap­tures the atmos­phere of unease and chaos that seems to dom­i­nate our 247 news cycle. Ramos doesn’t nec­es­sar­i­ly point towards a solu­tion as much as hold a mir­ror up to how things are. Exas­per­at­ed and almost hope­less, the film asks how do we pull our­selves out of the noise of mis­in­for­ma­tion to rec­on­cile ideals of jus­tice and fairness?

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.