The possibilities (and problems) of Mexico’s… | Little White Lies

The pos­si­bil­i­ties (and prob­lems) of Mexico’s Cinete­ca Nacional

14 Jun 2024

Words by Shyal Bhandari

Outdoor cinema with green trees and geometric roof structure, people sitting in the foreground.
Outdoor cinema with green trees and geometric roof structure, people sitting in the foreground.
A state-fund­ed cin­e­ma and archive, the Cinete­ca Nacional is a beau­ti­ful exam­ple of a pub­lic arts space – but is it for the few, rather than the many?

On the after­noon of Wednes­day 24 March 1982, it was warm and dry in Mex­i­co City with a mod­er­ate breeze in the air. High school­ers and uni­ver­si­ty stu­dents would have strolled out of class, smoked a cig­a­rette, and squeezed onto a bus or the metro to see what was on at the Cinete­ca Nacional – Mexico’s state-fund­ed film archive and movie the­atre locat­ed in the capital’s south. They might have bought a tick­et for Andrzej Wajda’s The Promised Land which was show­ing in the main audi­to­ri­um as part of a Pol­ish film series. Or maybe they’d hang around flirt­ing, teas­ing each oth­er, and mak­ing the most out of every last drop of a cold glass bot­tle of Coke.

At 5:50 p.m., dur­ing the screen­ing, eight explo­sions were heard, alleged­ly com­ing from the onsite film-pro­cess­ing lab. Audi­ence mem­bers gasped, unsure whether the nois­es were a cause for con­cern or a part of the film (there’s a scene in The Promised Land where a fac­to­ry is spec­tac­u­lar­ly burned down). Then, a tongue of fire burst from the screen. Every­one rushed to the exits. One report men­tions a stam­pede. For 16 hours the blaze roared through the Cinete­ca, killing at least five peo­ple and irre­versibly destroy­ing over 6,000 reels of film as well as count­less stills, scripts and books. Despite the hero­ism of over 300 fire­fight­ers, the loss­es to human life and cul­tur­al her­itage were tremen­dous. Although oth­er archives did exist, a sig­nif­i­cant por­tion of the nation’s ear­ly film his­to­ry had been erased. Films dat­ing as far back as 1920 would nev­er be seen again.

The gov­ern­ment-led inves­ti­ga­tion yield­ed no defin­i­tive cause. Cans of high­ly flam­ma­ble, lus­trous nitrate film were being stored in unven­ti­lat­ed areas designed to hold acetate prints. The­o­ries cir­cu­lat­ed: the film spon­ta­neous­ly com­bust­ed; there was an elec­tri­cal short cir­cuit, and even that it was an arson attack. How­ev­er the fire start­ed, there was sub­stan­tial neg­li­gence on the Cineteca’s part. The film archive should have been stored in cli­mate-con­trolled vaults away from the pub­lic. The dan­gers of nitrate were already well under­stood: 85 years before, in 1897, a nitrate fire killed 126 peo­ple at the Bazar de la Char­ité in Paris.

I won­der if news of the 1982 Cinete­ca fire was pub­lished in Ital­ian papers and might have inspired the then-twen­ty-some­thing Guiseppe Tor­na­tore to write the scene in Cin­e­ma Par­adiso, where Alfre­do the pro­jec­tion­ist is blind­ed by a can of nitrate film that sud­den­ly explodes. In the film, the ruined cin­e­ma is rebuilt by a pri­vate financier. The Cinete­ca was also rebuilt, but with pub­lic funds, and the new site was inau­gu­rat­ed in Jan­u­ary 1984. Again in the city’s south, in the leafy, tran­quil, and well-to-do neigh­bour­hood of Coyoacán.

The Cinete­ca rose from the ash­es, in many ways greater than its for­mer self – though there was the loss of the Cine Móvil: vans that trans­port­ed the big screen to rur­al com­mu­ni­ties. The cur­rent iter­a­tion of the Cinete­ca boasts ten audi­to­ri­ums, an open-air screen, a video library, a dig­i­tal restora­tion lab, a mul­ti-storey car park, bars, cafés, restau­rants, and – cru­cial­ly – tem­per­a­ture-con­trolled vaults that safe­ly house over 15,000 films. I am priv­i­leged to have expe­ri­enced the Cinete­ca inti­mate­ly, on many occa­sions and no occa­sion at all. When I lived in Coyoacán, I found myself strolling into the Cinete­ca a few times a week, almost always alone, maybe with a book or my lap­top. I’d sit under a para­sol in the court­yard and do some writ­ing with a cof­fee, then I’d mill about before tak­ing a look at what was showing.

Architectural structure with geometric patterns, Cineteca Nacional text, people walking below

The first film I saw there was Sebastián Lelio’s Dis­obe­di­ence as part of the Inter­na­tion­al Jew­ish Film Fes­ti­val in Mex­i­co. I grew up in north­west Lon­don with most­ly Jew­ish friends, so to see Rachel McAdams as an ortho­dox Jew snog­ging Rachel Weisz behind a ten­nis court in Gold­ers Green while sit­ting in an arm­chair in Mex­i­co City was noth­ing short of sur­re­al. Next was Roma, Alfon­so Cuarón’s ode to child­hood, set in La Colo­nia Roma, a 30-minute cycle north of the Cinete­ca. My soon-to-be first girl­friend and I went on one of our first dates. To my mind then, every frame was filled with love. A rewatch years lat­er would allow me to see dark­ness in those scenes that shed light on issues of polit­i­cal cor­rup­tion, clas­sism, and inequal­i­ty that are wide­spread in Mex­i­can soci­ety. It might be rea­son­able, there­fore, to ask, does the Cinete­ca, as a pub­lic cul­tur­al space, serve as a social good?

This pro­vokes the pre­lim­i­nary ques­tion: Who does the Cinete­ca serve? In the­o­ry, the answer is every­one. Dur­ing its open­ing hours, the Cinete­ca wel­comes all, irre­spec­tive of nation­al­i­ty, race, class, gen­der, sex­u­al­i­ty, or socioe­co­nom­ic sta­tus. The space is open; the entrances have no doors, sweep­ing ramps deliv­er wheel­chair acces­si­bil­i­ty, sun­light is divid­ed just­ly by thou­sands of criss-cross open­ings in the roof, and there’s plen­ty of well-kept grass for the wild­flow­ers of young love to bloom. On Tues­day to Thurs­day evenings, a film is pro­ject­ed on the open-air screen with blan­kets pro­vid­ed for free.

How­ev­er, the fact remains that the Cinete­ca tends to attract a cer­tain demo­graph­ic: art­sy folk who drink beer that isn’t yel­low, intel­lec­tu­als, uni­ver­si­ty stu­dents, hip­sters, and for­eign­ers like me. This can be explained, in part, by the pro­gram­ming which blends art­house, inde­pen­dent, inter­na­tion­al, and clas­sic Mex­i­can cin­e­ma. Unlike Toluca’s Cinete­ca Mex­iquense, which resort­ed to screen­ing Min­ions to get bums on seats, the Cinete­ca Nacional’s great­est pull – besides its ter­race bar – is its thought­ful­ly curat­ed film offer­ing. Diverse pro­gram­ming is what dis­tin­guish­es the Cinete­ca from the mul­ti­plex expe­ri­ence that dom­i­nates the rest of the city (don’t get me wrong, I love a mul­ti­plex in a mall, espe­cial­ly when there’s Dori­tos-infused pop­corn in the mix).

Yet even though the Cinete­ca doesn’t show many block­busters, it still draws in reg­u­lar Mex­i­can movie­go­ers look­ing for some­thing a lit­tle dif­fer­ent. There’s a viral meme about the Cinete­ca: A mid­dle-aged bloke with gel in his hair is hold­ing a large Coke and pop­corn with the cap­tion Sell me a tick­et to the least main­stream movie you’re show­ing”. The meme reflects how the Cinete­ca is part of the cul­tur­al fab­ric and, to some extent, attracts a social­ly mixed audi­ence. It can’t hurt that tick­et prices are between half and two-thirds the price of Cinépo­lis or Cin­e­mex (the equiv­a­lent of Cineworld or Odeon). Thanks to the Cinete­ca being fund­ed by the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment it’s sig­nif­i­cant­ly cheap­er than com­mer­cial cinemas.

How­ev­er, it is impor­tant to empha­sise that the activ­i­ty of going to the cin­e­ma is eco­nom­i­cal­ly strain­ing for most. Rel­a­tive to Mex­i­co City’s aver­age salary, the cost of a tick­et, even at Cinete­ca prices, rep­re­sents 1.4% of month­ly earn­ings. That might not sound like much, but as a point of ref­er­ence, a tick­et at the Cur­zon Soho would be 0.3% of an aver­age Londoner’s month­ly wage. Com­par­a­tive­ly, it’s five times more expen­sive to go to the movies in Mex­i­co City than in Lon­don. While the Cinete­ca does serve its pub­lic, it cer­tain­ly doesn’t serve every­one – or even most of the city’s res­i­dents. As a pub­lic ser­vice, that’s not good enough.

Despite the costs, on week­ends you will find cin­e­ma com­plex­es across Mex­i­co packed with fam­i­lies, groups of friends, and cou­ples. Curi­ous­ly, many in line at the con­ces­sion stand have no inten­tion of see­ing a film. They are wait­ing for fresh pop­corn. That’s a thing – you can order on an app and col­lect your pop­corn in a take­away box with a han­dle. With­out good pop­corn, any cin­e­ma, even the Cinete­ca, would fail to draw crowds in Mex­i­co where food is such a large part of cul­ture and dai­ly life.

The link­ing of pop­corn to the movies might orig­i­nate as a gringo mar­ket­ing ploy, but as with hot dogs and burg­ers, Mex­i­cans have made pop­corn their own. At the Cinete­ca, I like to get a 70:30 mix of but­ter and jalapeño pop­corn, then I’ll pump over lash­ings of Valenti­na hot sauce and grab a stack of nap­kins on my way in. Recent­ly, I vis­it­ed the BFI South­bank and was offered nuts or olives when I asked about pop­corn. I have noth­ing against nuts and even less against olives, but the choice not to sell pop­corn feels inten­tion­al. My con­cern is that if you exclude the excit­ing snacks that draw some peo­ple to the cin­e­ma, you might lose that audi­ence too.

Now I’m back in Lon­don, I look at my times at the Cinete­ca with immense nos­tal­gia. The last film I saw there was Woman of the Port, a minor work by the Mex­i­can direc­tor Arturo Rip­stein. The pro­tag­o­nist, a sailor, was mad­ly in love, just as I had been on my first vis­its to the Cinete­ca. It was exact­ly the kind of film des­tined to be pro­ject­ed there, where the mis­sion is to pro­tect, con­serve, and most impor­tant­ly, share Mex­i­can cin­e­ma with an ever-wider audi­ence of new gen­er­a­tions. It’s an insti­tu­tion that goes back fifty years, to 1974, when the orig­i­nal site on the cor­ner of Tlal­pan and Chu­rubus­co first opened. Eight years lat­er the Cinete­ca would be oblit­er­at­ed before its splen­did rebirth. Metres from the loca­tion of the fire (and two miles from the cur­rent Cinete­ca), a derelict mul­ti­plex has been con­vert­ed into the brand-new Cinete­ca Nacional de las Artes, with twelve screens. I went soon after it opened last year – it was cold and the pop­corn sucked. But hey, it’s still ear­ly days.

You might like