A new documentary boldly challenges our… | Little White Lies

A new doc­u­men­tary bold­ly chal­lenges our per­cep­tions of death

19 Aug 2018

Words by Matt Turner

Elderly woman in floral patterned blanket, holding a mug, looking directly at the camera.
Elderly woman in floral patterned blanket, holding a mug, looking directly at the camera.
Steven Eastwood’s Island fol­lows four ter­mi­nal­ly ill peo­ple across the final year of their lives.

Time is a pecu­liar thing. It’s just a way of chop­ping up a peri­od so that we know where we are, and when we are,” mus­es Alan, one of the four indi­vid­u­als fac­ing end-of-life sit­u­a­tions in Steven Eastwood’s Island, a doc­u­men­tary that sen­si­tive­ly, empa­thet­i­cal­ly, and con­cen­trat­ed­ly exam­ines what it means to face the real­i­ty of mor­tal­i­ty. It is easy to speak as philo­soph­i­cal­ly as Alan does when time seems ample, but when death is near the same sort of line of thought starts to sound braver. There is no time but the now,” he adds. The eter­nal now is the only thing that exists.” Death acts on its own sense of time, yet few adjust to it so effectively.

As Island shows, towards the end of life time can seem more elas­tic. Life feels long, until it is cut short; and as much as we may try, it is some­thing that we don’t real­ly hold all that much con­trol over. Set on the Isle of Wight, the film hears direct­ly from those with ter­mi­nal diag­noses, chart­ing their jour­neys and address­ing the expe­ri­ence of liv­ing with an aware­ness of the immi­nence of death, as well as – more unusu­al­ly – depict­ing its arrival. Indeed, Alan’s refusal to be mor­bid in the face of his own mor­tal­i­ty is one of many unex­pect­ed ways in which the film sub­tly works to shift the viewer’s expec­ta­tions over how this real­i­ty should, or rather could, be represented.

Deal­ing with death is far from unprece­dent­ed in non-fic­tion film, and Island is one of sev­er­al recent films focus­ing on acts of pal­lia­tive care. (Just in the last year, Wang Bing’s Mrs Fang, John Bruce and Pawel Wojtasik’s End of Life, Erick Stoll and Chase Whiteside’s Améri­ca have all focused, unspar­ing­ly and large­ly unsen­ti­men­tal­ly, on end-of-life sit­u­a­tions.) Island is unique in one aspect. It is the only film of the recent few that cap­tures the moment of death itself.

An elderly man in a red shirt sitting in a wheelchair, being served a meal by a woman in a blue nurse's uniform.

The film fea­tures a sin­gle extend­ed sequence in which Alan’s death is trans­mit­ted as it occurs. In a scene that is less shock­ing than it may sound, East­wood films Alan’s face from a fixed posi­tion, in close prox­im­i­ty, nev­er avert­ing his gaze. Eyes closed, mouth agape, Alan lies calm and still while draw­ing in his final breaths. Each gasp is clear­ly vis­i­ble form­ing a rhythm of its own, this gen­er­al­ly unseen action result­ing in the cre­ation of a new sense of time. The eter­nal now, seen one breath at a time.

This pass­ing proves to be not such an awful thing to wit­ness after all, and this sequence is not nec­es­sar­i­ly even the most uncom­fort­able in the film. The most mov­ing moment arrives as the film’s youngest sub­ject, Jamie, bare­ly 40 and bat­tling a par­tic­u­lar­ly aggres­sive form of can­cer, throws a fundrais­ing par­ty for friends. A joy­ous occa­sion that coun­ters the mis­ery that Jamie’s prog­no­sis tends to be asso­ci­at­ed with, while watch­ing in on it, East­wood cap­tures a rup­ture. As Jamie paus­es a moment to catch a breath, it all becomes too much. As Mark Ron­son and Bruno Mars’ Uptown Funk’ blasts out incon­gru­ous­ly in the back­ground, Jamie’s expres­sion slow­ly drains all of its remain­ing vital­i­ty. Oth­er­wise pos­i­tive, the cost of his brav­ery here becomes vis­i­ble on his face.

It is these moments that make the film. As uncom­fort­able as it may be to see what usu­al­ly goes unseen, it is often the most pri­vate moments that are the most human­is­ing. A strained expres­sion, a way­ward glance, a last hug, a bed-bound bath, or a final breath. Death has always been a taboo sub­ject, and what East­wood choos­es to film and what not to film is like­ly to be a point of con­tention. It is to the director’s cred­it, how­ev­er, that there is noth­ing exploita­tive or provoca­tive about Island, oth­er than the ques­tions that it rais­es, name­ly why West­ern cul­ture is so ter­ri­fied of death; of approach­ing it, address­ing it, accept­ing it and depict­ing it.

One of the most repeat­ed mantras is that death is one of life’s few cer­tain­ties. We are born and we will die. Island probes into this rel­a­tive­ly unchart­ed ter­ri­to­ry with great intel­li­gence and sen­si­tiv­i­ty, and shows that while loss is painful and grief can be dev­as­tat­ing, death itself – for all its grim inevitabil­i­ty – isn’t nec­es­sar­i­ly so hor­ri­ble. Care­giv­ing is ten­der, and film­mak­ing, when han­dled equal­ly ten­der­ly, can be an act of care.

Ahead of the film’s the­atri­cal release on 14 Sep­tem­ber, see direc­tor Steven East­wood and pro­duc­er Elhum Shak­er­i­far give a mas­ter­class on The Ethics of See­ing’ at Open City Doc­u­men­tary Fes­ti­val in Lon­don on 6 Sep­tem­ber, where Améri­ca also screens on 7 September.

You might like