How David Fincher put complex women in the frame | Little White Lies

Women In Film

How David Finch­er put com­plex women in the frame

12 Sep 2014

Words by Simran Hans

A person in a dark room, wearing a black outfit and holding a laptop.
A person in a dark room, wearing a black outfit and holding a laptop.
A look beyond the dom­i­nant male char­ac­ters that inhab­it the Gone Girl director’s cinema.

A for­mal­ist with a foren­sic eye for detail (and no patience for wad­ing through emo­tion­al sludge), David Finch­er holds his char­ac­ters at arm’s length – per­haps all the bet­ter to see them in their entire­ty. Most of these char­ac­ters are men; Finch­er is, after all, a man’s man with a par­tic­u­lar predilec­tion for sto­ries about fra­ter­ni­ty in cri­sis (The Game, Zodi­ac, The Social Net­work) and the crum­bling frame­work of mas­culin­i­ty in a late-cap­i­tal­ist soci­ety (Fight Club, The Social Net­work and – we think – Gone Girl). How­ev­er, that is not to say that Fincher’s women are shrink­ing violets.

There are excep­tions; Gwyneth Paltrow’s only notable scene as Tra­cy, wife of Brad Pitt’s detec­tive in Se7en, is noth­ing more than a shock in a box, while Chloë Sevigny’s role as Robert Graysmith’s shy, smart wife in Zodi­ac is so inci­den­tal to the plot that she might as well not exist. As for Alien 3’s fem­i­nist hero­ine Rip­ley – she isn’t exact­ly Fincher’s cre­ation. Yet, despite these mis­steps, many of the women in Fincher’s fil­mog­ra­phy stand out as being equal­ly as inter­est­ing, if per­haps not always as well-explored, as their male coun­ter­parts. From Jodie Foster’s fierce sin­gle moth­er in Pan­ic Room to the Machi­avel­lian women of the Finch­er-pro­duced House of Cards, tough, curi­ous, com­plex – and as psy­cho­log­i­cal­ly opaque as any of his mis­an­thropes – women fea­ture in almost all of his fea­tures. With his adap­tion of Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl set to open the New York Film Fes­ti­val lat­er this month, Lit­tle White Lies looks back at some of Fincher’s most inter­est­ing, com­pli­cat­ed and sub­ver­sive female creations.

Deb­o­rah Kara Unger’s steely, straight-talk­ing wait­ress Chris­tine facil­i­tates Nico­las Van Orton’s (Michael Dou­glas) tum­ble down the rab­bit hole cre­at­ed by mys­te­ri­ous organ­i­sa­tion CRS. Sexy, resource­ful and seem­ing­ly fear­less, the earthy Chris­tine is worlds away from Dou­glas’ shiv­er­ing suit­ed and boot­ed Van Orton – and much more com­pli­cat­ed than the aver­age love inter­est. She main­tains the abil­i­ty to dis­guise her inten­tions through­out The Game; whether she’s sav­ing him from a snarling Alsa­t­ian as the pair prowl the emp­ty streets of San Francisco’s Chi­na­town or cajol­ing him into drug-induced stu­por, she retains agency. Yeah, there’s that bit at the end when Van Orton tries to score a date, but even then it’s Chris­tine who asks him if he’s like to join her for coffee.

Giv­en that I haven’t been fucked like that since grade school” is Mar­la Singer’s most mem­o­rable line in Fight Club, it’s easy to think she’s a bohemi­an femme fatale, a token designed to tit­il­late in an oth­er­wise all-male cast. How­ev­er – as Edward Norton’s nar­ra­tor him­self states – all of this has some­thing to do with a girl called Mar­la.” Whether you read her as a mir­ror of the narrator’s splin­ter­ing psy­chosis, or the human source of strength he needs to defeat his demons, Hele­na Bon­ham Carter’s Mar­la is as cen­tral to the plot as Brad Pitt’s Tyler Durden.

Rooney Mara plays a small but sig­nif­i­cant role as Mark Zuckerberg’s (Jesse Eisen­berg) ex-girl­friend Eri­ca in The Social Net­work. Mara and Eisenberg’s ver­bal spar­ring is thrilling to watch, with Eri­ca deliv­er­ing Sorkin’s deli­cious zinger: Dat­ing you is like dat­ing a Stair­mas­ter.” Zuckerberg’s breakup with Eri­ca is pre­sent­ed as the cat­a­lyst for the cre­ation of Face­book, but she tran­scends her func­tion as a plot device by ver­bal­ly cas­trat­ing him, pub­licly high­light­ing both his misog­y­ny and his immaturity.

The Girl With the Drag­on Tat­too – Lis­beth Salan­der (Rooney Mara)
Mara is some­how both strong and vul­ner­a­ble as Lis­beth Salan­der in The Girl With the Drag­on Tat­too. A bisex­u­al hack­er with a pen­chant for punk, Salan­der exists out­side the main­stream, it is Daniel Craig’s bum­bling bour­geois jour­nal­ist Blomkvist who is the foil in Fincher’s depic­tion of their rela­tion­ship. While some might argue he fetishis­es Salander’s graph­ic rape scene, lin­ger­ing provoca­tive­ly on Mara’s gamine body in a show­er scene that fol­lows her trau­ma, Fincher’s for­mal­ist approach to the mur­der mys­tery at the heart of the sto­ry keeps the film from being a revenge tale. Salan­der is an intense­ly high-func­tion­ing indi­vid­ual who sub­verts tra­di­tion­al gen­der roles, pur­su­ing Blomkvist sex­u­al­ly and res­cu­ing him from cer­tain death at the film’s climax.

With no pre­views of Gone Girl avail­able at the time of writ­ing, we can only spec­u­late about how Finch­er has chis­elled Pike’s regal car­riage into the shape of Gillian Flynn’s impos­si­bly icy vil­lain­ess. Depend­ing on how you read her, Amy can be seen as a man-hat­ing mas­ter manip­u­la­tor; a jeal­ous, high­ly strung shrew that deceives her hus­band to pun­ish him for his evo­lu­tion­ary short­com­ings, or a fas­tid­i­ous decon­struc­tion of the Cool Girl’ myth. To quote Fly­nn: Being the Cool Girl means I am a hot, bril­liant, fun­ny woman who adores foot­ball, pok­er, dirty jokes, and burp­ing, who plays video games, drinks cheap beer, loves three­somes and anal sex, and jams hot dogs and ham­burg­ers into her mouth like she’s host­ing the world’s biggest culi­nary gang bang while some­how main­tain­ing a size 2, because Cool Girls are above all hot.”

In Flynn’s nov­el, Amy writes, I like strong women” is code for I hate strong women.” While Fincher’s canon resists the I like strong women’ moniker, his com­plex, ful­ly-realised female char­ac­ters sug­gests otherwise.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.