A powerful new film traces the campaign to lift… | Little White Lies

Women In Film

A pow­er­ful new film traces the cam­paign to lift Ireland’s abor­tion ban

18 May 2021

Words by Anahit Behrooz

A woman with a 'Vote Yes' banner stands atop the shoulders of a man in a crowd of people protesting or rallying for a cause.
A woman with a 'Vote Yes' banner stands atop the shoulders of a man in a crowd of people protesting or rallying for a cause.
The 8th is a poignant look at how grass­roots activism is dri­ving social change.

Aideen Kane, Lucy Kennedy and Maeve O’Boyle’s doc­u­men­tary The 8th may be filmed in Eng­lish, but in many ways protest is its pri­ma­ry lan­guage. Chart­ing the months lead­ing up to the 2018 ref­er­en­dum to over­turn Ireland’s con­tro­ver­sial Eighth Amend­ment, which for almost 35 years had effec­tive­ly crim­i­nalised abor­tion, the film is marked through­out by the voice of the peo­ple. Colour­ful plac­ards plas­tered with equal­ly colour­ful slo­gans (“Get your rosaries off my ovaries”) fill the screen, while angry chants of Repeal the Eighth” echo through city squares, screamed over and over by impas­sioned crowds.

Released on the three-year anniver­sary of the his­toric vote and its sub­se­quent mile­stone vic­to­ry, the arrival of The 8th feels even more pre­scient in the wake of the Black Lives Mat­ter and Kill the Bill demon­stra­tions that have tak­en place over the past year. When we were going to fes­ti­vals some peo­ple were say­ing Well, how rel­e­vant is this real­ly giv­en that we’re in Covid and peo­ple can’t go out on the streets’,” Kennedy says. And then George Floyd was killed and the protest move­ments in the US and oth­er parts of the world just erupt­ed. One of the things our film shows – and hon­est­ly one of the things that is ter­ri­fy­ing about the pro­posed leg­is­la­tion in the UK – is that protest is essen­tial for change.”

A protest itself doesn’t make an activist or cause change imme­di­ate­ly,” agrees Kane, but it’s incre­men­tal: it’s the pas­sion that it aris­es in peo­ple, and what that will ignite and spark. There is an agent of change in all of us.” This idea of grass­roots action is cen­tral to The 8th, which fea­tures remark­ably lit­tle elec­toral pol­i­tics for a doc­u­men­tary hing­ing on the results of a ref­er­en­dum. Rather, this is a film that belongs to activists and com­mu­ni­ty organ­is­ers, locat­ing polit­i­cal agency with­in the actions of every­day peo­ple and reveal­ing the tire­less work that lies behind the col­lec­tive strug­gle for human dig­ni­ty. Bring­ing togeth­er a large cast of cam­paign­ers, notably from both sides of the debate, two activists in par­tic­u­lar take cen­tre stage: renowned fem­i­nist aca­d­e­m­ic Ailb­he Smyth, and Andrea Horan, own­er of Dublin-based nail and beau­ty salon Trop­i­cal Popical.

The move­ment to change the Eighth Amend­ment was not some­thing that came from the Irish gov­ern­ment,” explains Kennedy, reflect­ing on their unique­ly com­mu­ni­ty-dri­ven approach. This was a hot pota­to before Jan­u­ary 2018: peo­ple didn’t even want to use the word abor­tion. It was from the activists, it was from the grass­roots, it was from peo­ple like Ailb­he who had been work­ing on it for 35 years.” O’Boyle adds, When you’re doc­u­ment­ing some­thing as large as this, you have to have a real­ly enig­mat­ic pro­tag­o­nist. We met many incred­i­ble activists along the way, but Ailb­he had the his­to­ry: she was in her sev­en­ties and had lived through [the pass­ing of the Eighth Amend­ment] and had fought all the way along. This was her fight to win, and the stakes were high for her.”

While Smyth rep­re­sents a gen­er­a­tion of fem­i­nists who have been oppos­ing the Eighth Amend­ment ever since it was passed into law, the dual focus on Horan also speaks to a new­er cohort of young, often work­ing-class, women work­ing to effect change with­in their social and pro­fes­sion­al cir­cles. Andrea want­ed to bring the cam­paign to peo­ple that fol­lowed her,” Kane explains, to meet them where they were, as opposed to expect­ing them to come to where the activism was hap­pen­ing. She want­ed to find – and she did find – authen­tic ways of engag­ing with peo­ple to unleash their own power.”

The film is a culmination of the ways in which women have been sidelined in our society.

In one of The 8th’s most poignant scenes, Horan sits with col­leagues and friends in her salon as they exchange sto­ries of the harm the abor­tion ban has caused to them and their loved ones, the cam­era lin­ger­ing inti­mate­ly on clasped hands and Horan’s tear­ful face as she offers sup­port and sym­pa­thy. She’s just this extra­or­di­nary char­ac­ter who illus­trates how to bring peo­ple into activism in a way that suits them,” Kennedy says.

The painful lega­cy of the Eighth Amend­ment is pal­pa­ble through­out, from the tes­ti­monies giv­en in Horan’s salon to the more wide­ly pub­li­cised con­tem­po­rary accounts that Kane, Kennedy and O’Boyle refer to. These vignettes revolve around spe­cif­ic his­toric cas­es that were for­ma­tive to Ireland’s cur­rent pro-choice move­ment, such as the remains of neglect­ed chil­dren being dis­cov­ered in Catholic moth­er-and-baby homes, or the trag­ic case of Savi­ta Halap­panavar, who died from sep­sis after being refused an abor­tion fol­low­ing an incom­plete miscarriage.

Their com­bined pres­ence in the film under­scores not only the cru­el­ty and vio­lence of the amendment’s restric­tions, but also the ways in which these restric­tions – and the pol­i­tics of health­care more broad­ly – inevitably dis­crim­i­nate across exist­ing fault lines of class and race. If you think about it, the women who could afford to trav­el, trav­elled,” Kennedy says. They went to the UK [where] they could get child­care for their oth­er chil­dren. They could take that time off work. They could get a plane tick­et. It’s women who are on the mar­gins of soci­ety finan­cial­ly, who it was a big­ger bur­den for.”

Ini­tial­ly we want­ed to cov­er the last 100 years in Ire­land, but because the film is 90 min­utes long, we realised we would have more impact if we focused on the last 35,” O’Boyle adds. With Savita’s sto­ry, for exam­ple, we incor­po­rat­ed a num­ber of oth­er med­ical cas­es around that sec­tion to show this isn’t just a one off – there are many, many women who have been in hor­ren­dous sce­nar­ios. We were try­ing to speak to that, so by the end of the film it becomes a cul­mi­na­tion of the ways in which women have been side­lined for such a long time in our society.”

By bring­ing togeth­er long-neglect­ed sto­ries of women’s suf­fer­ing over decades of state-inflict­ed vio­lence, The 8th crafts a com­pelling, emo­tion­al­ly res­o­nant argu­ment for repro­duc­tive rights, align­ing itself in many ways with the activism it rep­re­sents. We didn’t come to the film as activists,” Kane reflects, we came to it as film­mak­ers, and ulti­mate­ly it’s a film about an extra­or­di­nar­i­ly suc­cess­ful grass­roots move­ment that won. We didn’t inten­tion­al­ly make this film to be an activist tool, but […] a lot of the reac­tion we’re get­ting in screen­ings… some­one said to us it fills an activist’s soul.”

When you’re mak­ing a film, what you’re ide­al­ly try­ing to do is doc­u­ment what you’re see­ing and how things are chang­ing,” O’Boyle adds. Ini­tial­ly this was about repro­duc­tive rights and abor­tion but as it con­tin­ued it [took on] this nar­ra­tive of care and com­pas­sion. There was this idea around what kind of soci­ety we want to be. Let’s look at our­selves in the mir­ror and say, Are we going to take responsibility?’”

Find out more at the8th​film​.com

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.