Volver | Little White Lies

Volver

24 Aug 2006 / Released: 25 Aug 2006

Woman with dark hair and red and green floral patterned dress looking directly at the camera with a serious expression.
Woman with dark hair and red and green floral patterned dress looking directly at the camera with a serious expression.
4

Anticipation.

A festival favourite from an art-house giant.

5

Enjoyment.

By turns shocking, serene, darkly funny and ruthlessly true. An all-too-rare cocktail of cinematic know-how and genuinely touching human drama.

4

In Retrospect.

There’s so much to drink in, but you worry that Almodóvar isn’t the man to excite the masses.

An all-too-rare cock­tail of cin­e­mat­ic know-how and gen­uine­ly touch­ing human drama.

This is a man’s world,” he sings, but James Brown didn’t sweep the dust from his own grave­stone. This is a man’s man’s man’s world,” he sings, but James Brown didn’t hear the howl­ing of the East Wind that dri­ves peo­ple insane. This is a man’s world,” he sings, but James Brown knows it wouldn’t mean noth­ing, noth­ing, not one lit­tle thing with­out a woman or a girl.

Pedro Almodóvar’s Volver is a woman’s world to the quick. They cook and cluck and kiss and, as the occa­sion demands, they kill. It means com­ing back’ in Eng­lish. It means com­ing back to La Man­cha, to com­e­dy, to reli­gion, rela­tion­ships and sex. It means com­ing back to Car­men Mau­ra after 17 years lost in the bit­ter­ness. It means com­ing back, so how is Volver so fresh, so inven­tive, so utter­ly alive with the joys of cinema?

In Madrid, Raimun­da (Pené­lope Cruz) lives with her young daugh­ter, Paula (Yohana Cobo) and her hus­band, Paco, in a tiny apart­ment. She works two jobs, menial ones, her hair teased into a bomb­shell of floor-scrub­bing chic, and it soon becomes clear that she’s the matri­arch of a bro­ken fam­i­ly. Her hus­band, Paco, slumps on a sofa drink­ing beer, grab­bing sly eye­fuls of his teenage daugh­ter. In the bed­room he’s all clum­sy come-ons, hap­py to crack one off while his wife cries her­self to sleep.

Raimunda’s sis­ter, Sole (Lola Dueñas), runs an ille­gal salon from the flat where she lives alone, aban­doned by her hus­band two years before. Here the local women gath­er to bitch about soap operas and receive mon­strous­ly out­ré hair-dos. She is old­er than Raimun­da, but timid – a for­lorn fig­ure who miss­es her par­ents, killed in a fire in La Man­cha sparked by the gusts of that East Wind.

Where Madrid is a city with­out char­ac­ter, its face­less sprawl and dusty car parks glimpsed through the win­dows of drab hous­es, La Man­cha is an icon of deep Spain. In the cap­i­tal, trash TV cre­ates a mod­ern mythol­o­gy of bet­ter liv­ing, but in the coun­try­side old ghosts still walk the streets. Though it has a toe dipped in the twen­ty-first cen­tu­ry (Cer­vantes’ wind­mills are sleek new tur­bines) the char­ac­ter of the place is lit­tle changed in 400 years.

This is the land of the dead, where women tend their grave­stones like a doorstep and death is a thresh­old kept as spot­less as any oth­er. Why not, in a town where the final fron­tier swings back and forth like a saloon door?

In La Man­cha, their Aunt Paula has died. At the funer­al, where the whole vil­lage has gath­ered (a coven of black-clad bat­tle axes flap­ping fans and fat dry lips at Sole), there are rumours that their moth­er, Irene, reap­peared to Paula as a ghost to help her through the last few months of her life. A neigh­bour, Agusti­na, has heard her voice.

Sole will be vis­it­ed by this spir­it – a bump in the night from the inside of her boot – who has unfin­ished busi­ness to set straight, but Raimun­da has oth­er con­cerns: her hus­band has made a mess of the kitchen and there’s seri­ous mop­ping to be done. There’s noth­ing in the good wife’s hand­book about remov­ing blood­stains from the floor. A knife in the chest isn’t your aver­age fam­i­ly cri­sis, but attempt­ing to rape your daugh­ter isn’t the aver­age dis­play of father­ly affection.

Volver is a film cut like glass. It refracts the gaze of the cin­e­ma screen, send­ing it spin­ning across gen­res like shafts of criss­cross­ing light. It’s as can­ny a movie as you’ll ever see, a film that chat­ters in your ear with crafti­ness, but it’s so beau­ti­ful­ly made, so del­i­cate­ly poised between art and art­ful­ness that it achieves a nat­u­ral­ness – a grace that gives its zigzag­ging emo­tion­al cadences an easy rhythm.

That the film slips so dizzy­ing­ly from com­e­dy to farce to tragedy, often in the same scene (Paco’s death is a mini mas­ter­class of dex­ter­ous genre hop­ping that twists and turns about the edge of a knife) is due to the per­for­mances. Almod­ó­var has said that he bran­dish­es actors like weapons; well if that’s so, Pené­lope Cruz is his nuclear but­ton. If any­thing, Volver is Cruz’s bit­ter rebuke to Hol­ly­wood – to Woman on Top and Cap­tain Corelli’s Man­dolin, to the whole TomKat, A list, Brangeli­na bol­locks of it all.

Raimun­da has a sul­try, kitchen sink sex­u­al­i­ty that strains the fab­ric of the screen just as her breasts bil­low dan­ger­ous­ly over the edges of those plung­ing neck­lines. Cruz is the proud pos­ses­sor of mas­sive tits, and Almod­ó­var is fas­ci­nat­ed by them. Twice oth­er char­ac­ters com­ment on them, while the direc­tor stares gog­gle-eyed over­head as she wash­es up, gold chains lost in an abyssal cleav­age. But in clas­sic Almod­ó­var style there’s a warn­ing note. He returns to this shot as Raimun­da scrubs the blood from the knife that killed her hus­band, lin­ger­ing on the trans­gres­sive prox­im­i­ty between eroti­cism and domes­tic rituals.

It’s the small details that make her – the ragged hand­ker­chief whipped from her bra, or the fact that she dri­ves her old­er sister’s car. She’s a tow­er­ing, ter­ri­fy­ing mon­u­ment to fem­i­nin­i­ty, an effort­less mul­ti­tasker who shops and cooks and digs unmarked graves while break­ing only the most serene of sweats. She’s Com­man­der-in-Chief of the tribe of women, press-gang­ing the neigh­bour­hood into a restau­rant scheme in one of those bril­liant­ly false movie moments that Almod­ó­var excels at.

But that’s not the whole sto­ry, either. As the films builds, a sub­tle shift takes place, and what seemed sexy and mod­ern as Raimun­da strut­ted down the street sud­den­ly looks trashy and nar­cis­sis­tic. Who does she think she is with her strap­py san­dals and emo­tion­al steam­rolling? What hypocrisy to say, Don’t com­pli­cate oth­er people’s lives,” to Agusti­na, after pay­ing a hook­er to help her bury her husband.

What self­ish­ness when Agusti­na is dying of can­cer, to refuse her last wish – to find Irene’s ghost and ask after Agustina’s own moth­er who dis­ap­peared the same day as that fatal fire. What arro­gance to deny it when she hears of the affair that Agustina’s moth­er and her own father were con­duct­ing. My moth­er wouldn’t allow it,” is all she’ll snap.

Raimun­da is for­giv­en in a jack­ham­mer final act, a reunion with Irene anchored by an exquis­ite­ly dark emo­tion­al pay off. It’s a sin­is­ter hint of the cycles of vio­lence and trans­gres­sion at the root of vil­lage life, and it’s also one more damn­ing indict­ment of the men who have ruined these women’s lives.

The men of La Man­cha are almost entire­ly absent – sour mem­o­ries and whis­pered secrets the only trace of their pass­ing. In a rare intru­sion, they stare out of the screen like a herd of ostrich­es, or a gag­gle of school­boys caught in some guilty act. At least Paco is dis­tin­guished by a name, though he’s hard­ly a flag car­ri­er for the broth­er­hood. And yet… Before Paula is molest­ed she vis­its Agusti­na with her aunt and moth­er. She sits apart from them, but the scene is deep staged so she stays in focus, legs slung lazi­ly over a chair; cav­a­lier, inno­cent, provocative.

If you won­dered about her then, if you care­less­ly imag­ined, should you see your­self in Paco’s lip-smack­ing look? When he mas­tur­bates next to his wife and a sin­gle tear rolls down her cheek, is there a sense of impli­ca­tion about it? Because it feels like a fin­ger point­ing out of the screen – use­less, horny, drunk­en layabouts. Maybe frat­ri­cide is the best thing that ever hap­pened to a fam­i­ly; after all, women are clear­ly bet­ter off with­out us.

If there’s an ambiva­lence to the film’s the­mat­ic focus, what’s not in doubt is that Volver is a prodi­gious­ly well-made movie, though not always in the ways you’d expect. Almod­ó­var is an urban­ite by habit, tilt­ing at the absur­di­ties of Span­ish soci­ety. But in Volver his out­ra­geous­ness is tem­pered by introspection.

In return­ing to La Man­cha, the town where his own moth­er lived and died, it’s as if the arch provo­ca­teur has redis­cov­ered some­thing of his own Quixot­ic sen­si­bil­i­ty. Through this film,” he said, I have gone through a mourn­ing peri­od that I need­ed. I have said good­bye to some­thing which I had not yet said good­bye, and need­ed to.”

Pick apart the farce, the camp, and the dirty jokes and what’s left is a sense of qui­et heart­break. Volver is flam­boy­ant­ly con­ceived – full of visu­al cun­ning and con­ceits – but it’s filmed with sin­cer­i­ty, at times a con­fes­sion­al sim­plic­i­ty that’s both poignant and ele­gant. It’s not that Almod­ó­var is grow­ing up or calm­ing down, wor­ry­ing­ly for the rest of the Euro art house pack, it just seems like he’s get­ting better.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.