The Teachers’ Lounge review – a chain-reaction… | Little White Lies

The Teach­ers’ Lounge review – a chain-reac­tion melodrama

21 Mar 2024 / Released: 22 Mar 2024

Four adults in a classroom setting, a young woman in a red jumper seated at a desk holding a coffee cup.
Four adults in a classroom setting, a young woman in a red jumper seated at a desk holding a coffee cup.
3

Anticipation.

Çatak’s thriller-drama drew comparisons to Uncut Gems and was nominated for an Oscar.

2

Enjoyment.

Strains credulity through relentless escalations that rarely push it past a didactic realm.

2

In Retrospect.

Too in thrall to its fashionable dramatics to interrogate the questions its premise poses.

A new teacher is tasked with find­ing out which of her stu­dents is respon­si­ble for a series of thefts in Ilk­er Çatak’s drama.

In Micro­cos­mo­graphia Acad­e­mia’, his satir­i­cal trea­tise on uni­ver­si­ty pol­i­tics, Edwar­dian schol­ar F.M. Corn­ford pro­posed that, there is only one argu­ment for doing some­thing; the rest are argu­ments for doing noth­ing. The argu­ment for doing some­thing is that it is the right thing to do. But then, of course, comes the dif­fi­cul­ty of mak­ing sure it is right.”

Such are the emphat­i­cal­ly rhetor­i­cal prin­ci­ples, the rules of inac­tion, that impel İlker Çatak’s Oscar-nom­i­nat­ed The Teach­ers’ Lounge, a dra­ma set in a Ger­man sec­ondary school rat­tled by accu­sa­tions of theft. For sev­enth-grade teacher Car­la (Leonie Benesch, tedious­ly ultra-tense), a sen­si­tive edu­ca­tor who innate­ly sees her­self on the side of the stu­dents, the inci­dents hold the ide­al­is­tic promise of a teach­able moment, until her efforts to do some­thing about them inflict irrec­on­cil­able dif­fi­cul­ties that Corn­ford, who’d been writ­ing about the Cam­bridge scene in 1908, could have hard­ly fore­seen. After all, nobody had smart­phones back then.

The staff’s efforts to iden­ti­fy the thief leads first to vio­la­tions of pupils’ rights, as in a meet­ing between Car­la, her sin­gle-mind­ed col­leagues, and two stu­dents they pres­sure into iden­ti­fy­ing class­mates they pre­sume to be guilty. Once one of her stu­dents is sus­pect­ed, Car­la believes wrong­ly, she sur­veils the teach­ers’ lounge, leav­ing her lap­top cam­era to record some­body lift­ing cash out of the wal­let she left in her jack­et. Rec­og­niz­ing a pat­tern vis­i­ble on the sleeve of the shirt the appar­ent thief was wear­ing, Car­la iden­ti­fies sec­re­tary Ms Kuhn (Eva Löbau).

Yet Kuhn denies the charges so vehe­ment­ly it takes Car­la by sur­prise and caus­es oth­ers to ques­tion their alle­giances. Mak­ing mat­ters worse, Car­la has Kuhn’s son, Oskar (Leonard Stet­tnisch), in class; hav­ing alien­at­ed a promis­ing stu­dent, Car­la fights to regain his trust.

The idea of schools as micro­cosms of soci­ety, reflect­ing polit­i­cal and eco­nom­ic dynam­ics while serv­ing as self-con­tra­dict­ing sys­tems of inclu­sion and exclu­sion, is well-estab­lished. Jean Vigo’s clas­sic Zero for Con­duct cap­tures youth in revolt through anar­chic inter­play of real­ism and sur­re­al­ism that hon­ours childhood’s poten­tial; Fred­er­ick Wiseman’s High School, mean­while, was the documentarian’s first study of civic engage­ment and social struc­tures sub­sum­ing individuals.

Less pro­duc­tive­ly, more trendi­ly, Çatak’s film becomes a chain-reac­tion melo­dra­ma: act­ed by self-seri­ous types, scored by tight­ly wound strings, depen­dent on char­ac­ters say­ing the wrong things and leav­ing the right ones unsaid with jaws firm­ly, sar­don­ical­ly clenched. No sit­u­a­tion is resolved, no assump­tion proven; nobody’s lis­ten­ing, just react­ing as if written.

Ruinous as it is, the action remains rhetor­i­cal, even as it esca­lates. Savvy in their choice of sce­nario, Çatak and co-writer Johannes Dunck­er emerge cal­low and obliv­i­ous in their gener­ic, moral­is­tic cri­tique of the codes of con­duct gov­ern­ing our schools. Fore­cast­ing an abstract dooms­day, they intro­duce an omi­nous count­down that nev­er hits zero, draw­ing few con­clu­sions and even less blood.

Lit­tle White Lies is com­mit­ted to cham­pi­oning great movies and the tal­ent­ed peo­ple who make them.

By becom­ing a mem­ber you can sup­port our inde­pen­dent jour­nal­ism and receive exclu­sive essays, prints, week­ly film rec­om­men­da­tions and more.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.