Playwright-turned-filmmaker Florian Zeller's follow-up to The Father fails to achieve the emotional resonance of its predecessor.
With The Father, Florian Zeller created a claustrophobic, deeply affecting chamber piece on the subject of dementia that earned Anthony Hopkins his second Academy Award. His follow-up feature is an adaptation of another play in his trilogy – The Son – but unfortunately fails to make the same emotional impact as his strong debut, despite a starry cast and worthy subject matter.
Seventeen-year-old Nicholas (Zen McGrath) has been struggling since his parents Kate (Laura Dern) and Peter (Hugh Jackman) divorced. Peter now lives with Beth (Vanessa Kirby), the woman he left his wife for, and they have an infant son together, while Nicholas lives with his mother. After learning that their son has been skipping school for over a month, Kate and Peter confront Nicholas, who admits he is struggling with his mental health and now wishes to live with Peter, Beth and baby Theo. Despite Beth’s initial reservations about having a mentally ill teenager in the house with her new baby, he moves in with them, and things seem to be improving for Nicholas, at least for a little while.
Where The Father deftly navigated the disorientating impact of dementia upon both the person with the condition and those close to them, The Son fails to find quite such sure footing in its depiction of adolescent depression and suicidal ideation, in part because we experience this largely through Peter rather than Nicholas, whose character is so thinly realised it’s an uphill battle for McGrath to give him any sort of dimension. It’s difficult to tell if he is merely miscast or underserved by the script.
We know Nicholas is depressed, and it’s largely a result of his feelings of rejection following his father leaving his mother, but there’s precious little else to him – no sense of his interests, personality, or aspirations beyond vague references to him wanting to be a writer. When Peter refers to how clever and sensitive his son is, it’s lazy shorthand for character development that isn’t embedded in the script or performance.
The dialogue itself is stagey and unconvincing, as though little has been done to adapt Zeller’s original play for the screen, and while these heightened exchanges worked within the conceptual framing of The Father, here they seem clunky and awkward – this is a more conventional cinematic approach to drama. While the play was set entirely in Peter and Beth’s apartment, Zeller opens the world up a little more here. Perhaps Zeller didn’t want to risk repeating his work on The Father, but by opting for a more open setting some of the intimacy of The Son is lost, and the apartment itself where most of Peter and Nicholas’s exchanges take place lacks the intricate set design of its predecessor.
The subject of depression and suicidal thoughts in teenagers is still surrounded by stigma, and many parents struggle to speak to their children about the topic – in theory, The Son has a rich, worthy subject at its center and could be a progressive take on the mental health crisis facing many adolescents. But the film feels binary in its thinking, and while we’re told that Peter is doing everything he can to reconnect with his son and help to change his self-destructive thought patterns and behaviours, there’s little evidence to back this up.
Even the magnetic likes of Jackman, Dern and Kirby are wasted here, to the extent that by the time The Son reaches its miserable, cloying foregone conclusion, it’s a relief to be free of the uninspired direction and paint-by-numbers interrogation of a subject that deserves much more depth.
Little White Lies is committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them.
Published 14 Feb 2023
The Father was tremendous. Will lightning strike twice?
Lightning will not strike twice.
Relentlessly miserable and reductive filmmaking.
Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.
