The Pale Blue Eye | Little White Lies

The Pale Blue Eye

22 Dec 2022 / Released: 23 Dec 2022

Two men in dark clothing toasting with drinks at a rustic wooden table lit by candles in a dimly lit room.
Two men in dark clothing toasting with drinks at a rustic wooden table lit by candles in a dimly lit room.
3

Anticipation.

Great cast...

2

Enjoyment.

...Glacial pace.

3

In Retrospect.

The clever, compelling double-solution elevates this slow thriller.

A hard­ened detec­tive teams up with a young Edgar Allen Poe to solve a mur­der in Scott Coop­er’s chilly thriller.

You wait ages for one fic­tion­alised detec­tive sto­ry fea­tur­ing Edgar Allen Poe dur­ing his cadet­ship years at the Unit­ed States Mil­i­tary Acad­e­my in West Point, New York, and then two come along. Yet where Christo­pher Hatton’s Raven’s Hol­low was so deeply engaged with the super­nat­ur­al that it felt like some­thing out of the Broth­ers Grimm (or per­haps Wash­ing­ton Irv­ing), Scott Cooper’s The Pale Blue Eye is root­ed in the ratio­nal (even if some of its char­ac­ters dab­ble in Satan­ic rit­u­al, and Poe him­self claims as evi­dence mes­sages sent to him in his dreams by his dear depart­ed mother).

Of course, both films are pep­pered with ravens, tell-tale hearts, gloomy ceme­ter­ies, ref­er­ences to Lenore, and oth­er pre­fig­u­ra­tions (includ­ing the detec­tive for­mat itself) of Poe’s lat­er writ­ings, as if we were wit­ness­ing the mak­ing of the man, or at least a reimag­in­ing of his for­ma­tive expe­ri­ences and inspirations.

Adapt­ed from Louis Bayard’s 2006 nov­el of the same name, The Pale Blue Eye takes place in and around the Acad­e­my itself, after the body of a Cadet has been found hang­ing from a tree, and the corpse sub­se­quent­ly des­e­crat­ed, with the heart carved from its chest. This leads Colonel Sawyer (Tim­o­thy Spall) and his sec­ond-in-com­mand Cap­tain Hitch­cock (Simon McBur­ney) to turn for help to wid­owed police offi­cer Augus­tus Lan­dor (Chris­t­ian Bale, also in Cooper’s Out of the Fur­nace and Hos­tiles), who lives local­ly and has a rep­u­ta­tion for solv­ing dif­fi­cult cas­es. Haunt­ed by the dis­ap­pear­ance of his beloved daugh­ter Mad­die, Lan­dor is a bit­ter, bro­ken man who has turned his back on God – but he nonethe­less agrees to con­duct a dis­creet inves­ti­ga­tion, and quick­ly deter­mines that the death was not a sui­cide but a murder.

Soon Lan­dor part­ners up with Cadet Poe (Har­ry Melling), an eccen­tric mis­fit in this envi­ron­ment but also clear­ly a man of sig­nif­i­cant tal­ents, and the old­er and younger man, like William and Adso in The Name of the Rose, set about find­ing the killer togeth­er even as more bod­ies, both ani­mal and human, are found with their hearts and oth­er parts miss­ing. Lan­dor and Poe are drawn to the Academy’s doc­tor Mar­quis (Toby Jones), his neu­rot­ic wife Julia (Gillian Ander­son), their Cadet son Artemis (Har­ry Lawtey) and sick­ly daugh­ter Leah (Lucy Boyn­ton) – a cul­tured if dys­func­tion­al clan who may some­how be con­nect­ed to all the occult killings – even as the evi­dence starts point­ing towards Poe himself.

The Pale Blue Eye is all at once a melan­cholic romance, a revenger’s tragedy, and an intrigu­ing mys­tery. Its one prob­lem, though, is that it comes with a glacial pace to match its win­try set­ting. By the time the main plot has reached some­thing like a con­clu­sion and been offi­cial­ly wrapped up, the film lurch­es on into a lengthy coda which recasts the film’s events in a rather dif­fer­ent light – and while this sec­ond solu­tion is inge­nious and sat­is­fy­ing and packs a real emo­tion­al punch, its impact is under­mined by com­ing so late in a film that has already felt on the long side.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.