The Dark Tower | Little White Lies

The Dark Tower

19 Aug 2017 / Released: 18 Aug 2017

Words by Elena Lazic

Directed by Nikolaj Arcel

Starring Idris Elba, Matthew McConaughey, and Tom Taylor

A man in a long coat stands on a rocky hillside.
A man in a long coat stands on a rocky hillside.
3

Anticipation.

The one has been in the works for a long time, which isn’t usually a good sign.

1

Enjoyment.

Not even bad enough to be fun.

1

In Retrospect.

Surely one of the least memorable King adaptations there is.

Idris Elba plays a cos­mic gun­slinger in this tame adap­ta­tion of Stephen King’s fan­ta­sy saga.

In a nor­mal year, a high-pro­file Stephen King adap­ta­tion would be await­ed with some degree of antic­i­pa­tion. But this is no nor­mal year. The Dark Tow­er, a fea­ture film based on King’s eight-book fan­ta­sy series, is just one of sev­en adap­ta­tions of his work set for 2017.

There’s a tenth Chil­dren of the Corn movie arriv­ing soon on home video, while Net­flix has promised fea­ture-length ver­sions of Gerald’s Game’ and 1922′ before the year is out. On net­work tele­vi­sion The Mist series pre­miered in June, while a minis­eries based on King’s ter­rif­ic crime nov­el Mr Mer­cedes’ has aired in the US. Above all else, of course, is IT, which promis­es to be a ter­ri­fy­ing update of the cult 1990 miniseries.

Such a wealth of King con­tent presents no small chal­lenge for a film to make its mark, and for a time Niko­laj Arcel’s mega-bud­get The Dark Tow­er seemed a promis­ing con­tender, espe­cial­ly with two majors stars in tow. Yet it now remains entire­ly in the hands of Bill Skarsgård’s new scary clown to do jus­tice to King’s work at the cin­e­ma, as The Dark Tow­er is noth­ing short of a total misfire.

While wild and over-the-top King adap­ta­tions are often the most fun (and, indeed, most faith­ful to his work), The Dark Tow­er com­mits the far worse crime of turn­ing what could have been an epic, strange adven­ture into some­thing com­plete­ly devoid of the author’s trade­mark obses­sive­ness, atmos­phere and gen­uine attach­ment to well-drawn characters.

With its epic scope, colour­ful char­ac­ters and bonkers plot­ting, the stuff nec­es­sary for a tru­ly grip­ping film is unde­ni­ably all there. The film begins with Jake Cham­bers (Tom Tay­lor), a young kid liv­ing in New York with his moth­er and step-dad, still unsure whether his vivid dreams about a Tow­er under attack have any­thing to do with real­i­ty. But rather than explore the kid’s para­noia and absolute ter­ror when he comes face to face with the vil­lains of his night­mares, the film instead adopts the lev­el­ling tone of a time-hon­oured adven­ture yarn, sleep­walk­ing from one plot point to the next with­out pay­ing much atten­tion to the fact that this kid is sup­posed to be just like the rest of us.

This makes even the entrance of Idris Elba’s Gun­slinger, and his abil­i­ty to make bul­lets ric­o­chet off one anoth­er (!), feel rather tame and unex­cit­ing. This mut­ing even effects Matthew McConaugh­ey – often swing­ing his arms around for no appar­ent rea­son – who turns up in the unusu­al­ly low-key role of the evil, sadis­tic Man in Black. The final con­fronta­tion between these two A‑grade movie stars is nowhere near as sus­pense­ful as it should be, arriv­ing as it does after a clash between the man bent on destroy­ing the uni­verse and the only per­son who can stop him.

It’s almost as if a con­scious effort has been made to make this mix of west­ern, sci-fi and time trav­el genre ele­ments as banal as pos­si­ble. Deliv­er­ing only a hint of King’s vast and com­plex uni­verse, and with very broad char­ac­ters, the film fails on all counts, being nei­ther as nerdy or acces­si­ble as it might have been. That it nev­er seems com­plete­ly ridicu­lous or try-hard is per­haps the only sil­ver lining.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.