On the Basis of Sex | Little White Lies

On the Basis of Sex

20 Feb 2019 / Released: 08 Feb 2019

Words by Hannah Strong

Directed by Mimi Leder

Starring Armie Hammer, Felicity Jones, and Justin Theroux

Several businesspeople in formal attire, with a woman in the centre wearing a green coat.
Several businesspeople in formal attire, with a woman in the centre wearing a green coat.
3

Anticipation.

Not sure Felicity Jones is the best casting choice.

3

Enjoyment.

Curiously devoid of personality for a biopic.

2

In Retrospect.

A paint-by-numbers portrait of an American icon.

Felic­i­ty Jones takes on the man­tle of Supreme Court Jus­tice Ruth Bad­er Gins­burg in this earnest but tooth­less biopic.

Affec­tion­ate­ly referred to as The Noto­ri­ous RBG’ by fans, Supreme Court Jus­tice Ruth Bad­er Gins­burg is an endur­ing polit­i­cal and pop cul­ture pres­ence in the Unit­ed States. Hav­ing fought against sex­ism and anti­semitism to achieve one of the high­est judi­cial offices in the land, it’s per­haps sur­pris­ing that Hol­ly­wood didn’t get around to mak­ing a glossy biopic about her sooner.

Step for­ward Felic­i­ty Jones, the bright-eyed British actor who received a Best Actress Oscar nom­i­na­tion for her role as Stephen Hawking’s wife Jane in The The­o­ry of Every­thing back in 2014. She’s cast as the indomitable Gins­burg, known for her diminu­tive stature and dis­tinc­tive Brook­lyn twang, but it feels like a strange choice, not least because she doesn’t pull off the accent.

Along­side her is Armie Ham­mer as Ruth’s hus­band and biggest sup­port­er Mar­ty, and the pair head up a pro­gres­sive fam­i­ly in the late 1950s, with Ruth one of the first women admit­ted to Har­vard Law School. What fol­lows is a pot­ted his­to­ry of the Bad­er Gins­burg clan, cov­er­ing Ruth’s uphill bat­tle to raise her fam­i­ly while also con­tend­ing with the pres­sures of a misog­y­nist legal sys­tem, and tend­ing to her hus­band fol­low­ing his recent can­cer diagnosis.

It’s a dif­fi­cult thing to con­dense a 60-year career into two-hours, and the unin­spired for­mal­i­ty of the nar­ra­tive means that most of Leder’s film feels like it’s going through the motions, a cin­e­mat­ic ren­der­ing of a Wikipedia page biography.

By the time Gins­burg takes on the sex­u­al dis­crim­i­na­tion case that kicked-start­ed her career as a lawyer, we only real­ly get a sense for how dull Amer­i­can lit­i­ga­tion is. Justin Ther­oux has fun as Ginsburg’s friend and some­time adver­sary Mel Wulf, and the scenes of them butting heads pro­vide a lit­tle colour in what oth­er­wise amounts to a fair­ly dry affair, with lit­tle of the wit or per­son­al­i­ty which the real-life Gins­burg so rich­ly possesses.

Even a cameo from RBG her­self feels impos­si­bly twee, a cringe-induc­ing ren­der­ing of what girl pow­er’ must look like to a room full of stu­dio execs. If you’re real­ly keen to learn more about Gins­burg, you might do bet­ter with Julie Cohen and Bet­sy West’s doc­u­men­tary, RBG.

You might like