The Brand New Testament | Little White Lies

The Brand New Testament

14 Apr 2016 / Released: 25 Mar 2016

Large black furry gorilla showing teeth, with a woman in the background.
Large black furry gorilla showing teeth, with a woman in the background.
1

Anticipation.

Belgian comedy is often hit-or-miss, sometimes worth to risk two hours of your time.

2

Enjoyment.

Time passes slowly and fades away and ‘love’ definitely isn’t ‘loving’.

2

In Retrospect.

Do not waste the unknown number of hours of life you have left on incoherent schmaltz.

This sac­cha­rine reli­gious com­e­dy from Belgium’s Jaco Van Dor­mael fails to live up to its ini­tial promise.

The var­i­ous depress­ing glob­al events which coloured the end of 2015 and the begin­ning of 2016, added to the the unusu­al fre­quen­cy with which beloved celebri­ties have been dying, could tru­ly make any­one take the premise of The Brand New Tes­ta­ment very seri­ous­ly indeed. Maybe the rea­son why this world often seems cru­el is that God him­self – sup­pos­ing he exists – is a bit­ter and self­ish man.

In Jaco Van Dormael’s film, God takes the shape of actor Benoît Poelvo­orde, whose cus­tom­ary screams, erup­tions of vio­lence and brash dynamism are employed here to the full. For undis­closed rea­sons, God lives in Brus­sels with his shy and qui­et wife and their daugh­ter Ea (Pili Groyne), who begins to fol­low in the rebel­lious foot­steps of her broth­er, JC (David Mur­gia). One day, tired of His inhu­man­i­ty, she final­ly decides to enter her dad’s pri­vate room. Using the com­put­er with which He con­trols the world, Ea decides to reveal to every human being their date of death via text mes­sage. If one can accept the very ordi­nary world so far estab­lished, the effects of Ea’s action mark the begin­ning of the film’s down­ward spi­ral into the irri­tat­ing and the incoherent.

Ea’s inten­tion when send­ing these fate­ful texts only becomes clear when her broth­er JC states it him­self and his pre­dic­tions are con­firmed. Know­ing the exact moment of their death, peo­ple lose faith in God and decide to act accord­ing only to their desires. How­ev­er, one could imag­ine anoth­er ver­sion of the script where, know­ing how short a time they have before Judg­ment Day, peo­ple would become extreme­ly devout and thus empow­er this God, how­ev­er severe He may have been. It is nat­u­ral­ly point­less to crit­i­cise a film based on what it does not do rather than on what it does, but the chain of events trig­gered by Ea nev­er quite con­vinces and thus pro­ceeds on shaky foundations.

The Brand New Tes­ta­ment relies on that typ­i­cal­ly Bel­gian hybrid of tones, where bleak­ness and vio­lence are con­trast­ed with syrupy sen­ti­men­tal­ism. The lat­ter pro­gres­sive­ly dom­i­nates the film, and with mixed results, as Ea goes in search of the six mor­tals she has cho­sen to add to the exist­ing 12 apos­tles. These char­ac­ters come from dras­ti­cal­ly dif­fer­ent walks of life and each sto­ry of redis­cov­ery in the face of death is pre­sent­ed as a new gospel. Their mean­ings, how­ev­er, are not as dis­tinct as the pro­tag­o­nists them­selves. The pro­gres­sive inter­sec­tion of their sto­ries could have been con­struc­tive and pow­er­ful had Van Dor­mael not cho­sen to pro­mote a defen­si­ble yet sim­pli­fy­ing and mud­dled roman­ti­cism. His good inten­tions lim­it his scope to the Pow­er of Love instead of widen­ing it to the entire spec­trum of the human experience.

The epi­logue fur­ther under­mines the per­sua­sive­ness and cred­i­bil­i­ty of the director’s good heart. Sud­den­ly, touch­es of utopi­an and fan­tas­tic fem­i­nism, envi­ron­men­tal­ism (more pre­cise­ly, tol­er­at­ed inter-species romance) and right­ful dras­tic pun­ish­ment appear as last minute flour­ish­es rather than cen­tral con­cerns. Human­i­ty will have to wait if it wants anoth­er, more cred­i­ble Testament.

You might like