A Bunch of Amateurs | Little White Lies

A Bunch of Amateurs

11 Nov 2022

Words by Marina Ashioti

Directed by Kim Hopkins

A stone building with a clock tower on a hilltop, silhouetted against a sunset sky. A person on a white horse in the foreground, with chickens nearby.
A stone building with a clock tower on a hilltop, silhouetted against a sunset sky. A person on a white horse in the foreground, with chickens nearby.
4

Anticipation.

Kim Hopkins’ doc took home the Audience Award at Sheffield Doc/Fest.

3

Enjoyment.

Can feel slightly directionless at parts, but never not heartwarming.

4

In Retrospect.

Comes together as a wistful reflection on the power of cinema and community in the face of adversity.

A charm­ing doc­u­men­tary about Britain’s old­est ama­teur film­mak­ing club puts a quin­tes­sen­tial­ly North­ern sto­ry in the spotlight.

A Bunch of Ama­teurs, the lat­est doc­u­men­tary by Kim Hop­kins, opens with a quote by Susan Son­tag – If cinephil­ia is dead, then movies are dead too”. At a time where film view­ing is steadi­ly becom­ing more dis­persed and indi­vid­u­alised, a small yet keen com­mu­ni­ty of ama­teur film­mak­ers known as the Brad­ford Movie Mak­ers heed­ed Sontag’s call.

The Brad­ford Movie Mak­ers have been meet­ing every sin­gle Mon­day since 1932. Need­less to say, their club­house has seen bet­ter days. Hop­kins’ cam­era cap­tures their run­down build­ing from every angle: its out­side premis­es have become a fly-tip­ping hotspot, a dump­ing ground for waste and van­dal­ism; its insides crum­ble to the touch. Among dwin­dling num­bers of new mem­bers and finan­cial insta­bil­i­ty due to being five years behind on rent pay­ments, there doesn’t seem to be much room for opti­mism with­in Britain’s old­est ama­teur film­mak­ing enclave as it teeters on the edge of survival.

What used to be a thriv­ing com­mu­ni­ty of north­ern cinephiles bond­ing over their pas­sions now appears on our screens as a seem­ing­ly niche group of elders who split their time between watch­ing films, revis­it­ing reels of their ear­ly shorts and remak­ing scenes from old favourites (in this case, the icon­ic open­ing sequence from Okla­homa!) on the slimmest of bud­gets. Bick­er­ing, gen­er­a­tional dif­fer­ences, ego clash­es and cups of tea abound, but the com­mu­ni­ty approach to film­mak­ing always shines through.

Hop­kins eschews spec­ta­cle and sen­ti­men­tal­i­ty while also doing away with inven­tive sto­ry­telling devices. A char­ac­ter-dri­ven, ver­ité approach pro­vides a deft-enough frame­work to han­dle his­tor­i­cal sweep and inti­mate moments between the club mem­bers with equal steadi­ness. The film is strength­ened by Leah Marino’s tight, play­ful edit­ing, while a hand­held cam­era flu­id­ly fol­lows and delin­eates the film’s sub­jects with­out a need for oth­er devices, prompt­ing an immer­sion that does not seek to ide­alise this live­ly bunch of idio­syn­crat­ic film buffs as con­gru­ent heroes. Their ama­teur projects are sub­ject to nei­ther praise nor ridicule, as Hop­kins’ can­did doc­u­men­tary approach allows fond­ness to blos­som through an embrace of res­ig­na­tion, rather than idle observation.

While the Covid-19 pan­dem­ic left work­ing class­es and the elder­ly more vul­ner­a­ble and iso­lat­ed than ever, it comes as a bless­ing in dis­guise for the Brad­ford Movie Mak­ers. An unex­pect­ed turn of events reignites hopes that the club can stop at noth­ing, even in the face of unprece­dent­ed uncer­tain­ties and shift­ing indus­try dynam­ics. Spend­ing 95 min­utes in their com­pa­ny is a joy.

You might like