West of Memphis | Little White Lies

West of Memphis

20 Dec 2012 / Released: 21 Dec 2012

Words by Andrew Simpson

Directed by Amy Berg

Starring N/A

Woman standing in a field, wearing a black jacket and jeans, looking up at the sky.
Woman standing in a field, wearing a black jacket and jeans, looking up at the sky.
2

Anticipation.

Do we really need another film about the West Memphis Three?

3

Enjoyment.

Utterly gripping and impressively cinematic, if perhaps a little too on message.

3

In Retrospect.

After your blood has stopped boiling, it’s the quieter moments that stay with you. Now go see Paradise Lost.

The strange case of the West Mem­phis Three is trans­formed into a(nother) riv­et­ing doc­u­men­tary care of direc­tor Amy Berg.

Three chil­dren, sav­age­ly mur­dered; a reck­less police force; para­noid fears of dev­il wor­ship; three mis­un­der­stood teenagers; and a 20-year strug­gle for free­dom. These are just some of the ele­ments that make up Amy Berg’s West Of Mem­phis, the lat­est doc­u­men­tary to take on the sub­ject of the West Mem­phis Three.

Dis­tin­guished by its arrival in the wake of the Three’s recent release (as well as the pres­ence of long­time sup­port­er Peter Jack­son as pro­duc­er) those who thought Thomas Vinterberg’s The Hunt was a pow­er­ful tale of injus­tice are advised to brace themselves.

Char­ac­terised by dra­mat­ic twists and stranger-than-fic­tion plot points, the ordeal of Damien Echols, Jason Bald­win and Jessie Miskel­ley Jr could be the stuff of over­cooked pro­ce­dur­al dra­ma. Indeed Atom Egoyan’s Devil’s Knot – star­ring Col­in Firth and Reese With­er­spoon – will give the sto­ry the Hol­ly­wood treat­ment in 2013, and the case has already pro­vid­ed the sub­ject for sev­er­al doc­u­men­taries, not least Joe Berlinger and Bruce Sinofsky’s game-chang­ing Par­adise Lost trilogy.

All of which might beg the ques­tion of where West of Mem­phis fits in, if it were not for the film’s sense of per­spec­tive. Where­as Par­adise Lost offered impas­sioned, present tense accounts that helped recruit the likes of John­ny Depp, Eddie Ved­der and Jack­son to the West Mem­phis Three cause, Berg’s film is a pacy, often reel­ing glance back­wards, both a call to arms and a rec­ol­lec­tion of a night­mare that is only just ending.

Con­dens­ing near­ly twen­ty years of inves­ti­ga­tions, appeals and rev­e­la­tions into a con­sis­tent­ly engross­ing 150 min­utes, this is a whis­tle-stop tour of the major facts: the three heavy met­al-lov­ing out­casts’ 1993 arrest; the lead­ing inter­ro­ga­tion of the bor­der­line-men­tal­ly dis­abled Miskel­ley; the expert tes­ti­monies since ripped apart by qual­i­fied experts; and the even­tu­al release of the men on a fudged plea bargain.

That West Of Mem­phis remains con­sis­tent­ly engag­ing even for those famil­iar with the case would be enough in itself, but this being a film made explic­it­ly by West Mem­phis Three sup­port­ers, it is also an account of the pow­er of cin­e­ma to affect change. Tak­ing its cue from Par­adise Lost, which helped cre­ate the enor­mous crowd-sourced cam­paign that even­tu­al­ly freed the three, West of Mem­phis stakes a bold claim for rel­e­vance by going all out in its final act assault on a new suspect.

Berg’s film proves best, though, when it momen­tar­i­ly gives up the cause. Jessie Miskel­ley Jr’s return to his trail­er park com­mu­ni­ty is full of eerie trep­i­da­tion, whilst Pam Hicks talks of grief for her mur­dered child and mar­riage to the now impli­cat­ed Ter­ry Hobbs, whose own daugh­ter appears to speak of the addic­tion and depres­sion caused by her father’s abuse. Pre­sum­ably includ­ed to fur­ther impli­cate its sus­pect, it instead pro­vides the film’s most mov­ing moment, a reminder of the wider effects of awful crimes.

Like any attempt to com­press tor­tured his­to­ry, West Of Mem­phis is by no means defin­i­tive. Miss­ing many of Par­adise Lost’s fas­ci­nat­ing nuances – at the very least Berg should have giv­en more screen time to the venge­ful community’s fire-and-brim­stone Greek cho­rus, Mark Byers – it is nev­er­the­less a com­pelling take on a stag­ger­ing sto­ry, intro­duc­ing new infor­ma­tion with a keen sense of drama.

Its taut nar­ra­tive con­trol can occa­sion­al­ly come off as glossy cam­paign­ing, but it lets in just enough heart­break to become a fit­ting tes­ta­ment to human tragedy.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.