Valkyrie | Little White Lies

Valkyrie

23 Jan 2009

Words by Matt Bochenski

Directed by Bryan Singer

Starring Bill Nighy, Carice van Houten, and Tom Cruise

A man in military uniform standing by a window with a serious expression.
A man in military uniform standing by a window with a serious expression.
2

Anticipation.

Epic bad buzz. A German-themed Mission: Impossible, or just an impossible mission to sit through it?

3

Enjoyment.

Valkyrie is a solid, old-fashioned action yarn with plenty of tense twists and thrills.

3

In Retrospect.

Don’t believe the hype.

Tom Cruise plays a Nazi with a moral com­pass in this drab his­tor­i­cal dra­ma from direc­tor Bryan Singer.

Only God can judge us now,” says Colonel Claus von Stauf­fen­berg. But then, von Stauf­fen­berg didn’t live to see the inter­net. How do you approach a film like Valkyrie? Do you pre­tend not to have heard the end­less chat­ter? The bad buzz? Do you polite­ly ignore the release date changes? Because make no mis­take: this film was meant to be awful. Tom Cruise as a Nazi? What else could he bring to the role except inevitable failure?

Von Stauf­fen­berg is one of the few Ger­man heroes of World War 2. He led a group of high-rank­ing offi­cers in a dar­ing plot to assas­si­nate Hitler and take con­trol of Berlin. The plan was to blow-up the Führer in his bunker, blame the attack on an SS coup, sev­er com­mu­ni­ca­tions to the out­side world and put Oper­a­tion Valkyrie’ into effect; a stand­ing order that would give the nation­al guard the author­i­ty to seize con­trol of key areas, while the plot­ters qui­et­ly installed a rev­o­lu­tion­ary gov­ern­ment that would end the war.

What hubris, then, for the all-Amer­i­can Cruise to appro­pri­ate – no, steal! – this role for him­self. And espe­cial­ly at a time when the Ger­mans them­selves have been knock­ing out supe­ri­or, sub­ver­sive war films, from Down­fall to The Coun­ter­feit­ers. They have the infra­struc­ture, the tal­ent and the right; what does Tom Cruise have? The name and the cheque­book. For over a year now the knives have been sharp­ened: Valkyrie was so bad, so doomed, so utter­ly ill-con­ceived that it was going to destroy Cruise, bring down Unit­ed Artists and leave Sci­en­tol­ogy itself in ash­es. Oh, and it’s respon­si­ble for the cred­it crunch, too.

But this nar­ra­tive for­gets two things. The first is that the direc­tor, Bryan Singer, is a past mas­ter of edge-of-the-seat film­mak­ing. The sec­ond, more con­tro­ver­sial­ly, is that Tom Cruise is a stu­pen­dous­ly charis­mat­ic movie star and an actor of proven pedi­gree. Put the two of them togeth­er and what do you think you’re going to get?

A dis­as­ter? Well, no, sor­ry. Valkyrie may not be awards bait but it is a sol­id, at times grip­ping, thriller that wrings every ounce of dra­ma out of what is, at heart, a pul­sat­ing tale of the courage and ide­al­ism of some undone by the cow­ardice and pol­i­tics of others.

There are, of course, prob­lems – most obvi­ous­ly with the cast­ing. The Ger­man high com­mand is a Who’s Who of British thes­ps includ­ing Ken­neth Bran­gah, Tom Wilkin­son, Ter­ence Stamp, Bill Nighy and (ahem) Eddie Izzard. It’s as if an elite RADA class has been tak­en hostage by the Nazis. But the film­mak­ers do their best to move us past the dis­cor­dance between what we’re see­ing and what we’re hear­ing. In a neat trick, the film begins with the Ger­man Walküre’ mor­ph­ing into Valkyrie’, while Cruise begins his voiceover in Ger­man before switch­ing to Eng­lish. It’s not the most ele­gant of solu­tions, but it works if you’re pre­pared to take a leap of imagination.

At its best, Valkyrie is an expert­ly assem­bled and tight­ly edit­ed nail-biter (the stag­ing of the attack is a dra­mat­ic mas­ter­class), although Singer is a lit­tle too wed­ded to the glossy sheen of his block­buster work. He’s a lit­tle too slick, a lit­tle too pol­ished and odd­ly coquet­tish. Hitler is approached oblique­ly; Singer’s vision of the Führer in his eyrie at Bercht­es­gaden sur­round­ed by his high com­mand lacks punch, like some­thing Edward Hop­per might have paint­ed if the Nazis had won the war.

And Cruise? Cruise is… Cruise. Com­mand­ing, focussed, ener­getic, pro­ject­ing a per­for­mance that man­ages – just – to get beyond the cos­tume that clothes but doesn’t con­fine him. There’s also a real fris­son in watch­ing him take a bul­let. Exact­ly why, though, is some­thing every­one will have their own answer for.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.