Discover the paranormal chills of this classic… | Little White Lies

Home Ents

Dis­cov­er the para­nor­mal chills of this clas­sic haunt­ed house horror

26 Jun 2017

Words by Anton Bitel

Bearded man in tan coat embracing a woman in a white coat, standing in front of an old house with autumn leaves on the ground.
Bearded man in tan coat embracing a woman in a white coat, standing in front of an old house with autumn leaves on the ground.
The Ami­tyville Hor­ror is one of the great 70s genre films.

Stu­art Rosenberg’s The Ami­tyville Hor­ror resides in a strange and ambigu­ous cor­ner of US his­to­ry. It was based on Jay Anson’s con­tro­ver­sial 1977 book of the same name, which in turn was drawn from the equal­ly con­tro­ver­sial expe­ri­ences of the Lutz fam­i­ly, who had by then become a cause célèbre in the media. Hav­ing fled their Long Island home only weeks after first mov­ing in, the Lutzes were regard­ed by some as sur­vivors of a para­nor­mal encounter, by oth­ers as vic­tims of their own dys­func­tion and delu­sion, and by yet oth­ers as manip­u­la­tive, atten­tion-hun­gry hoaxers.

It’s impos­si­ble to say where the truth lies, but that is not enough to pre­vent a good sto­ry being exploit­ed both for genre thrills and for a snap­shot of the fault lines in 70s Amer­i­ca. Despised by crit­ics but loved by cin­ema­go­ers, the film grossed over $86 mil­lion at the US box office.

Right from the start, the icon­ic appear­ance of the house at 112 Ocean Avenue – actu­al­ly a New Jer­sey home con­vert­ed to resem­ble the orig­i­nal after the film­mak­ers were refused per­mis­sion to shoot on loca­tion – comes to the fore, shown in an exte­ri­or wide shot with its two illu­mi­nat­ed attic win­dows serv­ing as the eyes for what is real­ly the film’s main char­ac­ter. Hous­es don’t have mem­o­ries,” George (James Brolin) assures his new bride Kath­leen (Mar­got Kid­der) as she frets about the mur­ders that took place there a year ear­li­er. Yet Robert Brown Jr’s edit­ing, vio­lent­ly inter­cut­ting present scenes in which the new­ly­weds view the house for the first time with past scenes of bru­tal slay­ings in those same rooms, sug­gests the con­trary: that this house echoes with its own bloody history.

I can’t get the sto­ry right,” says Sergeant Gion­frid­do (Val Avery), as he tries to get to the bot­tom of what is going on. He was the inves­ti­ga­tor on the scene after the DeFeo mur­ders of 1974, and now he has returned to the house after two of its doors were inex­plic­a­bly blown off their frame from inside the house. While he tries to ratio­nalise what is going on, his old friend Father Delaney (Rod Steiger), a priest but also a trained psy­chother­a­pist, has suf­fered one freak mishap after anoth­er since vis­it­ing the house to bless it.

The Lutzes too notice that some­thing is not right about the house. The tem­per­a­ture keeps drop­ping. Win­dows open and close by them­selves. Flies swarm out of sea­son. A black goo floods the toi­lets. Mon­ey goes miss­ing. The fam­i­ly dog digs obses­sive­ly at a base­ment wall. Strangers appear at the door – and then dis­ap­pear. A cross on the wall inverts. Amy (Natasha Ryan), Kathy’s young daugh­ter by a pre­vi­ous hus­band, acquires a new imag­i­nary friend, Jody, whose pres­ence Kathy her­self begins to sense. And as ill­ness (or worse) takes over, George, so lov­ing at the start, becomes dis­tract­ed, mean-tem­pered and even violent.

While San­dor Stern’s script cer­tain­ly nev­er shies away from the super­nat­ur­al, it comes deliri­ous­ly overde­ter­mined with addi­tion­al frames of inter­pre­ta­tion to sup­port its nar­ra­tive struc­ture. Delaney appears to be suf­fer­ing a demon­ic attack insti­gat­ed by the house, but it might just be a broad­er cri­sis of faith brought on by the col­lapse of reli­gion in a sec­u­lar age (the one time we see him preach­ing, it is to a con­spic­u­ous­ly emp­ty church), or even a men­tal break­down (“I believe we cre­ate our own demons in our minds,” he is told by a younger, more scep­ti­cal colleague).

Mean­while, George’s rugged beardy look places him some­where between the mas­cu­line ide­al of the 1970s and the unhinged appear­ance of Charles Man­son (in a film where much is made of George’s close facial resem­blance to a past psy­cho killer). It is of course not impos­si­ble that George becomes pos­sessed by what­ev­er bad juju there is in a house said to have been both the site of a Shin­necock trib­al expo­sure camp’ and of a Salem refugee’s Satan­ic rituals.

But it is also pos­si­ble – indeed it is made explic­it – that we are watch­ing a man being torn apart by finan­cial dif­fi­cul­ties, impo­tence and the emas­cu­lat­ing pres­sures of hav­ing to liv­ing with three chil­dren who are not his own. We cer­tain­ly see the para­nor­mal at work in the film, but its man­i­fes­ta­tion at one point as a lit­er­al fly­ing pig hints at its prover­bial implau­si­bil­i­ty as an expla­na­tion, cast­ing promi­nence instead on inter­pre­ta­tions of a more psy­cho­log­i­cal or soci­o­log­i­cal bent.

The Ami­tyville Hor­ror is also trapped between two pieces of cin­e­mat­ic hor­ror his­to­ry. It bears the obvi­ous imprint of William Friedkin’s The Exor­cist from 1973, as lit­tle Amy falls under the malign influ­ence of a friend­ly seem­ing spir­it that seeks the family’s ruin, and the Catholic church strug­gles to deter­mine its own posi­tion in the affair. Yet with Amy claim­ing that her play­mate Jody wants me to live here for­ev­er and ever”, and with George’s dete­ri­o­ra­tion into a dead-eyed bad dad (even at one point tak­ing an axe to the bath­room door where his fam­i­ly is hid­ing), it is clear that the film had its own influ­ence on Stan­ley Kubrick’s The Shin­ing, released the fol­low­ing year.

In truth, The Ami­tyville Hor­ror is not as good as either Friedkin’s or Kubrick’s film. Its pac­ing is off, there are too many go-nowhere sub­plots, and it seems just to come to a clunk­ing halt at the end with lit­tle real res­o­lu­tion. At the same time, the film’s lack of com­mit­ment to any sin­gle read­ing of its nar­ra­tive archi­tec­ture is pre­cise­ly, in the final analy­sis, what makes it so uncanny.

The Ami­tyville Hor­ror is released by Sec­ond Sight on Blu-ray in a Lim­it­ed Edi­tion Steel­book on 26 June.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.