Why are there no openly gay Premier League… | Little White Lies

Queer Cinema

Why are there no open­ly gay Pre­mier League footballers?

16 Mar 2016

Two shirtless men sitting on a hotel bed, one taking a photo using a smartphone.
Two shirtless men sitting on a hotel bed, one taking a photo using a smartphone.
BFI Flare’s open­ing film, The Pass, is about a promi­nent foot­baller who repress­es his sex­u­al­i­ty. We explore why this is still hap­pen­ing for real.

After Thomas The Ham­mer” Hit­zlsperg­er retired from play­ing Pre­mier League foot­ball in 2013, he came out as gay. In numer­ous inter­views giv­en after the announce­ment, he diplo­mat­i­cal­ly artic­u­lat­ed com­plex per­son­al rea­sons for stay­ing in the clos­et until his career was over. He was, how­ev­er, unequiv­o­cal in flag­ging that the word gay’ is still being used as a term of abuse among his col­leagues. They think that in pro­fes­sion­al foot­ball you have to be strong, pow­er­ful and they think that being gay means you aren’t that you’re the oppo­site – you’re soft, you don’t real­ly like to tack­le, you’re very weak… Why do peo­ple think that being gay also means that you’re weak? I think I proved the oppo­site,” Hit­zlsperg­er explained in an inter­view with SPOX.

We know that chil­dren – boys main­ly, as young as 10 – start to use homo­pho­bic lan­guage on the foot­ball pitch,” says Louise Engle­field, Direc­tor of Pride Sports and Foot­ball v Homo­pho­bia, an ini­tia­tive launched in 2010 with the aim of cre­at­ing a safer envi­ron­ment for LGBT indi­vid­u­als at grass­roots lev­el. If I’m deliv­er­ing train­ing in foot­ball, or in sport, I will list a load of homo­pho­bic slurs and put them up on the screen and say, Right, these are some of the things I’ve heard said on a foot­ball pitch, how many of you have heard these things said on a foot­ball pitch?’ I’ve nev­er encoun­tered a young per­son in the years that I’ve been work­ing in this area who said, none.’”

The Foot­ball Asso­ci­a­tion are the­o­ret­i­cal­ly plugged into the bat­tle against dis­crim­i­na­tion. Although it is debat­able how much pow­er they have to enforce their val­ues on the ground, their web­site has an equal­i­ty’ sec­tion full of encour­ag­ing sound­ing resources, cam­paigns and pol­i­cy infor­ma­tion. There is a tele­phone num­ber and email address specif­i­cal­ly for report­ing dis­crim­i­na­tion. The work by the FA, as the gov­ern­ing asso­ci­a­tion in charge, and the laws that they’ve put in place and the rules and reg­u­la­tions, have made great strides in cre­at­ing a more wel­com­ing atmos­phere. There’s things like zero tol­er­ance for any type of homo­pho­bic abuse in games,” says Ben Big­gs, the cur­rent Chair­man of Stonewall FC, a gay foot­ball club that turned 25 this year.

Big­gs says that it has been 10 years since any­one at Stonewall FC was sub­ject­ed to homo­pho­bic abuse and thinks that a Pre­mier League foot­baller or foot­ballers will come out with­in the next three years. Society’s ready for it. Everything’s there. I think the rea­son they haven’t [come out] is because when a play­er does even­tu­al­ly, it’s going to be such a huge thing and they’re not nec­es­sar­i­ly pre­pared and don’t want to be a poster child for that. They may just want to con­cen­trate on play­ing the football.”

Of course, top flight foot­ball is an inter­na­tion­al game. Inclu­sive val­ues in a home coun­try fade in sig­nif­i­cance as the glob­al stakes are raised. The 2018 World Cup will take place in Rus­sia and the 2022 World Cup in Qatar, two nations that don’t exact­ly boast pro­gres­sive atti­tudes towards LGBT rights. If actions speak loud­er than words, then the mes­sage FIFA sends to gay ath­letes is painful­ly clear. Not only don’t they have our backs, our lives don’t mat­ter,” observes a USA Today arti­cle by Rob­bie Rogers, an out gay foot­baller who plies his trade in the MLS for LA Galaxy. For any gay soc­cer play­er who has hopes of play­ing for the US Nation­al Team at the World Cup, being open about their sex­u­al­i­ty could have real con­se­quences when they set foot in coun­tries with laws that could land them in jail.”

Even Big­gs, whose approach toward author­i­ties is gen­er­ous, thinks that FIFA could being doing a lot more. He rec­ol­lects the dis­mis­sive response of pre­vi­ous FIFA despot, Sepp Blat­ter, to con­cerns about tak­ing the World Cup to Qatar, where being gay is ille­gal: I’d say [gay fans] should refrain from any sex­u­al activ­i­ties,” declared Blat­ter in 2010. Dis­crim­i­na­tion is incom­pat­i­ble with the very essence of sport and the uni­ver­sal val­ues inher­ent to it,” said a FIFA spokesper­son six years lat­er, and in response to our enquiries, We believe that the host­ing of the FIFA World Cup offers a great oppor­tu­ni­ty to say no to any form of dis­crim­i­na­tion and send a clear mes­sage to the world in this regards.”

It’s easy for those in posi­tions of pow­er to respond to grow­ing con­cerns about LGBT tol­er­ance by mak­ing agree­able com­ments attached to hyper­bol­ic emo­tion­al state­ments about football’s inher­ent glo­ri­ous­ness. But accord­ing to a 2014 inter­na­tion­al study into homo­pho­bia in sport enti­tled Out on the Fields’, foot­ball is not inher­ent­ly inclu­sive. Six­ty-two per cent of all par­tic­i­pants and 73 per cent of gay men believe that homo­pho­bia is more com­mon in team sports than in the rest of soci­ety in their coun­try. This posi­tion is sup­port­ed by Englefield’s anec­do­tal find­ings as she encoun­ters young peo­ple in her field work. There’s some­thing about sport, and the way that sport has been con­tract­ed to prize a kind of hero­ic mas­culin­i­ty which is essen­tial­ly het­ero­sex­u­al above all else, that encour­ages homophobia.”

For Engle­field, the solu­tion is clear: edu­ca­tion, edu­ca­tion, edu­ca­tion. More needs to be done gen­er­al­ly around edu­cat­ing young peo­ple. Foot­ball is an absolute­ly mas­sive sport. It’s com­plete­ly influ­en­tial. It’s in schools. It’s the largest sport in the UK and it needs to take some respon­si­bil­i­ty for the mes­sages that it deliv­ers to its par­tic­i­pants. It’s real­ly impor­tant to deliv­er mes­sages around sanc­tion­ing and rules but there’s also some­thing here about mak­ing the envi­ron­ment more inclu­sive, try­ing to edu­cate young peo­ple in foot­ball so that, when they come through, the next gen­er­a­tion of young peo­ple are think­ing before they speak, think­ing before they use the kind of lan­guage that makes les­bian, gay, bisex­u­al and trans­gen­der peo­ple feel real­ly unwel­come in the game. It’s an ongo­ing cam­paign, an ongo­ing issue, it needs some more invest­ment from the foot­ball author­i­ties. We know we’ve made some progress over the last ten years but it doesn’t just go away just because there are a few pos­i­tive head­lines. Lots of work needs to be done.”

To find out how you can take action to make foot­ball less homo­pho­bic vis­it foot​bal​lvho​mo​pho​bia​.com

The Pass plays at BFI Flare on Wednes­day 16 and Thur­day 17 March. Find out more at bfi​.org​.uk/​flare

You might like