A new documentary explores Scotland’s climate… | Little White Lies

A new doc­u­men­tary explores Scotland’s cli­mate cri­sis history

22 Sep 2021

Words by Katie Goh

Industrial landscape with cooling towers, chimneys, and people working on the ground.
Industrial landscape with cooling towers, chimneys, and people working on the ground.
With Liv­ing Proof: A Cli­mate Sto­ry, direc­tor Dr Emi­ly Munro hopes to inspire change by look­ing to the past.

There is no greater threat to us right now than the cli­mate cri­sis. With seas becom­ing more acidic, polar ice­caps melt­ing, wild­fires rag­ing and cor­po­ra­tions still pump­ing vast amounts of CO2 into the atmos­phere, we are at a cru­cial moment in human history.

His­tor­i­cal­ly, cin­e­ma has had a rocky rela­tion­ship with cli­mate change: it’s not the juici­est sub­ject mat­ter for Hol­ly­wood block­busters and eco doc­u­men­taries tend to inspire dread rather than direct action. But a new film, com­pris­ing archival footage span­ning from the 1940s to 80s, hopes that by look­ing to the past we’ll be able to imag­ine a more sus­tain­able future.

Liv­ing Proof: A Cli­mate Sto­ry, direct­ed by film­mak­er and archivist Dr Emi­ly Munro, explores Scotland’s his­toric rela­tion­ship to the envi­ron­ment, sparked by Glas­gow being the host city for the UN Cli­mate Con­fer­ence lat­er this year. It was a bit like get­ting in a time machine,” says Munro about research­ing the film in the Nation­al Library of Scotland’s archive. We’re look­ing at the nation’s col­lec­tive, if frag­ment­ed, mem­o­ry that’s record­ed on film.”

Oth­er than three artis­ti­cal­ly edit­ed, con­nec­tive mon­tages set to con­tem­po­rary music, Liv­ing Proof lets the archive do the talk­ing, stitch­ing togeth­er footage from over 80 films. It starts with wartime pro­pa­gan­da and cin­e­mat­ic dra­mas and then moves to bright, for­mal­ist, Tech­ni­col­or films from the 60s that are about the clean, mod­ern tech­nolo­gies of the future,” she explains. Then you get to the 70s and there’s anoth­er shift: big cor­po­rate films encour­ag­ing invest­ment from the US and Lon­don, as well as more con­tem­pla­tive work that’s influ­enced by labour and envi­ron­men­tal movements.”

Although Liv­ing Proof fol­lows a lin­ear chronol­o­gy, it depicts our con­cerns about cli­mate change as any­thing but for­ward-mov­ing. Films from across the 20th cen­tu­ry par­al­lel today’s dis­cus­sions around envi­ron­men­tal crises, like the made-for-tele­vi­sion doc­u­men­tary The Liv­ing Land, first broad­cast in 1977. The nar­ra­tion is so melan­choly and so rel­e­vant in terms of ask­ing whether we’ve reached our lim­it and whether the human species can real­ly com­pre­hend where we are in time,” says Munro. You watch that and think, What have we been doing all this time?’”

Munro’s film also demon­strates that the cam­era is very much a tool, and one that can be co opt­ed by cor­po­ra­tions’ pro­pa­gan­da. The oil com­pa­ny BP made a series of so-called envi­ron­men­tal films in the 70s,” the direc­tor explains. They’re fas­ci­nat­ing because they’re speak­ing to con­cerns of the time that oil was going to run out. They’re actu­al­ly real­ly ambi­tious pres­tige films that are very con­vinc­ing exam­ples of green­wash­ing, say­ing things like, Yes, the weather’s chang­ing, but that’s just because we have the tech­nol­o­gy to bet­ter under­stand it now,’ or, The prob­lem is pop­u­la­tion growth.’”

As Munro points out, cinema’s rela­tion­ship to the envi­ron­ment is some­thing that is rarely dis­cussed. We talk about adver­tis­ing with respect to cli­mate change, and we’ve start­ed talk­ing about the spon­sor­ship of artis­tic insti­tu­tions, like nation­al muse­ums by oil com­pa­nies, but with the film indus­try there’s a reluc­tance to tack­le cli­mate change or to say, We’re no longer going to take mon­ey from com­pa­nies like McDonald’s.’”

Despite begin­ning with footage from near­ly a cen­tu­ry ago, much of the footage in Liv­ing Proof is strik­ing­ly pre­scient. It’s a cau­tion­ary tale,” says Munro. We’re again expe­ri­enc­ing mul­ti­ple crises – envi­ron­men­tal as well the pan­dem­ic and con­flicts. Back in the 40s and 50s, Scot­land and Britain were com­ing out of two wars, a depres­sion and a pan­dem­ic, and our answer to that was a rapid pur­suit of pros­per­i­ty which dam­aged, not just the envi­ron­ment, but also people.”

As we teether on the precipice of our climate’s future, learn­ing from our mis­takes has nev­er been more vital. The whole project was about pre­sent­ing ques­tions,” explains Munro. Are we capa­ble of the change that’s required? And are we going to address the fun­da­men­tal struc­tur­al issues in our soci­ety that have led us to this point?”

Liv­ing Proof: A Cli­mate Sto­ry will have its world pre­mière at Take One Action. Find out more at takeone​ac​tion​.org​.uk

You might like