We need to talk about Indiana Jones and the… | Little White Lies

We need to talk about Indi­ana Jones and the Tem­ple of Doom…

20 Jun 2020

Words by Saffron Maeve

Intricate masks, bright red and gold, with fierce expressions.
Intricate masks, bright red and gold, with fierce expressions.
I loved Steven Spielberg’s film grow­ing up, but its offen­sive Indi­an stereo­types make it hard to watch today.

It’s a mug­gy after­noon in 2009 and I’m sprawled out on my couch rewatch­ing Raiders of the Lost Ark with my dad. I cov­er my eyes every time there’s a snake on screen and I laugh at all the right moments, even if I don’t under­stand the jokes. My child­hood was pep­pered with Indi­ana Jones marathons: pure, unadul­ter­at­ed, whip-crack­ing fun. But it took me a while to realise that the sec­ond film in the orig­i­nal tril­o­gy cared more to insult than entice me. This was dis­heart­en­ing to say the least.

From its very begin­ning, it is appar­ent that Indi­ana Jones and the Tem­ple of Doom is a film made by peo­ple who know very lit­tle about the cul­ture they are depict­ing. The trou­ble begins when Indy, Shorty and Willie Scott find them­selves in an impov­er­ished Indi­an vil­lage, con­ve­nient­ly in dire need of a sav­iour to retrieve their sacred stone.

This over­ar­ch­ing theme of white sav­iourism – which is an issue in and of itself– is quick­ly eclipsed by the fla­grant racism in per­haps the worst din­ner scene in movie his­to­ry. The trio make their way into the Pankot Palace, where they are served live baby snakes, bee­tles and eye­ball soup, fol­lowed by chilled mon­key brains for dessert (served straight from the ani­mals’ decap­i­tat­ed heads, no less).

The film mobilis­es its Indi­an char­ac­ters with child­like irre­spon­si­bil­i­ty, car­i­ca­tur­ing both cul­tur­al and reli­gious beliefs for cheap laughs. And as usu­al, Indi­ans are the punch­line. Lat­er in the film, the leader of the Thuggee cult, Mola Ram, per­forms human sac­ri­fice (as in, rip­ping out a man’s heart with his bare hands) for the Hin­du god of death. This entire sequence speaks to the film’s insu­lar­i­ty towards Indi­an cul­ture; cher­ry pick­ing the myths that cul­ti­vate the most dan­ger­ous and sav­age image pos­si­ble for the sake of fur­ther­ing its messy narrative.

There needs to be better education about the harmful racist tropes that have contributed significantly to Hollywoods long-standing Hinduphobic rhetoric.

Even more offen­sive than the racial­ly-charged aspects of Tem­ple of Doom, how­ev­er, is the gen­er­al dis­re­gard for cul­tur­al accu­ra­cy. It should be not­ed that the Indi­an gov­ern­ment raised their con­cerns over the script, deem­ing it offen­sive”. Instead of fix­ing or even ton­ing down the more insult­ing aspects of the sto­ry, the pro­duc­tion sim­ply shift­ed to Sri Lan­ka. This duplic­i­tous move cost the film noth­ing in terms of box office num­bers; West­ern audi­ences ate it up like so many Indi­ans appar­ent­ly chow down mon­key brains. They sim­ply did not care about the racial impli­ca­tions, and most like­ly believed it to be true.

Indi­ans and non-Indi­an South Asians have been repeat­ed­ly mocked and dis­crim­i­nat­ed against through­out cin­e­ma his­to­ry. Think of Peter Sell­ers’ brown­face and lam­poon-ish antics in The Par­ty and The Mil­lion­airess (two for one!), or Shirley MacLaine play­ing an Indi­an princess in Around the World in 80 Days. While Hol­ly­wood chose to devote no space to actu­al Indi­an actors, Indi­an cul­ture nev­er escaped scruti­ny on screen. Even when it became less fash­ion­able for stu­dios to hire white actors to play peo­ple of colour, the same neg­a­tive con­no­ta­tions sur­round­ing them per­sist­ed. Tem­ple of Doom is mere­ly symp­to­matic of a much deep­er Hol­ly­wood issue: South Asians are sel­dom grant­ed screen time, and when we are, we prob­a­bly wouldn’t want it.

The issue with Steven Spielberg’s film in par­tic­u­lar is that it remains a cult clas­sic to this day. Some sin­cere­ly rev­el in the film’s aggres­sive­ly campy gore while oth­ers just tol­er­ate it for the sake of Indy’s hero­ic stunts. While Spiel­berg has acknowl­edged Tem­ple of Doom to be the black sheep of the fran­chise, it is sand­wiched between two beloved clas­sics: Raiders of the Lost Ark and The Last Cru­sade. Accord­ing­ly, it is not uncom­mon for the entire series to be praised and the wrong­do­ings of the racist mid­dle child to be absolved. We can still enjoy these films, but there needs to be bet­ter edu­ca­tion about the harm­ful tropes that have con­tributed sig­nif­i­cant­ly to Hollywood’s long-stand­ing Hindu­pho­bic rhetoric.

Indi­ans deserve to be rep­re­sent­ed on screen with the com­plex­i­ty that we pos­sess, not the uni­di­men­sion­al­i­ty that is thrust upon us. It’s Dopin­der in Dead­pool. It’s Hank Azaria voic­ing Apu in The Simp­sons. It’s me being able to list all of the pos­i­tive tele­vised depic­tions of Indi­ans on one hand. While Hol­ly­wood is creep­ing towards becom­ing a more promis­ing avenue for peo­ple of colour, sin­cere South Asian rep­re­sen­ta­tion can only become a real­i­ty once we unearth the harsh prej­u­dices embed­ded with­in the movies we know and love.

You might like