The transportive beauty of modern magical realism | Little White Lies

The trans­portive beau­ty of mod­ern mag­i­cal realism

14 Nov 2024

Young person wearing a black hooded jacket, looking down with a contemplative expression, against a background of stylised black flowers.
Young person wearing a black hooded jacket, looking down with a contemplative expression, against a background of stylised black flowers.
In two of 2024’s best films – Bird and On Becom­ing A Guinea Fowl – real­i­ty blurs with fan­ta­sy when the world becomes too cru­el to stand.

In mag­i­cal real­ist fam­i­lies, real­i­ty flick­ers. For as long as I can remem­ber, cer­tain rel­a­tives car­ried a fre­net­ic charge, punc­tu­at­ing the usu­al banal­i­ties of the con­ver­sa­tions of fam­i­ly get-togeth­ers with warn­ings and pre­mo­ni­tions or news from beyond. Our dead weren’t else­where (up above, down below, or wher­ev­er their cor­po­ral forms lay), but all around us, all the time – the spi­der that lives on your win­dowsill, the but­ter­fly that lands on your hand, the angel­ic form sit­ting on your aunt’s sofa you’re told not to crowd. All sym­bols become man­i­fest as the bound­aries are blurred between liv­ing and dead, past and present and real and imag­ined – sig­ni­fy­ing the work of col­lec­tive pro­cess­ing span­ning generations.

Of course, much before mag­i­cal real­ism was canon­ised in artis­tic forms, cul­tures the world over have always been involved in their own myth­mak­ing in this way. But the lan­guage of mag­i­cal real­ism was at first pop­u­larised as a lit­er­ary genre to process the con­flict-torn Latin Amer­i­ca of the 1940s – by look­ing ahead to two upcom­ing exam­ples, Andrea Arnold’s Eng­land-set Bird and Rungano Nyoni’s Zam­bia-set On Becom­ing A Guinea Fowl, it’s now clear that mag­i­cal real­ism in art has since tak­en flight and gone global.

The mag­ic real­ist frame­work offers up an alter­nate sys­tem of real­i­ty that maps onto our exist­ing one with­out dis­plac­ing it – it treats mag­ic as part of every­day life, accept­ed with­out ques­tion by its characters.

Gabriel Gar­cia Mar­quez – the Colom­bian writer inar­guably the most syn­ony­mous with the genre – believed that it was the gaze of the colonis­er which makes the real­i­ty of the colonised unbe­liev­able or fan­tas­ti­cal. This genre, then, along with plat­form­ing mar­gin­alised per­spec­tives, also chal­lenges sta­tus quo ideas around knowledge.

Mag­ic realism’s mer­its as a folk­loric – and polit­i­cal – tool are often under­sung or mis­un­der­stood as fan­ta­sy; but in blend­ing the real with the mag­i­cal, films like Bird and On Becom­ing A Guinea Fowl defa­mil­iarise the every­day and ren­der the extra­or­di­nary pos­si­ble, invit­ing their char­ac­ters (and their audi­ences) to view their world through a dif­fer­ent lens.

In doing so, mag­i­cal realism’s unique val­ue is its abil­i­ty to hold up a mir­ror to our world, urg­ing us to ques­tion what we accept as real. In a con­tem­po­rary cul­tur­al ter­rain where pol­i­tics and media serve us uncer­tain truths all the time, mag­i­cal real­ism ges­tures towards the very real dan­gers of tac­it accep­tance and asks us to look again.

The first time we see Franz Rogawl­s­ki as Bird, it feels like a dream. It’s ear­ly morn­ing when Bai­ley (played by superb first-time actor Nykiya Adams) awakes in a field in Kent, hav­ing hid­den there after a teenage vig­i­lante act gone awry. It’s bucol­ic if not for the pow­er lines flank­ing the edges. Bird is warm; Bai­ley is shak­en. She is dis­trust­ful of peo­ple in gen­er­al and, par­tic­u­lar­ly of odd strangers like Bird enjoy­ing the sim­ple plea­sure of the morn­ing light. Bai­ley pulls out her phone to film Bird osten­si­bly for her safe­ty, but it’s almost as if the record­ing will some­how cor­rob­o­rate the exis­tence of the preter­nat­ur­al fig­ure mov­ing towards her.

Heavily-jewelled headdress worn by a person with dark sunglasses and a black outfit, set against a dimly lit background.

Bai­ley lives with her sin­gle dad Bug (Bar­ry Keoghan), in a colour­ful­ly worn-down squat, where his pre­oc­cu­pa­tions side­line Bai­ley as she tries to gain a safe foothold of her own in an adult world, forced in between her father’s new fiancée or her mum’s (Jas­mine Job­son) vio­lent­ly misog­y­nist boyfriend.

There’s a lot of change afoot for them through­out: whether it’s Bai­ley get­ting her first peri­od and exper­i­ment­ing with eye­lin­er, or even Bug’s attempt to har­ness the intox­i­cat­ing pow­ers of a poi­so­nous (and expen­sive) toad he’s acquired. Bird, for his part, is look­ing for his estranged father. Bird takes her under his wing, so to speak, although the reci­procity between them speaks to a com­mon under­stand­ing of what it feels like to grow and change, while alone and unseen.

Amongst Arnold’s oeu­vre, the film bears many of the same touch­stones of the social-real­ist milieus in which we usu­al­ly find her char­ac­ters. But here in Bird, the film’s ideas around belong­ing and iden­ti­ty take on a dif­fer­ent form as Arnold turns to mag­i­cal real­ism for the first time. In an intense third-act moment of pro­tec­tion, Bird trans­forms into some­thing resem­bling his name­sake. It’s a beau­ti­ful and messy turn that leaps out of the nat­u­ral­ism we’ve seen up until that moment; besides the injec­tion of just-alright CGI, the height­ened flut­ter of un-real­i­ty allows us to expe­ri­ence a pro­fun­di­ty of feel­ing oth­er­wise dif­fi­cult to grasp through real­ism alone.

From one bird to anoth­er, On Becom­ing A Guinea Fowl also jumps the par­ti­tion of real­ism to arrive at its own emo­tion­al truth. Shu­la (Susan Chardy) is home for her Uncle’s funer­al, join­ing the group of women tasked with funer­al prepa­ra­tions along­side their expect­ed per­for­mance of rit­u­alised grief and mourn­ing. The scars of sex­u­al abuse at the hands of the new­ly deceased begin to chafe, and Shula’s grow­ing under­stand­ing com­pels her to find her voice so that the same pat­tern doesn’t repeat itself. Alas, it’s eas­i­er said than done giv­en the (in this case, gen­er­a­tional) impasse around com­plic­it silence.

The guinea fowl is use­ful to all the ani­mals in the ani­mal king­dom, we learn, as it rings the alarm to sig­nal dan­ger for every­one. As Shu­la chips away at the cul­tur­al mores that have led to the bur­den of secre­cy, the film’s tri­umphant final moments show Shu­la trans­formed – sound­ing the hope­ful death knell for repressed col­lec­tive trau­ma and its con­comi­tant grief.

Both Bird and On Becom­ing A Guinea Fowl present an emo­tion­al over­flow that can’t be addressed head-on, and in each instance, mag­i­cal real­ism does the leg­work to help us weath­er and process what feels unspeak­able. The genre seeks to wedge a door open in accept­ed ratio­nal­i­ty’, empha­sis­ing instead the valid­i­ty and uni­ver­sal val­ue found in indi­vid­ual or cul­tur­al mem­o­ry and experience.

There was a time on X (Twit­ter) last year when I was briefly obsessed with a now-defunct Mag­i­cal Real­ism bot that spit out a fresh log­line every four hours: At the stroke of mid­night a giant tiger ris­es from the Mediter­ranean sea.” An ancient Roman girl appears on a New York sub­way sta­tion plat­form, and laughs.” Con­sid­er­ing our culture’s vexed rela­tion­ship with truth, is it any sur­prise that we’re ever more drawn to a genre that com­bines real­i­ty with a lit­tle bit of mag­ic? Mag­i­cal real­ism can offer laugh­ter, heal­ing and new modes of know­ing in a con­found­ing world; to recite a well-worn Emi­ly Dick­in­son quote in the 11th hour: Hope is the thing with feathers.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.